Secrets Spilled: The Best and Worst of Trader Joe’s Frozen Pizzas!

We’ve conducted an extensive deep dive into customer feedback and flavor profiles to determine which Trader Joe’s pizzas are freezer legends and which are total flops.

From crispy deep-fried crusts to soggy disappointments, here is the definitive ranking.

Tarte aux Champignons – $4.79

• Description: A French-style flatbread featuring a flaky, puff-pastry-like crust topped with mushrooms, emmental cheese, and a light buttery sauce.

• Taste Test: Deeply earthy and sophisticated; the mushrooms are tender and the crust shatters like a high-end bakery croissant.

• Rating: 10/10

• Verdict: BUY (The gold standard of the TJ’s freezer aisle).

Tarte d’Alsace – $5.49/8 Oz

• Description: An Alsatian flatbread with a thin pastry crust, crème fraîche, ham, caramelized onions, and Gruyère cheese.

• Taste Test: A perfect balance of salty and sweet; the sweetness of the onions cuts through the rich ham and cheese effortlessly.

• Rating: 9.5/10

• Verdict: BUY (Tastes like it came from a French bistro).

Roasted Garlic & Pesto Pizza with Deep Fried Crust – $5.99

• Description: A unique pizza with a “deep-fried” style dough, topped with basil pesto and generous amounts of roasted garlic.

• Taste Test: The crust is the star—chewy, doughy, and incredibly crispy; however, be warned that it is a massive garlic “salt bomb.”

• Rating: 9/10

• Verdict: BUY (Keep some mints handy for afterward).

Pizza Bianca (New for 2026) – $4.99

• Description: A white pizza with Parmesan cheese sauce, mozzarella, sharp Parmesan, sliced red onion, and fresh rosemary.

• Taste Test: Savory and cozy; the rosemary is the dominant flavor, giving it an elevated, wood-fired vibe that feels artisanal.

• Rating: 9/10

• Verdict: BUY (Drizzle with TJ’s Hot Honey to take it to another level).

Uncured Pepperoni Pizza (Wood-Fired) – $5.99

• Description: A classic pepperoni pizza featuring a crust charred in a wood-fired oven for a smoky finish.

• Taste Test: The pepperonis are high quality and crisp up at the edges; the sauce has a bright, acidic zing that balances the fat.

• Rating: 8.5/10

• Verdict: BUY (The most reliable “classic” pizza in the store).

BBQ Chicken Pizza – $5.49

• Description: Topped with BBQ sauce, chicken, red onions, cilantro, and a blend of mozzarella and smoked Gouda.

• Taste Test: Frequently cited as better than major chain restaurant versions; the Gouda adds a lovely smoky depth that isn’t too sweet.

• Rating: 8.5/10

• Verdict: BUY.

Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza with Cauliflower Crust – $5.49

• Description: A wheat-free alternative with a cauliflower-based crust and herb-seasoned cheese blend.

• Taste Test: Surprisingly crispy and savory; many Redditors note they prefer this over the standard wheat cheese pizza because of the seasoning.

• Rating: 8/10

• Verdict: BUY (Even if you aren’t gluten-free).

Pizza Parlanno – $4.99

• Description: The “Supreme” of the TJ’s world, featuring Italian sausage, pepperoni, roasted peppers, and onions.

• Taste Test: A heavy, nostalgic pizza that satisfies a big appetite; the meat-to-veggie ratio is very generous.

• Rating: 8/10

• Verdict: BUY.

Shrimp & Garlic Flatbread – $5.99/7.04 Oz

• Description: A frozen flatbread topped with small shrimp, garlic, herbs, and a tangy sauce.

• Taste Test: Bright and punchy; the shrimp actually stay tender if cooked according to the box instructions.

• Rating: 7.5/10

• Verdict: BUY (Great as a quick, fancy appetizer).

Pizza Margherita – $4.79

• Description: A simple, authentic Italian-style pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and a few basil leaves.

