Sam’s Club has quietly become a frozen-seafood powerhouse. Every Member’s Mark seafood item is responsibly sourced (many are wild-caught, all fall under strict sustainability standards), individually portioned, and flash-frozen at peak freshness. The real proof? Tens of thousands of five-star reviews from everyday shoppers who keep coming back. Here are the 9 frozen seafood superstars that customers swear by — shuffled and ready for your freezer.
Member’s Mark Wild Caught Skinless & Boneless Ahi Tuna Steaks $16.94 (2 lbs)
Restaurant-grade wild-caught ahi that sears to a perfect rare center in under 3 minutes. Thousands call it “sushi-grade in my own kitchen,” with reviewers raving about poke bowls, quick marinades, and date-night seared tuna. Individually vacuum-sealed, zero fishy smell, and consistently thick, gorgeous steaks.
Member’s Mark Atlantic Salmon Fillet Portions (Skinless & Boneless) $23.94/2.5 lbs
The undisputed king with 14,100+ ratings and 4.8 stars. Individually wrapped, truly boneless, and converts salmon haters weekly. Air-fry, bake, pan-sear, or grill — it always comes out buttery and flaky. “Better than fresh from the grocery store” is the most common refrain.
Member’s Mark Wild Caught Japanese Hokkaido Sea Scallops $29.98 (1.5 lbs)
Dry-packed (no water or preservatives), wild-caught perfection. Customers say these sweet, buttery scallops sear better than anything from a seafood counter. “Best scallops I’ve ever had — period” appears in hundreds of reviews. Zero chewiness, just pure luxury at half the price.
Member’s Mark Beer Battered Cod Fillets $15.46 (2 lbs)
Crispy, pub-style cod that actually gets crunchy in the oven or air fryer. Nearly 6,000 five-star reviews praise the generous real-cod portions (not just breading) and wild-caught quality. “Better than most fish & chips restaurants” is a direct quote you’ll see over and over.
Member’s Mark Farm Raised Jumbo Raw Shrimp (Peeled & Deveined) $16.87 (2 lbs)
You May Be Interested In
Tail-on, perfectly cleaned jumbo shrimp that defrost in minutes. Over 4,200 glowing reviews highlight consistent size, sweetness, and zero hassle. Grill, sauté, or shrimp-boil — they’re always a crowd-pleaser and disappear fast.
Member’s Mark Wild Caught Boneless Alaskan Sockeye Salmon (Skin-On) $13–$15/lb (usually 3 lb bag)
Deep-red, rich wild sockeye in individual portions. Skin peels off easily after cooking if you want, or crisp it up for extra flavor. Reviewers love the uniform size and “fresh-from-Alaska” taste at a fraction of grocery-store prices.
Member’s Mark Wild Caught Skinless & Boneless Pacific Cod Loins $25.94 (3 lbs)
Thick, flaky, bone-free loins that stay moist no matter how you cook them. Chemical-free flash-frozen means zero mushiness. Tacos, chowder, baked with lemon — customers say these are their secret to flawless fish dinners every time.
Member’s Mark Farm Raised Skinless & Boneless Tilapia Fillet Portions $14.64 (3 lb bag)
Mild, flaky, zero fishy smell, and individually wrapped. Thousands keep this stocked for 20-minute dinners. Takes on any flavor (Cajun, lemon-garlic, tacos) beautifully and cooks perfectly straight from frozen.
Member’s Mark Farm Raised Catfish Fillets $20.24 (2.5 lbs bag)
Clean, mild U.S. farm-raised fillets with no muddy taste whatsoever. Reviewers say they’re perfect for Southern fish fries, blackened sandwiches, or baked with Cajun seasoning. Whole, unbroken fillets and frequent “best catfish ever” comments.
Final Thoughts
Sam’s Club has cracked the code on frozen seafood that actually tastes fresh — and thousands of five-star reviews prove it. Individually portioned, responsibly sourced, and priced so well you’ll wonder why you ever paid fish-counter prices. Stock your freezer with these nine customer-approved winners and turn any weeknight into a seafood feast without the hassle or the cost. Your taste buds (and your wallet) will thank you.
Recommended For You
