15 Costco Italian Items Ranked From “Skip It” to “Feels Homemade”

Whether you’re hosting Sunday dinner or just craving a quick weeknight carb-load, Costco’s Italian aisle is a treasure trove—and a minefield. We’ve tasted through the highs and lows to rank these 15 fan-favorites from worst to best.

---

15. Sonoma Creamery Pizza Crisps

Price: ~$11.99 | Ranking: ⭐ (1/5)

• While these promise a low-carb pizza fix, they often fall flat. Many shoppers compare the texture to “seasoned cardboard,” and the flavor can have a strange, sour aftertaste. Unless you are strictly keto and desperate, these are a skip.

14. Rana Roasted Lobster Ravioli

Price: ~$14.49 | Ranking: ⭐⭐ (2/5)

• It sounds like a luxury, but the reality is a letdown. Customers frequently complain about the “pasty” filling and a distinct lack of actual lobster meat. For the price, you’re better off buying plain pasta and a separate seafood topping.

13. Kirkland Signature Cheese Pizza (Food Court)

Price: $9.95 (Whole) / $1.99 (Slice) | Ranking: ⭐⭐ (2.5/5)

• A controversial ranking, but the food court cheese slice is often cited as overly greasy with a surprisingly dull sauce. While it’s a budget-friendly classic, it lacks the depth and “pull” of a truly great Italian-style slice.

12. Kirkland Signature Tortellini Pasta Salad (Deli)

Price: ~$16.00 ($5.99/lb) | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5)

• This pre-made deli item has been hit-or-miss lately. Some batches suffer from gummy, undercooked pasta and an oily vinaigrette that doesn’t quite hit the bright notes you want from a fresh Mediterranean salad.

11. Kirkland Signature Frozen Cheese Pizza (4-Pack)

Price: ~$13.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5)

• It’s a freezer staple for a reason, but it’s strictly “average.” The crust can be a bit flavorless, serving more as a vehicle for the cheese than a highlight itself. It’s a reliable backup, but nothing to write home about.

10. Mama Mancini’s Jumbo Meatballs

Price: ~$12.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐ (3.5/5)

• Found in the refrigerated section, these are massive and convenient. They come bathed in a decent sauce, but the texture can be a bit soft for those who prefer a meatball with a more rustic, handmade sear.

9. Kirkland Signature Italian-Style Beef Meatballs (Frozen)

Price: ~$18.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐ (3.5/5)

• These are “Italian meatballs in ALL CAPS.” They are heavily seasoned with fennel and garlic, which fans love and critics find overwhelming. They are dense and hearty—perfect for a slow cooker but too intense for a light pasta dish.

8. Kirkland Signature Italian Sausage and Beef Lasagna (2-Pack)

Price: ~$16.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)

• This is a heavyweight champion of the freezer aisle. It’s packed with meat and cheese, tasting remarkably close to homemade. The only downside? It takes over an hour to bake, so it requires some planning.

7. Kirkland Signature Chicken Alfredo with Penne (Deli)

Price: ~$16.00 ($4.49/lb) | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)

• A deli-section icon. The sauce is made with real cream and butter, avoiding that “processed” taste found in jarred versions. It’s incredibly rich and comforting, though it definitely benefits from a little extra cracked black pepper.

6. Rao’s Eggplant Parmesan

Price: ~$14.89 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)

• If you can’t get a table at Rao’s, this is the next best thing. The breading stays surprisingly crisp for a frozen dish, and the sauce is that signature Rao’s quality—bright, acidic, and perfectly balanced.

5. Motor City Pizza Co. Double Pepperoni (2-Pack)

Price: ~$12.79 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5/5)

• Technically Detroit-style, but its Italian roots are showing. Consistently ranked as the best frozen pizza at Costco. The “frico” (cheese crust) edges are salty, crunchy perfection that puts delivery chains to shame.

4. Kirkland Signature Basil Pesto

Price: ~$9.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5/5)

• This refrigerated pesto is a cult favorite. It’s vibrant, garlicky, and uses high-quality pine nuts and Pecorino Romano. It’s so fresh that it actually has a shelf life, unlike the shelf-stable jars that taste like dried herbs.

3. Tutta Bella Neapolitan Margherita Pizza (2-Pack)

Price: ~$14.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5/5)

• Found in the refrigerated section, these par-baked pies bring the wood-fired experience home. The crust has those characteristic charred “leopard spots,” and the simple mozzarella and basil toppings taste incredibly authentic.

2. Kirkland Signature Parmigiano Reggiano

Price: ~$22.00 ($10.99/lb) | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

• The “King of Cheeses.” Imported from Italy with the DOP seal, it has those beautiful crunchy salt crystals and a nutty depth that pre-shredded cans can’t touch. At Costco prices, it’s an absolute steal for the quality.

1. Kirkland Signature 100% Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Price: ~$19.99 | Ranking: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

• The gold standard. Chefs and home cooks alike swear by this blend. It’s peppery, fresh, and high-quality enough for finishing a dish, yet affordable enough for everyday cooking. It is the ultimate Costco Italian win.