Kroger’s Cozy Fall Favorites: Pumpkin Delights, Spooky Sweets & Seasonal Surprises!

Hey Kroger fans! On this crisp September 20, 2025 (America/Phoenix time), fall is ushering in surprising seasonal discoveries that shoppers are loving.

From cozy bakery treats to fun Halloween candies, I’ve synthesized current Kroger offerings into this shoppable guide with prices, details, and tips to help you decide.

Stock up for gatherings or snacks—happy autumn exploring!

Bakery Fresh 8 Inch Pumpkin Pie — $4.99/21.5 oz

• Description: A classic ready-to-eat pumpkin pie in an 8-inch size, filled with smooth pumpkin puree and warm spices. Ideal for small families or quick desserts. Comes pre-baked for convenience.
• Taste & texture: Creamy, spiced filling with a flaky, buttery crust.
• Key details: Ingredients include pumpkin, wheat flour, eggs, milk, sugar; allergens: wheat, eggs, milk; no diet tags; refrigerate after opening.
• Best uses: Slice for family dinners; top with whipped cream or ice cream.
• Verdict: Buy — Unbeatable price for a homemade-tasting seasonal staple that’s effortless to serve.

Private Selection® Pumpkin Spice Crumb Cake — $6.49

• Description: Moist pumpkin cake layered with a ripple of spice and topped with crunchy streusel. A premium bakery item perfect for fall mornings or afternoons. Serves about 10 slices.
• Taste & texture: Sweet pumpkin with warm spices; tender cake and crumbly topping.
• Key details: Ingredients: sugar, bleached flour, eggs, pumpkin, margarine; allergens: wheat, eggs, soy, milk; no diet tags; store at room temp or freeze slices.
• Best uses: Enjoy with coffee for breakfast; warm slightly for dessert.
• Verdict: Buy — Excellent value for high-quality, versatile flavor that captures fall essence affordably.

Bakery Fresh Fall Cupcakes — $5.04/12 ct

• Description: Assortment of 12 fall-themed cupcakes with seasonal flavors and decorations. Fresh-baked in-store for that bakery aroma. Great for sharing at parties.
• Taste & texture: Soft, moist cake with creamy frosting; varied seasonal notes.
• Best uses: Bring to potlucks; serve as after-school treats.
• Verdict: Buy — Good bulk price for fun, festive cupcakes that add joy to fall events.

Bakery Fresh Fall Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Cookie — $5.60/10 ct

• Description: 10-count pack of large snickerdoodle cookies infused with pumpkin and cinnamon sugar. Soft and chewy with a seasonal twist. Bakery-fresh quality.
• Taste & texture: Cinnamon-sweet with pumpkin undertones; chewy center and crisp edges.
• Best uses: Pair with hot cider; dunk in milk for snacks.
• Verdict: Buy — Affordable indulgence with unique fall flavor that’s perfect for casual munching.

OREO Fall Treats Trick or Treat Halloween Sandwich Cookies Variety Pack — $9.99/20 ct

• Description: Variety pack of Halloween-themed OREO cookies with fun designs and classic creme filling. Includes multiple flavors for trick-or-treating or snacking. Bulk size for sharing.
• Taste & texture: Crunchy chocolate wafers with smooth creme; playful seasonal vibes.
• Key details: Ingredients/allergens not specified (contains wheat, soy typically); no diet tags; store in cool, dry place.
• Best uses: Hand out for Halloween; add to lunchboxes.
• Verdict: Maybe — Solid deal for holiday fun, but skip if you prefer non-themed classics to avoid limited seasonality.

Pepperidge Farm Gingerman Cookies — $4.98/5 oz

• Description: 5-oz bag of ginger-flavored cookies shaped like little men. Crisp and spiced for a nostalgic fall treat. Easy to grab on the go.
• Taste & texture: Spicy ginger with subtle sweetness; snappy crunch.
• Best uses: Enjoy with tea; decorate for holiday baking.
• Verdict: Buy — Budget-friendly option for versatile, warming spice that fits any fall occasion.

Twix Fun Size Caramel Cookie Chocolate Candy Bag — $1.50/5 ct

• Description: Bag of fun-size Twix bars with caramel, cookie, and chocolate. Perfect for fall candy bowls or treats. Compact and shareable.
• Taste & texture: Crunchy cookie, gooey caramel, smooth chocolate.
• Key details: Ingredients/allergens not specified (contains milk, soy, wheat); no diet tags; store cool.
• Best uses: Fill candy dishes; use in baking mixes.
• Verdict: Buy — Great low price for a crowd-pleasing snack with timeless appeal.

REESE’S Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pumpkins Halloween Candy Snack Size Bag — $7.99/16.2 oz

• Description: Snack-size peanut butter pumpkins coated in milk chocolate. Halloween-shaped for festive fun. Ideal for portioned treats.
• Taste & texture: Creamy peanut butter with rich chocolate; smooth melt.
• Best uses: Trick-or-treat giveaways; quick energy snacks.
• Verdict: Buy — Fantastic value for addictive flavor that’s a fall holiday essential.

Bakery Seasonal Iced Sugar Cookies — $5.59/12 ct

• Description: 12-count pack of iced sugar cookies with seasonal designs. Soft-baked and decorated for fall vibes. Simple yet delightful.
• Taste & texture: Sweet vanilla with soft chew; smooth icing.
• Best uses: Serve at gatherings; customize with kids.
• Verdict: Buy — Inexpensive way to bring seasonal cheer with easy, shareable treats.

Dove Promises Milk Chocolate Pumpkins Fall Halloween Candy Bag — $4.99/8.87 oz

• Description: Bag of milk chocolate pumpkins with inspirational messages inside. Smooth chocolate for fall indulgence. Great for gifting or personal treats.
• Taste & texture: Velvety milk chocolate; melt-in-mouth creamy.
• Best uses: Add to care packages; enjoy as after-dinner bites.
• Verdict: Maybe — Nice quality for chocolate lovers, but skip if seeking bolder flavors for broader versatility.