Joining Sam’s Club for the first time can feel overwhelming—especially when everything comes in bulk. The key is knowing which items truly deliver value beyond just bigger packaging. From kitchen staples and freezer favorites to household essentials and pet care, these must-buy picks help new members stretch their budget without sacrificing quality. Each item below has earned strong reviews, competitive pricing, and a loyal following among Sam’s Club shoppers. If you’re building your go-to shopping list, these 15 finds are smart places to start.
Member’s Mark Mesquite Grilled Chicken Fillets, Frozen — $17.88 (bulk frozen pack)
These mesquite grilled chicken fillets are one of Sam’s Club’s most praised freezer finds, with thousands of five-star reviews backing them up. Fully cooked and frozen, they’re perfect for quick lunches, salads, wraps, or easy weeknight dinners. Shoppers consistently describe them as juicy, flavorful, and far better than typical frozen chicken options. Compared to similar antibiotic-free raw chicken at Walmart—which costs more per pound and requires prep—this product saves both time and money. For convenience-focused households, this is a freezer staple worth grabbing early.
Arm & Hammer Pure Baking Soda — $8.88 (13.5 lb bag)
This oversized bag of baking soda goes far beyond baking. With over 100 uses, it’s a multipurpose staple for cleaning, deodorizing, laundry boosting, and even pet care. The massive 13.5-pound size makes it ideal for households that use baking soda regularly, and the price is significantly lower than buying smaller boxes at grocery stores. Whether you’re scrubbing sinks, freshening carpets, or baking from scratch, this bulk buy quickly pays for itself. New Sam’s Club members often underestimate how useful—and cost-effective—this item truly is.
Member’s Mark Salted Sweet Cream Butter — $12.18 (four 1-lb boxes)
Butter lovers and bakers alike swear by this bulk butter pack. Each box contains four sticks, making it easy to portion, freeze, or store for long-term use. With nearly 20,000 reviews and a 4.9-star rating, shoppers praise its creamy texture and reliable performance in baking and cooking. Buying butter in bulk helps offset rising grocery prices, especially during baking-heavy seasons. Compared to grocery store prices, this pack delivers serious value while maintaining quality that rivals name brands.
Member’s Mark Elite Quality Velvet Hangers — $12.42 (50-pack)
Closet upgrades don’t get much better than this. These slim velvet hangers prevent slipping, maximize closet space, and instantly create a uniform, organized look. With a 4.8-star rating from over 6,300 reviewers, shoppers consistently mention durability and value. Many note they’re paying about half the price compared to similar hangers elsewhere. For new members looking to tackle home organization, this is a surprisingly satisfying and practical Sam’s Club purchase that delivers immediate results.
Member’s Mark BBQ Baked Beans With Brisket — $8.96
These baked beans are a standout side dish that works for potlucks, cookouts, and everyday meals. Made without high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors, they’re hearty, smoky, and loaded with brisket pieces that add real depth of flavor. Shoppers frequently call them a “game-changer,” especially for hosting. The generous size feeds a crowd and costs far less per serving than smaller grocery store versions. If you entertain even occasionally, this is an easy, crowd-pleasing bulk buy.
Magnolia Star Pure Vanilla Extract — $7.98 (on sale from $9.98)
This pure vanilla extract is a hidden gem for home bakers. Made from hand-selected Madagascar vanilla beans and non-GMO, it delivers rich flavor at a price point that’s hard to beat. Many shoppers say once they try it, they stop buying smaller bottles elsewhere. Because vanilla extract has a long shelf life, buying it in bulk makes sense—especially for frequent bakers. New Sam’s Club members often underestimate how much they’ll save long-term with this pantry upgrade.
Member’s Mark 80/20 Ground Angus Beef Patties, Frozen — $29.98 (18 patties)
These frozen Angus beef patties are all about convenience and quality. Made with an 80/20 blend, they’re juicy, flavorful, and cook straight from frozen—no thawing required. The 18-count pack is perfect for families, meal prepping, or backyard gatherings. Shoppers consistently praise the taste and say they’ll keep buying them as long as they’re available. When compared to purchasing fresh beef and forming patties yourself, this option saves time without compromising flavor.
