When my usual frozen pizza isn’t hitting the spot, I turn to Kroger for a change. These five alternatives offer worthwhile options for everything from a solo meal to family pizza night.
Prices were checked at a Kroger in Granbury, Texas on October 14; they vary by store and change with each week’s ad.
1. Totino’s Party Pizza Pepperoni 17g Protein Thin Crust Frozen Pizza – $2.00
When I miss the cheap, quick comfort of Celeste Pizza for One, this square personal pizza is the closest fit. It is a handy microwave option for solo lunches, after-school hunger, or those late nights when cooking feels ambitious.
Taste: The pepperoni, cheese, and sauce deliver an unmistakably nostalgic cafeteria-pizza flavor. Its thin crust turns crisp enough to make each slice easy to pick up, though this is unapologetically simple freezer food.
Make It Better: After microwaving, add a little Parmesan, garlic powder, or extra cheese to give it more personality.
Parting Thoughts: For two dollars, it is an honest little comfort meal rather than a gourmet imitation.
2. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge Cheese Frozen Pizza – $7.99
Cheese lovers replacing Celeste Original 4 Cheese Pizza get a much more indulgent option here. I would save this oven-baked pie for movie night or an easy dinner when a basic cheese pizza sounds too restrained.
Taste: The rich cheese blend melts into generous, gooey layers over tangy sauce, with an almost Alfredo-like creaminess. A thinner, crisper crust keeps all that molten cheese from feeling completely heavy.
Make It Better: Let the pizza rest briefly after baking so the cheese settles instead of sliding off with the first slice.
Parting Thoughts: The higher price makes sense for a cheese-first splurge, but minimalists may find it overly rich.
3. Freschetta Classic Supreme Naturally Rising Crust Frozen Pizza – $5.99
A crowded family pizza night calls for a heartier Celeste frozen pizza replacement, and this oven-baked supreme fills that role well. Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, and onions give everyone something more substantial than a plain personal pie.
You May Be Interested In
Taste: The sauce is lively, while the meat and vegetables stay balanced instead of letting one topping dominate. Its naturally rising crust bakes up puffy and light, with a welcome crunch underneath.
Make It Better: Give it the full bake so the center rises properly and the bottom develops its best crunch.
Parting Thoughts: Choose this one when a dependable, shareable supreme matters more than novelty.
4. California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Recipe Chicken Frozen Pizza Chicken Pizza on a Crispy Thin Crust – $8.99
Skip the usual red-sauce routine: this is a restaurant-inspired Celeste frozen pizza alternative built around barbecue chicken. It suits a Friday-night dinner when you want something less traditional, and a digital coupon brought it to $6.99 through 10/13 at the store checked, though offers change by week and location.
Taste: Sweet-tangy barbecue sauce meets savory chicken, red onion, and Gouda notes for a layered flavor that stands apart from standard pepperoni. The crust is exceptionally thin and crisp, landing closer to flatbread than a pillowy pizza.
Make It Better: Serve it straight from the oven while the thin crust is at its crispest, and cut smaller wedges if it is joining other game-night snacks.
Parting Thoughts: Anyone tired of conventional freezer-aisle flavors will appreciate the change, provided a sweeter sauce sounds appealing.
5. Private Selection Margherita Neapolitan Style Crust Frozen Pizza – $5.00
For a more elevated take on replacing Celeste frozen pizza, this oven-baked Margherita brings Neapolitan-style character without piling on toppings. It is currently $5.00, marked down from $8.79, making it especially appealing for a low-effort dinner that still feels a bit special.
Taste: Fresh tomato and mozzarella flavors keep the profile bright, clean, and classically Italian. The stone-fired crust is thin and crisp rather than thick or bready.
Make It Better: Scatter fresh arugula over the baked pizza for a peppery contrast and a more finished presentation.
Parting Thoughts: At the marked-down price, this is the smart pick for Margherita devotees who value restraint over a mountain of toppings.
Keep Reading
- Top 10 Kroger Frozen Foods That Make Losing Weight Delicious!
- 10 Best Frozen Foods at Kroger (According to Fans)
- Kroger Unadvertised Deals
- 10 Best Frozen Foods at Kroger (According to Fans)
