The holiday season at Publix isn’t just about subs—it’s about the limited-edition sweets hitting the shelves.
We taste-tested the newest 2025 ice cream flavors and bakery finds to tell you exactly what deserves a spot in your cart this weekend.
1. Limited Edition Coffee Chai Latte Ice Cream ($7.29)
-
Where to find it: The Freezer Aisle (Look for the green carton)
-
The Flavor Profile: This is the breakout star of 2025. It starts with a milder “white coffee” ice cream base that isn’t as overpowering as a standard espresso flavor. The magic happens with the swirl of chai spices and the crunchy cinnamon molasses cookie pieces scattered throughout.
-
The Verdict: If you love a dirty chai latte, this is your dream dessert. It’s spicy, warm, and creamy without being too sweet.
-
Rating: 9/10
2. Rum Nut Bread Pudding Ice Cream ($7.29)
-
Where to find it: The Freezer Aisle
-
The Flavor Profile: Another new entry for 2025. Publix took a vanilla-rum raisin base and actually folded in real pastry pieces. The texture here is incredible—you get the chewiness of the bread pudding mixed with the smooth, custard-like ice cream.
-
The Verdict: It tastes like a high-end dessert you’d order at a restaurant in New Orleans. The rum flavor is distinct but safe for the kids.
-
Rating: 8.5/10
3. Santa’s White Christmas Ice Cream ($7.29)
-
Where to find it: The Freezer Aisle (Grab it fast—this one sells out!)
-
The Flavor Profile: A collaboration with Barnie’s Coffee & Tea Co., this flavor defines a Florida Christmas. It features that signature Barnie’s coffee flavor mixed with cocoa espresso flakes.
-
The Verdict: You cannot celebrate Christmas without at least one scoop of this. It is nostalgic, perfectly caffeinated, and the espresso flakes add a satisfying snap.
-
Rating: 10/10 (Hall of Fame Status)
4. Peppermint Cocoa Cheesecake ($19.99 Whole / $5.29 Slice)
-
Where to find it: The Bakery (Refrigerated Case)
-
The Flavor Profile: Move over, Pumpkin Spice. This decadent cheesecake features a chocolate cookie crust, a rich chocolate cheesecake body, and a peppermint swirl on top. It’s dense, fudgy, and cooling all at once.
-
The Verdict: A sliver goes a long way. This is the perfect “I don’t want to bake” solution for a holiday potluck.
-
Rating: 9/10
5. Cranberry Cinnamon Goat Cheese Log ($4.99)
-
Where to find it: The Specialty Cheese/Deli Section
-
The Flavor Profile: While not a dessert in the traditional sense, this log is the MVP of holiday snacking. The tartness of the goat cheese cuts right through the sweetness of the candied cranberries, while the cinnamon adds a festive warmth.
-
The Verdict: Spread this on a plain cracker or a sliced baguette. It tastes like Christmas morning on toast.
-
Rating: 8/10
6. Limited Edition Peppermint Stick Ice Cream ($7.29)
-
Where to find it: The Freezer Aisle
-
The Flavor Profile: A vanilla base loaded with red and green peppermint candy pieces. As the ice cream melts, the candy creates pink swirls of minty goodness.
-
The Verdict: Simple, effective, and excellent when served alongside a slice of chocolate cake or blended into a milkshake.
-
Rating: 7.5/10
