Tried, Tasted & Rated: 10 Costco Food Finds for This Week

November 16, 2026

Costco Tried, Tasted & Rated: six products in a 3-by-2 grid, with editorial scores in each upper-right corner, November 17, 2026

Cookie-butter chocolates, a holiday popcorn flavor and a bright yellow box of paneer tikka masala are giving Costco shoppers plenty to investigate this week. This Tuesday’s selection also includes practical freezer finds, bake-a-few cookie dough and a new dairy creamer for holiday coffee. These 10 picks are new to our Tried, Tasted & Rated lineup, with no repeats from the earlier editions we checked.

Costco Finds With Tasting Feedback: What to Buy, Consider or Skip

1. Chocxo Milk Chocolate Cookie Butter Cups

Chocxo Milk Chocolate Cookie Butter Cups

Price: $12.99 observed | Size: 14.8 ounces

Why it is on this list: Photographed in a California warehouse on November 13, with a separate Northern California price observation during the look-back. The flavor was already being reviewed in September.

The strongest sweet pick. A chocolate cup with cookie-butter flavor is an easy holiday sell. The more useful question is whether the filling tastes like spiced cookies or simply another sweet chocolate center. This one has unusually specific tasting feedback behind it.

Taste & Texture: A September firsthand reviewer praised the balance between the chocolate shell and the cinnamon-and-molasses filling, including the small crunchy pieces on top. Separate shoppers have called it a favorite seasonal Chocxo flavor, although one found it good rather than exceptional. Together, those reports support a rich, cookie-spiced treat with enough texture to keep the soft center interesting.

Before You Buy: Cookie butter does not mean this is a peanut-butter cup with a different label. The manufacturer’s recipe uses cashew butter in the filling, so check the current allergen panel before sharing. Also buy for the flavor: the package’s five grams of sugar per cup does not make this an unsweetened chocolate.

How to Serve It: Set out a few individually wrapped cups with after-dinner coffee. For a dessert plate, unwrap them shortly before serving and let the chocolates stand on their own rather than adding another rich topping.

Pair It With: Black coffee, unsweetened tea or sliced pears. Those simpler accompaniments give the cinnamon and chocolate room to come through.

Verdict: Buy for the cookie-butter flavor — 8.5/10. The detailed independent feedback makes this a more convincing seasonal purchase than a package that merely looks festive. Start with one bag before stocking up.

2. Laoban Scallion Pancakes

Laoban Scallion Pancakes

Price: About $11.99–$12.49; local clearance may be lower | Size: 12 pancakes; 50.79 ounces

Why it is on this list: A recent Costco freezer arrival that received fresh November 11 coverage and November 13 regional price checks. It was already spotted in September.

The most useful savory freezer find. These give you a quick side, a snack or the base of a more substantial lunch. Having separate frozen pancakes also makes the warehouse-size bag easier to use gradually.

Taste & Texture: Verified buyers of the same scallion-pancake product in a smaller retail bag often praise the crisp layers and ease of cooking. The criticism is useful too: some want more scallion flavor, and one found the result too doughy. Expect a layered bread with savory onion notes, with the final texture depending on getting both sides properly browned.

Before You Buy: This is the pancake product, not Laoban’s dumplings or bao buns covered in earlier editions. The ingredient list includes wheat, soy and sesame. Compare your own shelf tag with the regular price; a low clearance price at one warehouse does not mean the entire chain has marked it down.

How to Serve It: The manufacturer’s air-fryer directions call for removing the plastic separators, lightly oiling the pancake and cooking at 380°F for four minutes per side. Follow your bag’s directions and check for browning. Cut into wedges for dipping, or use a cooked pancake under scrambled eggs.

Pair It With: A cucumber salad and a small dish of soy sauce mixed with rice vinegar. Add chili crisp only if you want more heat.

Verdict: Buy for versatility — 8/10. The strongest argument is how many meals one bag can support. A good fit for shoppers who enjoy crisp, layered dough; less certain for anyone expecting a very strong scallion bite.

3. Jesse & Ben’s Tallow Sea Salt House-Cut Fries

Jesse & Ben’s Tallow Sea Salt House-Cut Fries

Price: About $11.49–$11.99 | Size: 2 pounds

Why it is on this list: Featured again in a November 14 warehouse walkthrough, with November 16 price checks. This is a returning spotlight on an existing Costco item, not a new November recipe.

A premium side worth considering. This bag is for shoppers who want a straightforward potato side and are willing to pay more for the particular cooking fat and house-cut style. At roughly six dollars a pound, it deserves a little scrutiny before taking freezer space.

