9 Five Below Mix And Match Snacks For Holiday Snack Boxes Under $5

November 21, 2026

Building a holiday snack box gets expensive fast — these nine picks from Five Below keep every slot under $5 so you can fill the whole thing for less than a dinner out.

1. Limited Edition Pocky® Peppermint 2.36oz – $3.00

Limited Edition Pocky® Peppermint 2.36oz

Seasonal crispy biscuit sticks dipped in cool mint chocolate — a limited-run flavor that tends to disappear before the holidays are over. At $3.00, this is one of the more distinctive options in the mix for adding a festive note to any snack box.

The Verdict: Grab a few to mix with other chocolates in the box — the mint contrast pulls its weight at $3.00.

Shop this at Five Below →


2. Lotus Biscoff® Cookie Family Pack 8.8oz – $4.00

Lotus Biscoff® Cookie Family Pack 8.8oz

Thirty-two individually-wrapped caramelized spice cookies for $4.00 — the per-unit math is hard to argue with. Non-GMO and vegan-friendly, they cross demographic lines and work in snack boxes aimed at kids or adults alike.

The Verdict: Best volume deal in the bunch; worth picking up two if the box count is high.

Shop this at Five Below →


3. Drizzilicious® Mini Rice Cakes Very Berry Bites 4oz – $4.00

Drizzilicious® Mini Rice Cakes Very Berry Bites 4oz

When every other item in the box skews chocolate or candy, these berry-drizzled mini rice cakes bring a lighter, crunchier option that earns its spot. At $4.00 for 4 oz, the price is fair for the contrast they provide.

The Verdict: Good for anyone who wants a lower-indulgence counterpoint — less interesting on its own, more valuable next to the richer picks.

Shop this at Five Below →


4. Holiday Reese’s® Miniatures Candy-Filled Candy Cane – $3.00

Holiday Reese's® Miniatures Candy-Filled Candy Cane

A candy cane shape packed with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Miniatures — the packaging does the presentation work so there is nothing to wrap. At $3.00, it drops directly into a snack box or stocking without requiring any assembly.

The Verdict: Hard to beat as a no-fuss filler — recognizable brand, festive format, $3.00 on the sticker.

Shop this at Five Below →


5. Haribo® Sweet & Sour Reindeer Gummies – $1.50

Haribo® Sweet & Sour Reindeer Gummies

Haribo’s holiday-shaped version of its sweet-and-sour formula comes in an approximately 4 oz bag at $1.50. Buy three or four and the whole assembled snack box still lands comfortably under budget.

The Verdict: At $1.50, the price makes the whole argument — stock a handful and mix them freely.

Shop this at Five Below →


6. Amos® Peelerz® Lumps Of Coal Gummy Candy 1.7oz – $3.00

Amos® Peelerz® Lumps Of Coal Gummy Candy 1.7oz

The naughty-list joke writes itself when these coal-shaped peelable gummies land in a holiday box. The peelable format makes them interactive enough to be a talking point, not just another wrapped candy.

The Verdict: The novelty earns the $3.00 — a smart add when the box needs something that stands out from a row of standard wrappers.

Shop this at Five Below →


7. Biscoff® & Go Cookie Butter And Breadsticks Snack Pack 1.6oz – $2.00

Biscoff® & Go Cookie Butter And Breadsticks Snack Pack 1.6oz

Dip-format snack pack: Biscoff cookie butter paired with breadsticks for dunking, non-GMO and vegan-friendly, in a single-serve 1.6 oz size for $2.00. It is the one interactive item in this lineup — everything else you just open and eat.

The Verdict: Two dollars for a dip kit that breaks up the monotony of a bag-heavy box is a reasonable trade; the nut-free label is useful when the recipient’s preferences are unknown.

Shop this at Five Below →


8. The Elf On The Shelfâ„¢ Double Crisp Candy 3oz – $1.50

The Elf On The Shelfâ„¢ Double Crisp Candy 3oz

At $1.50, the Elf on the Shelf Double Crisp candy exists for exactly one purpose: filling out a snack box without touching the budget. The licensed holiday packaging handles the presentation without any extra effort on your end.

The Verdict: Pure value at $1.50 — not the most memorable candy in the box, but it earns every cent.

Shop this at Five Below →


9. Junior Mints® Theater Box Candy 3.5oz – $1.50

Junior Mints® Theater Box Candy 3.5oz

Theater-box Junior Mints at $1.50 — a dependable chocolate-and-mint format that needs no introduction and pairs cleanly with the other chocolates in this lineup. The classic box shape fits neatly alongside other items without taking over.

The Verdict: Dependable and inexpensive — a couple of these round out any box without any deliberation required.

Shop this at Five Below →

Keep Reading

Related posts

Determined woman throws darts at target for concept of business success and achieving set goals

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.