The Ultimate Trader Joe’s Holiday Taste Test 2025: 25 Trending Must-Haves

We’ve rounded up this season’s most talked-about Trader Joe’s holiday foods—then taste-tested them ourselves so you don’t waste a trip or your budget.

From savory bites to festive sweets, here’s the real verdict on what’s delicious, what’s divisive, and what deserves a spot in your cart.

Savory Bites & Holiday Appetizers

Mini Fillet Mignon & En Croute – $9.99/10 Oz

• The Takeaway: A fancy, impressive appetizer that looks like a miniature Beef Wellington.

• The Hot Topic: Redditors note that while the beef is tender, the filling is heavy on the mushroom duxelles, which is divisive. Some reviewers found the seasoning a bit mild and highly recommend dipping it (like in the Garlic Spread Dip).

• Best Served: Air-fried for maximum puff and crispiness. Great for a sophisticated gathering.

Spicy Cheddar Cheese & Jalapeño Biscuit Bites – $4.99/9.52 Oz

• The Takeaway: A unique, savory cookie-like biscuit with a distinct flavor.

• The Hot Topic: The overwhelming feedback is that these are too dry. The jalapeño flavor is prominent, but the spice level is low. Reviewers are confused about their purpose—not quite a side dish, not quite a snack.

• Pairing Suggestion: Dip in sour cream, hot honey, or use as a base for a mini ham slider.

Garlic & Herb Butter Mussels – $5.99/6.35 Oz

• The Takeaway: A massive, surprisingly delightful win! Even for first-time mussel eaters.

• The Highlight: The garlic and herb butter sauce is the star, making the dish rich and forgiving. Many reviewers praised how easy they are to prepare and the excellent flavor.

• Preparation Tip: Cook on the stovetop (in a pan with a lid) instead of the oven to keep the buttery sauce from melting away onto the baking sheet.

Pasta Festiva (Red & Green Cheese & Pesto Ravioli) – $3.99/9 Oz

• The Takeaway: A vibrant, festive-looking pasta that’s a good base, but not a showstopper on its own.

• The Highlight: The bright red and green colors make it instantly Instagrammable. The cheese filling is plentiful, and the pesto flavor is subtle, not overpowering.

• Must-Do: Do not eat plain. Toss with olive oil, Parmesan, or your favorite red sauce immediately.

Filipino Style Chicken Adobo – $4.29/10.2 Oz

• The Takeaway: Generally considered “mid” or a miss by many social media taste testers.

• The Flavor Profile: It’s described as having a slight, gentle sweetness but lacking the traditional bold, garlicky, and vinegary tang expected of Adobo. The dark meat chicken was also a turn-off for some.

• Verdict: Good as a quick, light lunch (low in calories), but not a rich, satisfying main course.

Bird’s Eye Chili Hot Sauce (New!) – $2.99/4.22 Oz

• The Takeaway: A surprisingly potent and flavorful hot sauce for chili-heads.

• The Heat Meter: This is genuinely hot—often ranked just below the Habanero sauce.

• The Quirks: Reviewers noted the unusual presence of actual chili seeds within the sauce, giving it an unexpected texture. It has a great, vinegary flavor that balances the heat.

Cranberry Orange Spinach Salad Kit – $3.99/9 Oz

• The Takeaway: A surprisingly refreshing and well-balanced seasonal side.

• The Star Component: The Tangy Orange Dressing ties the whole salad together, pairing perfectly with the sweet cranberries and crunchy honey-roasted pecans.

• Substitution Note: The kit includes blue cheese crumbles, but you can easily omit them if you’re not a fan, and the salad still works wonderfully.

Sweet Treats & Desserts

Peppermint Brookie – $4.99/10.5 Oz

• The Takeaway: A legendary, highly addictive holiday item that sells out fast.

• The Flavor: A fudgy brownie base topped with peppermint-flavored sugar cookie batter and white chocolate chips. The flavor is intensely pepperminty (like a mint candy, not subtle).

• Rating: A must-buy for anyone who loves the Peppermint Bark/Hold the Cone flavor profile.

Pistachio Baklava – $9.99/16 Oz

• The Takeaway: A sophisticated, decadent dessert that requires a fork and a napkin.

• The Experience: Very flaky phyllo dough layered with crushed pistachios and soaked in a sweet Turkish syrup. The packaging (in its own metal tin) makes it look incredibly high-end and gift-worthy.

• Taste Note: The syrupy sweetness is very strong; some reviewers likened the glazed flavor to a Krispy Kreme donut. Best served with black coffee or tea.

Chocolate Mascarpone – $3.99/8 Oz

• The Takeaway: A light, fluffy, and versatile chocolate treat.

• The Texture: Much lighter and airier than expected—like a thick chocolate mousse or whipped cream. It’s a great no-bake dessert base.

• Best Uses: Use it as a dip for strawberries, a filling for cannolis or tarts, or simply eat it by the spoonful as a richer chocolate pudding replacement.