Taste & Texture: The current warehouse reviewer said she had tried these previously and liked them. Separately, a shopper contributing a repeat-purchase recommendation singled them out for air-fryer preparation. That supports a favorable recommendation, but the available feedback is less detailed than for the chocolates or pancakes; there is no basis for promising that every batch will taste like restaurant fries.

Before You Buy: The three ingredients are potatoes, grass-fed beef tallow and sea salt. Beef tallow makes these unsuitable for a vegetarian meal. The short ingredient list is a description of the recipe, not proof that this is a healthier fry. These also differ from the brand’s avocado-oil and rosemary-and-garlic versions.

How to Serve It: Cook from frozen according to the bag, leaving enough space for hot air to circulate. A smaller batch is a better starting point than filling the basket to the top. Taste before adding more salt.

Pair It With: A burger, a roast-chicken sandwich or a simple green salad. Ketchup on the side lets everyone decide how much sweetness they want.

Verdict: Consider if you want this style of fry — 7.5/10. Positive repeat-buyer feedback makes the bag worth a look, but the premium price keeps it from being an automatic pantry-budget win.

4. Urban Bistro Apple Pie Squares with Cranberries

Urban Bistro Apple Pie Squares with Cranberries

Price: About $10.79–$10.89 before local markdowns | Size: 12 two-packs; 24 squares; 48 ounces

Why it is on this list: A September arrival still drawing November attention, including fresh November 11 freezer coverage. It has not appeared in our earlier Tried, Tasted & Rated selections.

A warm dessert without a whole pie. The best feature may be the packaging: each wrapped pack holds two small squares. You can make dessert for one or two people and leave the rest frozen.

Taste & Texture: The package describes apple and cranberry filling in a cinnamon-sugar crust. Shopper feedback highlighted in current coverage favors heating them in an air fryer for a crisper finish, with another buyer enjoying them alongside a hot drink. The tasting evidence is encouraging but limited, so think of these as a convenient fruit-pie snack rather than a guaranteed substitute for a bakery pie.

Before You Buy: The box contains 24 squares, not 12 individual pastries. At the observed regular price, that is about 45 cents per square. The photographed label says to keep them frozen and cook thoroughly; follow that label rather than treating them as a shelf-stable snack.

How to Serve It: Heat one wrapped pair’s contents using the package directions, removing packaging as directed. For a more substantial dessert, put the cooked squares on a plate with a small scoop of vanilla ice cream. The filling can be hot, so give them a moment before the first bite.

Pair It With: Tea, coffee or a modest spoonful of plain whipped cream. Extra caramel is optional; the crust and filling already supply sweetness.

Verdict: Buy for portionable fall dessert — 7.5/10. A practical choice for smaller households or anyone who wants warm pie flavors on demand. The manageable portions are the clearer selling point than claims of exceptional pastry.

5. SkinnyPop Elf Maple Syrup Flavored Kettle Popcorn

SkinnyPop Elf Maple Syrup Flavored Kettle Popcorn

Price: $6.59 observed; some warehouses higher | Size: 15.3 ounces

Why it is on this list: A limited-edition holiday flavor highlighted in November 14–15 coverage, following earlier fall sightings. Costco carries the large bag.

Festive packaging, modest maple expectations. The Elf theme makes this an obvious movie-night snack. The reason to pause is the flavor promise: maple on the front of the bag does not necessarily mean an intense syrup taste in every handful.

Taste & Texture: One October firsthand tester enjoyed the popcorn’s light, crunchy texture but was disappointed by how little maple she could taste, describing the experience as close to ordinary kettle corn. Customer feedback on the smaller retail bag also includes enthusiastic reactions. The available evidence points to a snack that may please kettle-corn fans more reliably than people chasing a strong maple flavor.

Before You Buy: Some recent articles announce the product without tasting it. Those announcements confirm the seasonal release, not its quality. Costco’s 15.3-ounce bag is also considerably larger than the 4.8-ounce grocery-store version, so compare package sizes when judging the price.

How to Serve It: Serve it straight from the bag in small bowls for a holiday film. If you are arranging a snack spread, keep chocolate and other additions in separate dishes so guests can choose their own combination.

Pair It With: Plain pretzels or a cup of unsweetened tea. A salty accompaniment can make the sweet popcorn feel more balanced without turning the whole bowl into a heavy dessert.

