Trader Joe’s Fall 2025 Haul: The Ultimate Ranking of Pumpkin, Apple, and Maple Obsessions – Fans Are Losing It!

Trader Joe’s fall 2025 lineup is here, packed with pumpkin spice, apple cider, and maple-inspired favorites.

We’ve rounded up 12 must-try items based on expert reviews, employee picks, and taste tests.

From snacks to desserts, these seasonal finds deliver big flavor and value. Availability and prices vary, so grab them quickly!

Teeny Tiny Apple Pies – $5.49/7.76 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Bite-sized pies with flaky crusts and spiced apple filling; perfect solo or with ice cream, delivering gooey sweetness without being too heavy.

• Ranking: Top-tier fall dessert for nostalgic charm and shareable size.

• Fan Feedback: Fans admit to devouring entire boxes; non-pumpkin lovers call it their new fall go-to.

Maple Leaf Ice Cream Sandwiches – $3.99/12.17 Fl Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Maple cookies sandwiching creamy maple ice cream; soft, mess-free, with pancake-like sweetness and a crunchy-creamy balance.

• Ranking: Standout for thematic charm and crowd-pleasing flavor; employee favorite.

• Fan Feedback: Shoppers call it a “Canadian-inspired delight”; predicted to sell out fast for parties.

Apple Cider Donuts – $4.99/15.9 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Cinnamon-sugar coated, cake-like donuts with mild cider flavor; dense and addictive when fresh, best microwaved if stale.

• Ranking: Seasonal staple, praised for breaking the pumpkin monotony.

• Fan Feedback: Coffee-pairing fans love the morning ritual vibe; a hit for its nostalgic crunch.

Pumpkin-Flavored Joe-Joe’s – $2.99/10.5 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Oreo-style cookies with pumpkin-spice icing; ginger and clove shine in a light, soft bite that’s authentically fall.

• Ranking: High marks for spiced flavor and enjoyable chew.

• Fan Feedback: Lunchbox favorite; fans love the non-gimmicky spice twist.

Sliced Apple Cinnamon Sourdough Bread – $4.99/17.63 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Pre-sliced sourdough with apple chunks and cinnamon swirls; toasts to chewy, savory perfection for grilled cheese or French toast.

• Ranking: Top savory pick for cozy fall meals; outshines cinnamon raisin.

• Fan Feedback: Shoppers suggest cheddar melts; praised for balanced fruitiness.

Salted Maple Cold Foam Creamer – $4.49/15 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Nozzle-dispensed creamer like a maple-flavored cloud; subtle salt cuts sweetness, ideal for lattes or dessert toppings.

  You May Be Interested In

  

  Rated Trader Joe’s New Find from March 2026—Worth It or Waste Your Money?

  

  Costco’s March Madness: The Ultimate Taste Test & Review Guide

• Ranking: Morning routine must-have; versatile for baking.

• Fan Feedback: Coffee lovers call it a game-changer; fans excited for drink and dessert uses.

This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar Cereal Bars – $2.49/7.8 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Chewy oat bars with gooey pumpkin filling; spiced with ginger, cinnamon, and nutmeg for a fresh, portable snack.

• Ranking: Surpasses expectations for cereal bars with balanced spice.

• Fan Feedback: Shoppers repurchase for midday fuel; appreciated for chewy texture.

Butternut Squash Mac & Cheese Bites – $3.99/10 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Frozen bites with squash puree, three-cheese bechamel, rigatoni, and sage; rich, cheesy comfort with herbal balance.

• Ranking: Decadent fall twist on mac, loved for sophistication.

• Fan Feedback: Yearly fan favorite; praised for light veggie depth.

Pumpkin Spice Mini Sheet Cake – $5.99/18 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: 18-oz cake with pumpkin purée, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, and cream cheese icing; moist, nostalgic, and shareable.

• Ranking: Cult-favorite dessert; top pick for value and flavor.

• Fan Feedback: Shoppers hoard multiples; even pumpkin skeptics are obsessed.

Savory Squash Pastry Bites – $5.49/9 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Frozen pumpkin and butternut squash bites in pastry; bakes in 12 minutes for bold fall flavor.

• Ranking: High-demand returnee for easy appetizers.

• Fan Feedback: Fans eagerly await restocks; loved for party-ready convenience.

Glazed Pumpkin Pie Spice Donut Holes – $3.49/6 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Mini glazed donuts bursting with pumpkin pie spice; perfect snacking size with warm pastry vibes.

• Ranking: Kid-friendly hit for portion and flavor balance.

• Fan Feedback: Party pick; fans eye it for fall gatherings.

Maple Brown Butter Almonds – $3.99/8 Oz

• Description & Taste Test: Almonds coated in maple brown butter, dusted with cocoa and maple sugar; pancake-like aroma with sweet, nutty crunch.

• Ranking: Snack bowl star; employee hype for aroma.

• Fan Feedback: Tasters gush over scent; predicted to dominate fall snacking.