Canned goods can be a pantry lifesaver—affordable, long-lasting, and ready when you are. But not all canned foods are created equal, and some fall flat on taste, texture, or quality. If you’re stocking up at Sam’s Club, be selective. These 12 Member’s Mark canned items might look like a deal, but based on customer reviews and taste tests, they’re better left on the shelf.
1. Member’s Mark Cut Green Beans $7.78/12 x 14.5 oz
Classic green beans, steam-cooked and packed in water. Often described as mushy and flavorless, these beans lack the crisp freshness that even canned versions from competitors manage to retain.
2. Member’s Mark Solid White Albacore Tuna in Water $13.98/8 x 5 oz
Premium albacore packed in water with no artificial preservatives.
Customers report a dry, fibrous texture and overly “fishy” aroma that doesn’t compare well to name-brand alternatives.
3. Member’s Mark Diced Tomatoes in Juice $9.48/12 x 14.5 oz
Vine-ripened tomatoes diced and packed in tomato juice.
While convenient, the tomatoes can taste overly acidic and watery, making sauces thinner than desired.
4. Member’s Mark Crushed Tomatoes in Tomato Puree $5.98/105 oz
A base for pasta sauces and soups, made with ripe crushed tomatoes.
Lacks depth and richness—many users say they need to doctor it heavily just to make it palatable.
5. Member’s Mark Mandarin Oranges $6.84/10 x 15 oz
Seedless mandarin segments in light syrup.
Overly sweet with a chemical aftertaste, and the texture can be overly soft or even slimy.
6. Member’s Mark Tomato Sauce $9.48/12 x 15 oz
Basic tomato sauce for a variety of dishes.
Bland and overly processed—lacks the fresh tomato flavor needed to elevate homemade meals.
You May Be Interested In
7. Member’s Mark Tomato Paste $7.98/12 x 6 oz
Concentrated tomato paste for sauces and stews.
Too bitter and metallic-tasting for many home cooks—often needs extra sugar and seasoning to correct.
8. Member’s Mark Pineapple Tidbits $6.48
Bite-sized pineapple chunks in juice.
Texturally inconsistent—some too firm, others mushy—and lacking the bright, tropical flavor fans expect from pineapple.
9. Member’s Mark Whole Peeled Tomatoes in Tomato Juice $7.48
Hand-selected tomatoes packed whole in juice.
Many complain the skins aren’t fully removed and the juice is watery, making recipes soggy instead of saucy.
10. Member’s Mark Tropical Fruit Salad $6.98
A mix of tropical fruits in light syrup.
Lacks natural fruit flavor—comes across as overly syrupy with rubbery chunks of papaya and guava that don’t hold up well.
11. Member’s Mark Whole Kernel Sweet Corn $6.58
Sweet corn kernels picked at peak ripeness.
Surprisingly bland and mealy, missing the pop and sweetness you expect—even from canned corn.
12. Member’s Mark Premium Chunk Chicken Breast $13.48/6 x 12.5 oz
Fully cooked white meat chicken packed in water.
Reviewers note a rubbery texture and unpleasant aftertaste. Not ideal for salads or sandwiches without heavy seasoning.
Conclusion
Buying in bulk is great—until you’re stuck with a case of canned goods you don’t want to finish. These 12 Member’s Mark items might look like a smart buy, but they often disappoint on taste and texture. Want better quality for your dollar? Shop smarter, and skip these next time you’re at Sam’s Club.
Recommended For You