Verdict: Consider for kettle-corn fans — 6.5/10. A cheerful seasonal snack, with enough uncertainty around the maple intensity to keep expectations restrained. Skip it if a bold syrup flavor is the main reason you would buy.

6. Love & Cookies Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Love & Cookies Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Price: Check the local shelf tag; a reliable Costco price was not confirmed | Size: 18 portions; 27 ounces

Why it is on this list: A November 15 creator post identifies the Costco bag at select Southern California warehouses. Costco’s catalog independently confirms the 18-count format.

Convenient cookies, with mixed tasting feedback. The appeal is being able to bake just a few cookies whenever you want them. The dough comes portioned, and the package says it can go from frozen to freshly baked in about 15 minutes.

Taste & Texture: The current Costco creator describes a rich, buttery result. An earlier independent taste test of the brand’s chocolate-chip dough was more reserved: the cookies browned attractively and had crisp bottoms, but the reviewer wanted more chocolate and chew and noticed an unexpected spice note. That contrast makes this a try-one-bag candidate, not a sure replacement for your favorite homemade cookie.

Before You Buy: The earlier review covered the brand’s retail dough, not a side-by-side test of this new Costco bag. The warehouse package is much larger than the eight-portion bag on the brand’s own site. Because a dependable local Costco price was unavailable, this recommendation weighs convenience and reported flavor, not a claimed bargain.

How to Serve It: Keep frozen and bake the number you need using the bag’s oven or air-fryer instructions. Start with a small batch to see how the finished texture suits you. The package’s 15-minute claim is a guide; use its full instructions for your appliance.

Pair It With: Milk or a small scoop of vanilla ice cream after baking. Coffee is a good option if you prefer a less sweet accompaniment.

Verdict: Consider for small-batch convenience — 6.5/10. A useful format with mixed feedback. Worth investigating if your warehouse carries it, but the missing verified price and uneven reviews keep the recommendation cautious.

New Arrivals and Recent Finds to Watch: Taste Ratings Pending

7. La Jolla Baking Co. Jalapeño & Cheese Breadsticks

La Jolla Baking Co. Jalapeño & Cheese Breadsticks

Price: $8.99 observed | Size: 12 breadsticks; 50.8 ounces

Why it is on this list: Recorded in Los Angeles-area November 9 and November 13–15 checks, then highlighted in November 15 coverage. This is a current regional find; an exact national launch date was not established.

A substantial soup-and-supper side. These are generously sized breadsticks, with visible jalapeño slices and a cheese topping. At the observed price, each comes to about 75 cents, which makes the bag easy to picture alongside several dinners.

Flavor & Format: The product and package establish the cheese-and-jalapeño combination, but reliable firsthand tasting of this exact bag was too limited to judge softness, cheese intensity or heat. The visible peppers are a reason to expect a more assertive side than a plain roll, not a reliable measure of how spicy each breadstick will be.

Before You Buy: The label gives the weight as 50.8 ounces, a little over three pounds. Twelve large breadsticks can be more bread than a small household needs in a few days, so plan to freeze a portion. Check that you are buying the jalapeño-and-cheese variety.

How to Serve It: The photographed label recommends warming in a 390°F oven for seven minutes and freezing to extend freshness. Follow your bag’s instructions, particularly if warming from frozen. Cutting each breadstick into smaller pieces would make it easier to share alongside a bowl of soup.

Pair It With: Tomato soup, a bean-and-vegetable stew or roast chicken with a salad. A fairly simple main course lets the cheese and peppers do the seasoning work.

Verdict: Promising early look; taste rating pending. The size and observed price make this a useful regional find. A firm recommendation on flavor needs better tasting evidence.

8. Daily Delight Paneer Tikka Masala

Daily Delight Paneer Tikka Masala

Price: $14.99 observed | Size: Two 17.5-ounce pouches; 35 ounces total

Why it is on this list: Photographed in a California warehouse on November 13 and recorded in regional early-November stock checks. Coverage identifies it as a limited Diwali-season offering.

The dinner shortcut to watch. This fully cooked curry provides the main component of a meal; you supply the rice or bread. Two separate pouches also offer more flexibility than a single large tray.

Flavor & Format: The manufacturer describes marinated, tandoor-roasted paneer in a spicy gravy with fenugreek, butter and cream. That establishes the intended flavor profile, but there was not enough independent tasting of Costco’s exact refrigerated pack to judge the cheese texture, sauce balance or heat level confidently.

Before You Buy: This is a prepared paneer curry, distinct from the plain Kirkland paneer cheese featured previously. The package says to keep it refrigerated. Do not assume it is a shelf-stable meal because it comes in pouches, and budget separately for any rice, naan or vegetables you want alongside it.

