Bringing a dessert to Thanksgiving dinner should be a joy, not a chore! If you’re short on time but still want to contribute something delicious and crowd-pleasing, your local Kroger has you covered. Skip the stress of baking and pick up one of these 10 fantastic, ready-to-serve desserts.
The Crowd-Pleasing Classics (Pies)
Thanksgiving isn’t complete without pie, and Kroger’s bakery and freezer sections are stocked with easy, delicious options.
1. Bakery Fresh Pumpkin Pie
-
Why it’s a winner: This is the quintessential Thanksgiving dessert. Kroger’s in-house bakery pumpkin pie is usually a great value and comes ready to slice. It’s the classic flavor everyone expects and loves.
-
Pro Tip: Pick up a can of Kroger’s Whipped Topping (or Cool Whip) to go with it—it’s mandatory!
2. Bakery Fresh Pecan Pie
-
Why it’s a winner: Rich, gooey, and nutty, pecan pie is the perfect counterpoint to the more spiced pumpkin. Look for the 10-inch version in the bakery for a generous, impressive size.
-
Pro Tip: A quick zap in the microwave or a few minutes in a low oven elevates the flavor and makes the filling perfectly warm and soft.
3. Marie Callender’s Dutch Apple Pie (Frozen)
-
Why it’s a winner: For those who prefer a fruit option, this frozen pie offers that warm, comforting, homemade taste without the work. The buttery streusel topping is a major crowd-pleaser.
-
Pro Tip: Bake it at home the night before or the morning of. The smell alone will fill your kitchen with holiday cheer, making it feel like you baked all day!
? Beyond the Pie Plate
Sometimes you need a break from tradition. These options offer variety and an easy-to-serve format.
4. Bakery Fresh Carrot Cake (or other seasonal cake/bar)
-
Why it’s a winner: A dense, spiced cake with cream cheese frosting is a welcome treat after a heavy savory meal. It offers a different texture and flavor profile than the usual holiday pies.
-
Pro Tip: Look for their holiday-specific flavors like pumpkin or cinnamon spice cakes that pop up in the bakery section around November.
5. Private Selection Bundt Cakes (Red Velvet or Pineapple Upside Down)
-
Why it’s a winner: Kroger’s Private Selection brand often offers high-quality, pre-made cakes. A Bundt cake looks elegant on the table and is incredibly easy to transport and serve.
You May Be Interested In
-
Pro Tip: Dust it lightly with powdered sugar before serving to make it look extra fancy.
6. Dessert Bar/Brownie Platter
-
Why it’s a winner: For a buffet-style dessert that doesn’t require utensils, a platter of pre-cut brownies, lemon bars, or mini pumpkin bars from the bakery is a lifesaver. Perfect for kids and anyone who wants just a small bite.
-
Pro Tip: Combine a mix of flavors (chocolate, caramel, fruit) for maximum appeal.
? Mini Treats & Individual Servings
These small-format desserts are perfect for ensuring everyone gets exactly what they want.
7. Bakery Fresh Mini Pecan and Mini Apple Pies
-
Why it’s a winner: These tiny 4-inch pies are adorable and offer portion control. Guests can try both a pecan and a fruit pie without committing to a huge slice.
-
Pro Tip: Group them together on a tiered stand for a cute, upscale presentation.
8. Private Selection Pecan Tarts
-
Why it’s a winner: These are a more sophisticated, bite-sized alternative to the big pecan pie. The rich, buttery crust and sweet filling are addictive.
-
Pro Tip: Serve them slightly chilled or at room temperature alongside a bowl of fresh berries for color.
9. Seasonal Iced Sugar Cookies or Cut-Out Cookies
-
Why it’s a winner: Especially fun if there are children present, Kroger’s holiday sugar cookies (often decorated with fall or Thanksgiving themes) are festive, easy to eat, and a lighter option.
-
Pro Tip: They make a great take-home favor or a lovely, colorful addition to the dessert table.
10. Edwards Key Lime Pie or Turtle Pie (Frozen)
-
Why it’s a winner: Not every Thanksgiving guest loves warm, spiced desserts. Edwards frozen thaw-and-serve pies offer a creamy, cold, and bright flavor contrast that is often a refreshing hit after a heavy meal.
-
Pro Tip: Remember to thaw it in the refrigerator for the specified time (usually overnight) to ensure it’s perfectly set when you arrive.
Recommended For You