• Taste Test: Clean flavors with a thin crust, though social media users frequently complain it needs more basil and salt.

• Rating: 7/10

  You May Be Interested In

  

  10 NEW Trader Joe's Finds You NEED To Buy Right Now!

  

  New at Costco: What’s Worth Buying (and What to Skip) – April 2026

• Verdict: BUY (Best used as a base for your own extra toppings).

---

Organic Roasted Vegetable Pizza – $4.99

• Description: Loaded with eggplant, zucchini, peppers, and onions on an organic wheat crust.

• Taste Test: The vegetables are flavorful, but the moisture from the produce can make the center of the crust a bit soggy.

• Rating: 6.5/10

• Verdict: BUY (Pro tip: Bake it directly on the oven rack, not a pan).

Bambino Pepperoni Pizzas – $4.49

• Description: A box of four mini personal-sized pepperoni pizzas.

• Taste Test: A favorite for kids; the crust is quite thick and bready, which can overwhelm the sauce and toppings.

• Rating: 6/10

• Verdict: BUY (Keep these on hand for quick snacks).

Pizza 4 Formaggi – $4.99/13.4 Oz

• Description: A standard four-cheese blend on a thin, round crust.

• Taste Test: It’s a solid pizza, but lacks any “wow” factor or unique flavor compared to cheaper generic brands.

• Rating: 6/10

• Verdict: SKIP (The Margherita or Bianca are better options).

Mushroom & Black Truffle Flatbread – $5.49/9 Oz

• Description: An earthy flatbread topped with mushroom purée and black truffle oil.

• Taste Test: Highly polarizing; truffle lovers adore it, but others find the smell and taste to be “chemical” or “perfumed.”

• Rating: 5.5/10

• Verdict: SKIP (Unless you specifically seek out truffle-flavored items).

Organic 3 Cheese Pizza – $4.59/13.4 Oz

• Description: A basic rectangular organic cheese pizza with a thin crust.

• Taste Test: Frequently described on Facebook groups as “cardboard-like”; the sauce is a bit bland and the cheese doesn’t melt well.

• Rating: 5/10

• Verdict: SKIP (Too many better options nearby).

Spizzico di Pizza – $8.95/9 Oz

• Description: Tiny “nibble” sized pizza discs sold in a multi-pack.

• Taste Test: Mostly crust with a tiny, often dried-out dollop of sauce in the middle; not very satisfying.

• Rating: 4/10

• Verdict: SKIP (Buy the Bambinos for a better mini-pizza experience).

Vegan Meatless Meat Eater’s Pizza – $5.99/11.95 Oz

• Description: A vegan pizza topped with plant-based pepperoni and sausage crumbles.

• Taste Test: While the vegan meats are impressive, the vegan cheese has a “gummy” texture that sticks to the roof of your mouth.

• Rating: 4/10

• Verdict: SKIP (The crust is good, but the cheese lets it down).

Cauliflower Pizza (Veggie Topped) – $4.99

• Description: A cauliflower-crust pizza topped with roasted vegetables and cheese.

• Taste Test: Unlike the cheese-only version, this one often stays “mushy” and never quite crisps up in the oven.

• Rating: 3/10

• Verdict: SKIP.

Gluten-Free Pepperoni Pizza (Rice Flour Crust) – $5.99

• Description: A gluten-free pepperoni pizza made with a rice-flour-based dough.

• Taste Test: Social media consensus is that this crust is “gritty” and “unpleasantly dry” compared to the cauliflower GF option.

• Rating: 3/10

• Verdict: SKIP.

Frozen BBQ Chicken (Standard Recipe) – $5.49/13 Oz

• Description: The non-Gouda, standard BBQ chicken pizza found in some regions.

• Taste Test: Often criticized on YouTube reviews for “rubbery” chicken and a sauce that is cloyingly sweet like syrup.

• Rating: 2/10

• Verdict: SKIP (Always look for the “Smoked Gouda” version instead).