The Sam’s Club bakery is on fire this fall with festive desserts that make entertaining easier (and sweeter) than ever. From pumpkin-spiced cake balls to giant cookie cakes, these limited-time bakery creations are perfect for Halloween parties, cozy gatherings, or even Thanksgiving dessert tables. Whether you’re planning for kids, coworkers, or just your own sweet tooth, these 16 finds are sure to impress—no baking required.
1. Member’s Mark Holiday Cookie Tray – $21.98/60 pieces
This massive 60-count tray includes five irresistible cookie varieties: Cookie Butter, Millionaire’s Shortbread, Turtle Shortbread, Cranberry Dream, and Pumpkin White Chunk. Each cookie offers a rich, homemade flavor that tastes like it came straight from grandma’s kitchen. Perfect for potlucks or office parties, this tray guarantees a sweet bite for every palate.
2. Snoopy Fall Half Sheet Cookie Cake – $19.98
A nostalgic treat that brings smiles all around, this double-layer chocolate chip cookie cake is covered with two coats of frosting and decorated with Snoopy and Woodstock jumping in piles of fall leaves. Serving up to 48 people, it’s the perfect combination of whimsy and deliciousness for any fall gathering.
3. Member’s Mark Pumpkin Spice Cake Balls – $17.98/24 pieces
Fall flavor perfection! These pumpkin spice cake balls are incredibly moist, dipped in a chocolate coating, and decorated for the season. Each bite packs the warmth of cinnamon and nutmeg, making them a must-have for pumpkin lovers. Ideal for parties, gifting, or pairing with coffee.
4. Halloween Monster Half Sheet Cookie Cake – $19.98
This monstrous dessert features six spooky faces crafted from frosting atop a double chocolate chip cookie cake. With two layers of cookie and frosting, it serves up to 48 people—plenty to feed a crowd at your next Halloween bash.
5. Member’s Mark Fall Brownie Tray – $21.98/24 pieces
Rich, fudgy, and festively topped with autumn-colored sprinkles, this brownie tray is ready for sharing. Each brownie square is dense and chocolatey, offering a satisfying bite that’s perfect for dessert platters or casual get-togethers.
6. Member’s Mark Assorted Mini Pies – $12.74/6 pieces, 4” each
Each box includes six gourmet mini pies: two French Silk, two Chocolate Peanut Butter, and two Cherry Topped Vanilla Bean. With buttery graham cracker crusts and creamy fillings, they look beautiful on a dessert spread and are perfect for portion control—if you can stop at one.
7. Seasonal Gourmet Cupcakes – $10.98/8 pieces
These cupcakes bring spooky charm to the dessert table. Decorated with monster faces, zombie hands, tombstones, and plenty of sprinkles, each tray includes four vanilla and four chocolate cupcakes. They’re bakery-fresh, perfectly soft, and guaranteed to delight both kids and adults.
8. Member’s Mark Fall Cutout Cookies – $9.98/15 pieces
These soft sugar cookies are shaped like pumpkins and leaves, frosted in festive fall colors. Sweet but not overly sugary, they’re a delightful treat to serve with cider or coffee. Each cookie has a bakery-fresh texture that melts in your mouth.
You May Be Interested In
9. Halloween Celebration Cupcakes – $16.48/30 pieces
Perfect for classroom parties or office celebrations, this 30-count cupcake set includes white and chocolate cupcakes topped with vibrant buttercream frosting in blue, orange, and green. Each is finished with Halloween-themed toppers for a festive touch.
10. Member’s Mark Brownie Tray – $21.98/24 pieces
These dense, chewy brownies are baked to perfection and come ready to serve. Their rich chocolate flavor pairs beautifully with coffee or milk, making them a quick dessert option that feels homemade.
11. Member’s Mark Holiday Muffins – $5.98 / 6-Count
Soft, oversized, and bursting with fall flavor, this muffin variety pack includes Butter Pecan, Red Velvet, and Cranberry Orange. Each muffin is bakery-style moist, making them a cozy breakfast treat or a sweet afternoon snack.
12. Monster Chocolate Cake Balls – $19.98/24 pieces
These spooky cake balls are almost too cute to eat—decorated as mummies and monsters with colorful icing details. Each bite reveals rich chocolate cake inside a smooth candy coating. A creative and fun way to serve dessert without cutting cake.
13. Decorated Fall Cake – $17.8/10” Round
A simple yet elegant round cake that captures the essence of autumn with warm tones and seasonal designs. Moist, flavorful, and perfectly frosted, it’s an easy choice for family dinners or Friendsgiving celebrations.
14. Peanuts Cupcakes – $16.48/30 pieces
These Peanuts-themed cupcakes feature 15 vanilla and 15 chocolate, each topped with colorful buttercream and Snoopy-inspired decorations. Great for themed parties or nostalgic fans, they taste as cheerful as they look.
15. Member’s Mark Halloween Cutout Cookies – $10.98/15 pieces
Brightly decorated with Halloween characters, these buttery sugar cookies are soft and sweet with a satisfying crunch on the edges. They’re ideal for dessert tables or goody bags at Halloween events.
16. Member’s Mark Half Sheet Double Layer Cookie Cake – $19.98
This colossal dessert features two thick layers of chocolate chip cookie and two coats of frosting. Serving up to 48 guests, it’s perfect for birthdays, parties, or any time you want to impress a crowd with minimal effort.
Final Thoughts
Sam’s Club has truly outdone itself this fall, offering bakery treats that blend festive design with unbeatable value. From cookie cakes that serve a crowd to adorable cupcakes and perfectly portioned pies, there’s a dessert for every occasion. These bakery finds make it easy to bring joy to your table—without turning on your oven. Just grab them before they disappear for the season!
Recommended For You