Panettone & Chocolate Gelato – $4.49/1 Pint

• The Takeaway: A unique, European-inspired frozen dessert perfect for a holiday centerpiece.

• The Key Ingredient: The gelato is swirled with pieces of Panettone, a sweet Italian Christmas bread often studded with candied citrus peel, giving it a chewy texture.

• Flavor Profile: Sweet, rich chocolate ice cream with bursts of candied citrus and soft, bread-like chunks.

Cinnamon Sugar Waffles – $2.99/10.7 Oz

• The Takeaway: A simple but effective way to elevate breakfast.

• The Versatility: Great straight from the toaster for a hint of cinnamon roll flavor. Many reviewers noted these make an excellent ice cream sandwich base.

• Tip: If you love a lot of sugar, you’ll still want syrup, as the sugar crystals are a subtle rather than dominant flavor.

Trending Seasonal Staples & Gifts

Danish Gingerbread Snaps (New 2025 Packaging) – $3.49/8.81 Oz

• The Takeaway: A traditional Brunkager (brown cake) style cookie—very thin, crispy, and highly spiced with cinnamon, ginger, and black pepper.

• Why They’re Trending: They come in a collectible, gift-wrapped blue holiday tub and are accidentally vegan. Great for using in pie crusts!

Chocolate Peppermint Loaf – $4.49/19 Oz

• The Takeaway: The pre-made version of the classic holiday flavor. Fans love how dense and moist it is, topped with thick white frosting.

• Tip: Slice and warm it up slightly for a decadent dessert.

Peppermint Pretzel Slims – $3.49/6 Oz

• The Takeaway: The perfect trifecta of sweet, salty, and minty. These are incredibly popular and often the first seasonal snack to sell out.

• Review Note: The coating is a white confectionary (often called “yogurt-flavored”) with crunchy peppermint pieces.

Cranberry Orange Dip – $3.99/7.5 Oz

• The Takeaway: Described as a whipped, sweet-tart pink cloud of ricotta and cream cheese with tangy cranberry and orange zest.

• The Versatility: Reviewers enjoy this as a dip for graham crackers, gingersnaps, or even as a spread on bagels. It toes the line perfectly between sweet and savory.

Sparkling Cranberry Ginger Brew – $4.99/8.45 Fl Oz

• The Takeaway: A festive mixer or a powerful non-alcoholic beverage.

• Flavor Profile: Known for having a bold, zesty ginger kick balanced by the tart cranberry flavor. Perfect for making holiday mocktails or enhancing a Moscow Mule.

Hot Cocoa Cookie Waffles (New) –  $4.49/11.29 Oz

• The Takeaway: A new seasonal twist on the viral Cookie Butter product line.

• Anticipated Flavor: A stroopwafel-style cookie sandwich with a rich hot cocoa/chocolate and likely a hint of marshmallow flavor in the filling.

Coastal Cheddar Cheese with Truffle – $4.99/5.29 Oz

• The Takeaway: A great value cheese that brings an earthy, funky truffle flavor to the party.

• Review Note: It’s an extroverted cheese—the truffle flavor is definitely present and infuses the sharp white cheddar. Great addition to any holiday charcuterie board.

Gingerbread Dude Cookie – $2.99/4.25 Oz

• The Takeaway: A simple, sweet, and comforting classic.

• The Experience: A giant, soft-baked gingerbread man cookie. A fun, low-cost item for a quick sugar fix.

English Cheddar Cheese with Champagne (New) – $11.99/1 Lb

• The Takeaway: An intriguing, high-end cheese that adds a unique texture to the lineup.

• Flavor Profile: A dense English cheddar infused with Champagne. The process mimics a Pop-Rock crispness, creating a nutty-fruity flavor and a subtle fizzy feel.

Holiday Scented Candle Tin Trio – $8.99/9 Oz

• The Takeaway: A hugely popular gift item. The trio typically features scents like Cinnamon Pinecone, Foraged Cassis, and Noble Fir.

• Review Note: The large Cedar Balsam and Candy Cane candles also trend, but the trio offers the best variety for a gift.

Dark Chocolate Covered Peppermint Cremes –  $5.99/7 Oz

• The Takeaway: A returning seasonal favorite with a slightly new look and a price increase this year.

• The Appeal: A classic chocolate-peppermint combination with a smooth, fondant-like center.

Advent Calendar for Pets (Cat & Dog) – $7.99

• The Takeaway: The calendars have been updated this year based on customer feedback. The cat version now features freeze-dried salmon & sweet potato treats.

• Review Note: The new cat treats have a lighter, spongy, paw-print texture and are a big hit with previously picky felines.

Trio of Flavored Honey (Lemon, Lavender, Ginger) – $10.99/24 Oz

• The Takeaway: A popular gift set for the pantry. Excellent for tea or charcuterie.

• The Use: The Lemon is great for tea or sauces, the Ginger for marinades, and the Lavender is perfect for drizzling over goat cheese or Greek yogurt.