Member’s Mark Chicken Broth — $7.98 (six-pack)
You May Be Interested In
Having good broth on hand transforms everyday cooking, and this six-pack delivers exceptional value. At roughly $1.33 per carton, it’s nearly half the price of the same-size broth at Walmart. Shoppers love using it for soups, stews, risotto, casseroles, and sauces. Because broth is shelf-stable, buying in bulk makes sense and eliminates last-minute grocery runs. For new Sam’s Club members who cook regularly, this is one of the smartest pantry staples to stock early.
Member’s Mark Purified Water — $4.28 (40-pack)
This 40-pack of bottled water is one of Sam’s Club’s most affordable essentials. Whether you’re hosting gatherings, packing lunches, or preparing for emergencies, the value is hard to beat. Shoppers consistently mention the clean taste and unbeatable price compared to other retailers. For families, busy households, or anyone who prefers bottled water on hand, this pack delivers convenience and savings without sacrificing quality.
Crest Complete + Scope Outlast Ultra Toothpaste — $9.98 (on sale from $11.98)
This toothpaste bundle combines trusted oral care with serious savings. Crest Complete with Scope Outlast provides long-lasting freshness and cavity protection at a lower cost than buying individual tubes elsewhere. Shoppers love getting a familiar brand in a bulk pack, calling it an easy “yes” purchase. For new members building their household essentials list, this item proves how Sam’s Club excels at everyday necessities done right.
Member’s Mark Colombian Supremo Medium-Dark Roast Coffee Pods — $32.98 (100-count)
For coffee drinkers, this is one of Sam’s Club’s strongest value plays. With 100 pods at just 33 cents per cup, it undercuts Walmart’s comparable K-Cup pricing by nearly half. The medium-dark roast delivers a smooth, balanced flavor that appeals to a wide range of tastes. Given that most Americans drink multiple cups a day, this bulk buy makes both financial and practical sense for many households.
Hefty Supreme 3-Compartment Foam Plates — $16.98 (on sale from $19.98)
These plates are a hosting essential. Designed with three compartments, they easily handle full meals without bending, soaking, or collapsing. Shoppers appreciate how sturdy they are, especially for cookouts, holidays, and busy nights when dishes aren’t appealing. Buying them in bulk means you’re always prepared for guests or low-effort dinners. For new Sam’s Club members who entertain or value convenience, this is a reliable go-to.
Member’s Mark Select & Tear 2-Ply Paper Towels — $19.98 (bulk pack)
With a 4.9-star rating and over 134,000 reviews, these paper towels are one of Sam’s Club’s most trusted household items. Shoppers praise their strength, absorbency, and consistent quality, often noting they’ve been buying them for years. The select-and-tear feature reduces waste, and the bulk pack saves money over time. For everyday messes, spills, and cleaning tasks, this is a dependable staple worth adding immediately.
Member’s Mark Grain Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Dry Dog Food — $39.98 (large bag)
Pet parents love this grain-free dog food for its ingredient quality and value. Real salmon is the first ingredient, making it a popular choice for dogs with sensitive stomachs or dietary needs. With over 1,000 reviews, shoppers consistently say their dogs enjoy it—and that’s what keeps them coming back. Compared to premium pet food brands, this option offers similar quality at a more approachable price, making it a smart pick for new Sam’s Club members with pets.
Member’s Mark 24-Piece Glass Food Storage Set by Glasslock — $19.98 (on sale from $24.98)
This glass storage set is one of Sam’s Club’s most loved home items, backed by nearly 9,000 reviews. The containers are safe for the oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher, making them incredibly versatile. Locking lids help prevent leaks, and the glass construction resists stains and odors. For meal preppers or anyone trying to reduce plastic use, this set offers long-term value at a price that’s hard to beat elsewhere.
Final Thoughts
For new Sam’s Club members, the smartest approach is focusing on bulk buys that combine quality, convenience, and real savings. These 15 items consistently outperform competitors and earn high praise from shoppers who buy them again and again. Start with these essentials, and you’ll quickly see how a Sam’s Club membership can pay for itself.
Recommended For You
