Holiday baking asks for sugar at every turn — cookies, brownies, quick breads, cocoa — and these seven Food Lion finds let bakers cut it without rebuilding recipes from scratch.
Prices were checked at foodlion.com on November 21; they vary by store and change with each week’s ad.
1. Lily’s No Sugar Added Dark Chocolate Style Baking Morsel Chips – $10.89

The direct swap for Nestle Toll House Semi-Sweet Morsels or Food Lion Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Morsels in holiday cookie dough, brownie batter, and bark — same 55% cacao depth, none of the added sugar. These shelf-stable chips hold their shape in the oven and melt cleanly for drizzles. The main trade-off is a faint erythritol finish that most people won’t notice once baked into a dough but becomes more apparent eaten straight from the bag.
Worth It?: The premium item on this list, but its chip-for-chip performance in cookies and bark earns the price for anyone baking in quantity.
2. Truvia Sweet Complete Brown Sweetener from Stevia Leaf with Erythritol – $7.99

Gingerbread, blondies, brown butter cookies — these are the recipes that need the swap most, and this 14 oz bag measures as a dead ringer for Domino or Food Lion Light Brown Sugar in both volume and baking function. The molasses-scented undertone, which plain white sweeteners miss entirely, comes through in spiced batters and caramel notes. For large holiday batches, the reduction in total sugar adds up fast.
Worth It?: Pick this up early in the season; for most holiday cookies and spiced cakes, results land close enough to the original that it earns a permanent shelf spot.
3. Pillsbury Zero Sugar Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix – $4.19

At $4.19, this box lands around the same price as a standard Duncan Hines Fudge Brownie Mix or the regular Pillsbury Fudge Brownie Mix while delivering 0g added sugar per serving. The mix bakes in an 8×8 pan in the oven and yields a fudgy, dense center — 90 calories per piece of twelve — close to what comes out of a full-sugar box. It uses a sugar-alcohol and no-calorie sweetener blend, so portion size matters for anyone sensitive to sugar alcohols.
Worth It?: A solid yes for any household making lower-sugar treats this season — it fills a gift box or cookie tray without asking for extra measuring or blending.
4. Food Lion Unsweetened Applesauce – $3.89

In place of sugar or butter and oil in muffins, quick breads, and spiced cakes, this 46 oz jar adds moisture and body without introducing any flavor that fights the spices. The apple flavor is neutral enough to disappear entirely into pumpkin bread or a cinnamon-walnut loaf. At $3.89, the size carries an entire week of holiday baking without a second trip to the store.
Worth It?: The cheapest ingredient on this list and arguably the most flexible — it disappears into any spiced bake and cuts sugar without changing the recipe’s structure.
5. Food Lion 100% Pure Pumpkin – $1.99

Not to be confused with sweetened pumpkin pie filling, this $1.99 can holds unseasoned, unsweetened pure pumpkin — 4g of natural sugar per half-cup, no added sugars, no spice blends locked in. Its fiber and moisture content allow the baker to reduce a portion of added sugar in holiday pumpkin breads, bars, and cookies without compromising structure. The flavor is straightforwardly pumpkin, which pairs with any spice the baker chooses.
Worth It?: Best suited for recipes that want moisture and a natural sweetness offset rather than a strict zero-sugar target.
6. Monk Fruit In The Raw Zero Calorie Sweetener Blend Classic with Erythritol – $7.99

A 1:1 replacement for regular cane sugar, this 16 oz bag blends monk fruit extract — roughly 200 times sweeter than sugar — with erythritol for bulk and measurability, landing at zero net carbs per serving. It covers pies, muffin batches, and holiday cakes; the formula is keto-certified and heat-stable for oven baking. For bakers who have found stevia-based options too assertive, the monk fruit profile tends to read considerably cleaner.
Worth It?: Worth trying if previous stevia-based swaps left a bitter trail — the monk fruit profile converts some skeptics.
7. Food Lion Unsweetened Baking Cocoa – $4.99

Sweetened baking chocolate and milk chocolate chips both fix the sugar ratio before the baker has a say — this 8 oz can of unsweetened baking cocoa does not. At 10 calories and 0g added sugar per tablespoon, it pairs with any zero-calorie sweetener from this list to build brownies, cakes, or spiced hot cocoa exactly as sweet as the recipe calls for. At $4.99, it costs less than premixed cocoa products that arrive pre-sweetened.
Worth It?: The more practical buy when precision matters: controlling cocoa and sweetener separately gives flexibility that premixed products don’t.


