Your holiday shopping list is about to get a serious upgrade.
We’ve sifted through this season’s newest arrivals and long-awaited returns to bring you the definitive list of what deserves a spot in your cart—and what can stay on the shelf.
The Viral Hits (“Run, Don’t Walk”)
1. Garlic & Herb Butter Mussels —$5.99/6.35 Oz
-
The Buzz: These are exploding on TikTok as the ultimate “fancy but cheap” hack.
-
Why Buy: They come on the half-shell and heat up in minutes. Users love dipping crusty baguettes in the leftover garlic-parsley butter.
2. Mini Filet Mignon En Croute — $9.99/10 Oz)
-
The Buzz: Basically mini Beef Wellingtons.
-
Why Buy: A “lazy host” hero. You get tender beef wrapped in puff pastry with mushroom duxelles. Social media users say these make you look like a pro chef with zero effort.
3. Peppermint Pretzel Slims — $3.49/6 Oz
-
The Buzz: Ranked as the #1 holiday snack in multiple taste tests this month.
-
Why Buy: The perfect salty-sweet balance. Unlike other peppermint items that can be overwhelming, the white chocolate and peppermint ratio here is described as “unmatched.”
4. Italian Tomato Pasta Sauce Trio — $9.99/30.69 Oz
-
The Buzz: People are buying these in bulk for gift exchanges.
-
Why Buy: Includes three distinct jars (Puttanesca, Roasted Vegetable, and Cherry Tomato). It’s a high-value gift set that looks more expensive than it is.
5. Kouign Amann (Frozen Pastries) — $5.49/11.2 Oz
-
The Buzz: A bakery-quality favorite that is back for the season.
-
Why Buy: Pro-Tip from Reddit: Ignore the box instructions. Let them proof overnight (8+ hours) instead of the recommended time for maximum fluffiness before baking.
6. Jingle Jangle — $9.99/22.7 Oz
-
The Buzz: The tin is a status symbol.
-
Why Buy: A chaotic but delicious mix of chocolate-covered pretzels, popcorn, and peanut butter cups. It consistently sells out because it hits every craving at once.
7. Buffalo Style Chicken Meatballs — $4.29/12 Oz
-
The Buzz: A new protein hit for December.
-
Why Buy: Made with chicken thigh/breast and Monterey Jack cheese. Great for quick holiday appetizers or a low-effort game day snack.
8. Truffle Risotto — $4.99/16 Oz
-
The Buzz: Called “restaurant quality” by employees and fans alike.
-
Why Buy: Real Italian rice with black truffles. It takes minutes on the stovetop but tastes like you spent an hour stirring.
9. Gingerbread Ice Cream Sandwiches — $3.99/13.52 Fl Oz
-
The Buzz: A new arrival replacing the standard chocolate chip version.
-
Why Buy: The cookie is soft and spiced with molasses/ginger, pairing perfectly with the cold vanilla ice cream. A festive upgrade.
10. Hot Honey Popcorn — $2.99/7 Oz
-
The Buzz: “Sweet, spicy, and addicting.”
-
Why Buy: It was supposed to be a limited seasonal item but keeps coming back due to demand. If you see it, grab two bags.
11. Holiday Cheer Unexpected Cheddar Spread — $4.99/9 Oz
-
The Buzz: The cult-favorite cheese gets a holiday remix.
-
Why Buy: Infused with cranberries, Riesling, and cinnamon. Fans are putting this on everything from crackers to baked potatoes.
12. Candy Cane Baton Wafer Cookies — $1.99/5 Oz
-
The Buzz: A lighter alternative to the heavy chocolate items.
-
Why Buy: Crispy rolled wafers with peppermint crème. They are being praised as a “refreshing” palate cleanser after heavy holiday meals.
13. Mini Peppermint Meringues — $2.99/4 Oz
-
The Buzz: A “diet-friendly” holiday treat that doesn’t taste like one.
-
Why Buy: Airy, crisp, and melt-in-your-mouth. Users warn you might accidentally eat the whole tub because they are so light.
14. 3 Spreads for Cheeses & Toast — $8.99/13.75 Oz
-
The Buzz: Another top-tier “giftable” pantry item.
-
Why Buy: Features Strawberry & Black Pepper, Rhubarb & Vanilla, and Mango & Yuzu. Elevates any charcuterie board instantly.
15. Almost a Kilo of Belgian Chocolate Bars — $14.99/31.7 Oz
-
The Buzz: A massive value buy.
-
Why Buy: You get a trio of high-quality chocolate bars (including a milk chocolate with crunchy corn). Perfect for breaking apart into stocking stuffers.
The “Skip It” List (According to Socials)
16. Lebkuchen Cookies — $4.49/7.05 Oz
-
The Buzz: “Tasted like paper.”
-
Why Skip: Reviewers found the edible wafer bottom ruined the texture, making it chewy in a bad way. One taste test ranked this dead last.
17. Trader Joe’s Peppermint Bark — $14.99/16 Fl Oz
-
The Buzz: “Too thick to bite.”
-
Why Skip: While a classic, recent reviews complain the slab is too hard to break and the peppermint flavor completely overpowers the chocolate.
18. Sleigh Ride Cookies — $3.99/8.5 Oz
-
The Buzz: “Tastes like a dog treat.”
-
Why Skip: These iced cookies are cute visually but described as incredibly dry and lacking flavor.
19. Vanilla Bourbon Sugar — $3.99/3.5 Oz
-
The Buzz: “False advertising.”
-
Why Skip: Users disappointed by the lack of bourbon flavor—many claim it tastes more like artificial root beer.
20. Clotted Cream Fudge — $2.99/5.29 Oz
-
The Buzz: “Rock hard.”
-
Why Skip: While the packaging is cute, reviews suggest the texture is sugary and grainy rather than the smooth, creamy fudge people expected.