How to Serve It: Heat one pouch using its directions, stir as instructed and serve with freshly cooked rice. A separate cucumber-and-yogurt side would give the meal a cooler contrast. Keep the second pouch according to the package’s storage guidance rather than opening both automatically.

Pair It With: Basmati rice, naan and a simple cucumber salad. Roasted cauliflower is another useful addition if you want more vegetables on the plate.

Verdict: Interesting early look; taste rating pending. A promising option for shoppers seeking a meat-free dinner shortcut. Product details are confirmed; a reliable verdict on the finished curry needs more firsthand feedback.

9. Kinder’s Organic French Onion Dip & Seasoning Mix

Kinder’s Organic French Onion Dip & Seasoning Mix

Price: $9.99 observed | Size: Six 1.25-ounce packets; 7.5 ounces total

Why it is on this list: Featured in November 15 shopping coverage and recent warehouse listings. The six-pack had already appeared before the look-back, so this is renewed holiday interest rather than a first-ever release.

A pantry option for holiday hosting. Instead of buying one large tub of prepared dip, you can mix a packet when guests are coming. The box says each packet makes two cups, giving you six separate batches.

Flavor & Format: The exact Costco product is an organic French onion mix with toasted onions. It is intended to turn sour cream into dip and can also be used as seasoning. Reviews of Kinder’s regular onion mix range from enthusiastic to complaints about saltiness, but those are not sufficient evidence to score this organic version.

Before You Buy: The $9.99 price covers the dry packets, not the sour cream. It works out to about $1.67 per packet before adding the base. Be sure the photo and name match the organic six-pack; the brand sells other onion-seasoning products that can be easy to confuse.

How to Serve It: Make one batch according to the packet and chill it as directed before serving. Taste the finished dip before adding more seasoning. Keeping the other packets unopened preserves the main convenience of the format.

Pair It With: Ridged potato chips, carrot sticks, cucumber slices or a mixed vegetable platter. Offering both chips and vegetables makes one bowl useful to more guests.

Verdict: Useful format; taste rating pending. Worth a look for frequent hosts who already like mixing their own dip. The exact organic version needs better tasting confirmation before earning a score.

10. Starbucks Sugar Cookie Latte Creamer with Real Milk & Cream

Starbucks Sugar Cookie Latte Creamer with Real Milk & Cream

Price: $7.99 observed | Size: 58 fluid ounces

Why it is on this list: Photographed in California on November 13, with a separate November 9 regional price observation. The dairy version had already been reported in late October.

A holiday coffee option with an important label difference. The green bottle brings a seasonal café flavor into a home coffee routine. The detail that matters is the dairy base: this is made with real milk and cream.

Flavor & Format: The label promises sugar-cookie flavor, but the familiar name can create confusion. Earlier reviews of the almond-and-oat version do not tell us how this dairy bottle tastes. Current reports confirm its arrival and format; independently verified tasting of this exact version was too limited for a confident judgment about its cookie flavor or sweetness in brewed coffee.

Before You Buy: This is a large refrigerated bottle. If only one person uses flavored creamer occasionally, think about whether you will finish it within the label’s storage guidance. It is also creamer, not a ready-to-drink latte, so the flavor you get will depend partly on your coffee and how much you add.

How to Serve It: Start with a small measured splash in your usual coffee, stir and taste before adding more. That is an easier way to find your preferred balance than filling a mug with creamer first. Keep it refrigerated and follow the bottle’s instructions after opening.

Pair It With: Plain toast, an English muffin or a less-sweet breakfast. The creamer supplies the festive note without needing a second sugary item beside it.

Verdict: Early look for flavored-coffee fans. The exact bottle, size and recent Costco price are confirmed. A taste score will wait for stronger feedback on the dairy formula.

For this week’s shopping list, the cookie-butter cups have the strongest combination of detailed tasting feedback and seasonal appeal. The scallion pancakes are the most versatile savory pick, while the apple-pie squares suit a household that wants a small warm dessert without committing to a whole pie. Among the early looks, the paneer curry and jalapeño breadsticks offer the most useful dinner shortcuts. Check your local warehouse before making a special trip, especially for the regional arrivals.

Product photographs are from Costco’s catalog. Packaging and servings may vary. The featured image is an AI-assisted editorial collage. Pairings and serving suggestions are editorial ideas unless otherwise attributed.

Related posts

Determined woman throws darts at target for concept of business success and achieving set goals

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.