Sam’s Club is a bulk-buying paradise, but not everything in the warehouse is a win. From snacks to household essentials, we’re breaking down what’s worth tossing in your oversized cart—and what you’ll wish you left behind. Here are 12 Sam’s Club steals that shoppers rave about and 12 items that consistently fall flat.
BUY: Member’s Mark Jalapeño Artichoke Dip
Creamy, spicy, and addictively scoopable, this dip is a fan favorite for parties and everyday snacking. It tastes like something from a restaurant and pairs perfectly with crackers or veggies.
AVOID: Toilet Paper
Despite the bulk appeal, Sam’s Club toilet paper often receives low marks for texture and durability. Many shoppers say it just doesn’t hold up compared to name brands.
BUY: USDA Prime Steaks
High-quality and flavorful, these prime cuts are a butcher-level score without the fancy price tag. They’re well-marbled and tender—perfect for grilling season.
AVOID: Condiments
While the prices are tempting, the giant bottles of mustard or mayo often expire before the average household can use them. Flavor and freshness also vary.
BUY: Member’s Mark Organic Triple Berry Blend
Packed with antioxidant-rich blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries, this frozen berry blend is a smoothie-lover’s dream. It’s affordable, versatile, and lasts for months.
AVOID: Cereal
Buying cereal in bulk might sound like a good idea—until you’re stuck with a stale, oversized bag your family gets bored of halfway through.
BUY: LaCroix Sparkling Water
A great deal if you love flavored sparkling water. Sam’s Club stocks massive packs at a price far better than most grocery stores.
AVOID: Clothes
Though affordable, the clothing selection can be hit or miss. Fit, quality, and style often fall short compared to other retailers.
BUY: Spices
Sam’s Club offers large containers of common spices at unbeatable prices. Perfect for home cooks who love to season generously and don’t want to pay $5 for a tiny jar.
AVOID: Milk
Milk at Sam’s Club is sometimes priced higher than local grocers—and its shelf life can be surprisingly short for a bulk purchase.
BUY: Member’s Mark Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Soft, rich, and loaded with gooey chocolate, these cookies rival homemade. Warm them up slightly for a bakery-quality treat.
You May Be Interested In
AVOID: Sunscreen
Despite the low price, Sam’s Club sunscreen often ranks poorly in ingredient quality and effectiveness compared to drugstore favorites.
BUY: Rotisserie Chicken
A cult classic. Sam’s Club rotisserie chickens are juicy, flavorful, and incredibly affordable. Perfect for a quick dinner or meal prep.
AVOID: Diapers
Many parents report inconsistent absorbency and sizing with the Member’s Mark diapers. When it comes to baby products, reliability matters.
BUY: Member’s Mark Yeast Dinner Rolls
Soft, pillowy, and slightly sweet, these dinner rolls taste homemade and freeze beautifully. A solid buy for holidays or weekly dinners.
AVOID: Coffee
Unless you’re buying a national brand, many of the in-house coffee blends lack depth of flavor and freshness. Stick with your favorite roasts elsewhere.
BUY: Member’s Mark Peanut Butter-Filled Pretzels
These salty-sweet bites are a snacking staple for many members. They come in giant tubs that disappear faster than you’d expect.
AVOID: Canned Goods
The per-can cost isn’t always better than grocery stores, and the variety is limited. Plus, do you really need 12 cans of creamed corn?
BUY: Member’s Mark Mountain Trek Mix
Loaded with nuts, dried fruit, and chocolate, this trail mix is perfect for road trips, office snacking, or satisfying sweet-salty cravings.
AVOID: Fresh Produce
Bulk produce sounds like a good idea—until it starts spoiling. Unless you’re feeding a crowd, many shoppers struggle to finish it in time.
BUY: Member’s Mark Tandoori-Style Naan Bites
These bite-sized naan breads are soft, fluffy, and full of flavor. Perfect for dipping, mini pizzas, or quick snacks.
AVOID: Member’s Mark Franks in a Basket
This appetizer promises a party hit but often lands flat with rubbery texture and bland flavor. You’re better off making your own.
Final Thoughts
Sam’s Club can be a treasure trove—if you know what to look for. From top-tier steaks to dangerously delicious cookies, the right picks can elevate your pantry and save you serious cash. But don’t be lured into buying bulk items that disappoint in quality or waste shelf space. With this list, you’re now armed with the insider knowledge to shop smart and skip the duds. Happy cart-filling!
Recommended For You
