Thanksgiving isn’t complete without dessert — it’s the finale everyone’s waiting for after a table full of turkey, stuffing, and mashed potatoes. Luckily, Sam’s Club makes it easy to finish strong without spending hours in the kitchen. From rich pumpkin cheesecake to pecan pie perfection, these store-bought showstoppers are crowd-pleasers that taste homemade — but without the stress or high price tag. Here are the six Sam’s Club Thanksgiving desserts worth adding to your cart before the holiday rush.
Member’s Mark Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cake Roll – $8.97
This in-house-baked roll captures the flavor of fall in every bite. Made fresh daily with real pumpkin and a luscious cream cheese filling, it strikes the perfect balance between spice and sweetness. With 11 servings per roll, it’s the ideal dessert to slice and share after your holiday meal. Moist, flavorful, and impressively priced under $9, this cake roll easily competes with homemade.
Sublime Desserts Macarons Assorted Flavors – $14.94
Bring a touch of elegance to your dessert spread with these pastel-perfect macarons. Each box includes 36 pieces in assorted flavors — that’s just 41 cents per macaron! Their crisp shells and creamy fillings make them as beautiful as they are delicious, ideal for entertaining or gifting. For a quick, colorful upgrade to any holiday table, these are a must-have.
Member’s Mark 12″ Pumpkin Pie – $5.98
No Thanksgiving is complete without pumpkin pie, and Sam’s Club nails it. This 12-inch bakery-fresh pie serves 11 to 14 people, delivering that warm, spiced-pumpkin taste everyone loves. The flaky crust and smooth filling taste just like homemade, minus the prep and cleanup. At under $6, it’s one of the best dessert values you’ll find this season.
You May Be Interested In
Member’s Mark Pumpkin Spice Cake Balls – $18.98
Perfect for parties or post-dinner grazing, this 24-pack of pumpkin spice cake balls delivers bite-sized bliss. Each one is coated in sweet frosting and infused with cozy pumpkin spice flavor. Guests can easily grab one (or three) without committing to a full slice of cake. At 79 cents each, these treats are festive, fun, and totally worth it.
Member’s Mark 9″ New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake – $18.84
Rich, creamy, and irresistibly smooth, this pumpkin twist on classic cheesecake is a must for dessert lovers. With a buttery graham-cracker crust and a silky pumpkin filling, it’s decadent enough for special occasions yet affordable at $1.35 per slice. Serve it chilled for an ice-cream-like texture or thawed for a traditional creamy bite — either way, your guests will rave.
Member’s Mark 12″ Pecan Pie – $12.98
Back by popular demand, this Southern-style pecan pie packs in rich, roasted Georgia pecans and a sweet, buttery filling. The 12-inch size serves 10–12, making it perfect for family gatherings. Fans give it a 4.7-star rating for its freshness, generous nut topping, and unbeatable flavor. It’s the ultimate blend of crunch and gooey sweetness that tastes straight from Grandma’s kitchen.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re hosting Thanksgiving dinner or showing up with dessert in hand, Sam’s Club has you covered with quality, affordable options that taste homemade. These treats bring all the warmth and sweetness of the holiday season — without the mess, stress, or hours in the kitchen. Stock up early, because once these desserts hit the bakery section, they won’t last long!
Recommended For You
