12 Best Costco Holiday Desserts That Store out Taste Buds

As the holidays approach, Costco’s bakery aisle becomes a wonderland of indulgent treats perfect for Thanksgiving spreads or Christmas soirées.

We rounded up a dozen fan-favorites and put them through rigorous taste tests—slicing, savoring, and scoring for flavor, texture, and wow-factor.

From creamy cheesecakes to nutty pies, these desserts delivered big on value and delight. Spoiler: Every bite was a win.

Kirkland Signature Tuxedo Cake – $21.55

• Layers of dense chocolate cake and velvety mousse create a decadent, toe-curling richness that’s pure holiday luxury.
• The glossy ganache topping adds elegance, slicing beautifully for 12-14 servings without crumbling.
• Our testers raved about the balanced sweetness—pairs perfectly with coffee or spiked eggnog for post-dinner bliss.

Kirkland Signature Variety Dessert Bars – $22.69

• This 2025 newcomer packs 32 bars in flavors like pecan caramel brownie and blondie, offering endless variety for crowds.
• Gooey centers with crisp edges deliver intense richness; the pecan version was a standout for its buttery depth.
• Ideal for gifting or freezing—testers noted they’re dangerously addictive with a glass of milk.

Kirkland Signature Double Crust Apple Pie – $14.74

• Cinnamon-kissed apple filling bursts with tart-sweet acidity under a crackly sugar lid that screams autumn comfort.
• The flaky, non-soggy crust holds up well when warmed, yielding 10 hearty slices.
• Taste panel loved the nostalgic vibe but wished for fewer seeds; elevate with vanilla ice cream for extra oomph.

Mediterranean Baklava with Honey – $16.99

• Flaky phyllo layers cradle walnuts and pistachios in a honey-soaked embrace, evoking Mediterranean festivity.
• Crispy yet moist, with just the right chew—our group devoured the 2.2-pound tray in one sitting.
• Subtle spice notes shine after a quick warm-up; a fresh, nut-forward twist on traditional holiday sweets.

Kirkland Signature Pecan Pie – $16.99

• A towering crown of buttery, toasted pecans swims in gooey custard atop a sturdy, crumbly crust.
• The jumbo 70-ounce size feeds 12 easily, with bold corn-syrup sweetness tempered by nutty depth.
• Testers called it a “solid value king”—best chilled for firmer texture, transforming into milkshake fodder.

Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Spice Loaf Cake – $9.99

• Moist crumb laced with warm spices and topped with tangy cream cheese icing that’s not overly thick.
• Delivers cozy fall flavors in loaf form, slicing into 8-10 generous portions for casual gatherings.
• Our panel praised the homemade-like icing and subtle pumpkin punch—pairs with tea for a lighter dessert win.

Sticky Toffee Pudding Co. British Sticky Toffee Pudding – $18.99

• Steamed date cakes drenched in warm toffee sauce offer sticky, caramelized comfort straight from the UK.
• The two-tray pack reheats beautifully, serving 12 with scoops of vanilla ice cream for molten magic.
• Rich and fruity without heaviness—testers deemed it the ultimate fireside treat for chilly nights.

Kirkland Signature Plain Cheesecake – $29.89

• Ultra-creamy New York-style filling on a buttery graham crust lives up to its hype as bakery perfection.
• Nearly 5 pounds yield 14 slices; versatile base for holiday toppings like berries or chocolate drizzle.
• Silky texture wowed our tasters—elegant enough for Christmas, with zero artificial aftertaste.

Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Cheesecake – $21.99

• Dense, buttery pumpkin-infused filling skips heavy spices for pure squash smoothness over a stellar crust.
• The 5-pound wheel impresses with festive orange hue, easily portioned for 12-16 guests.
• Panel favorite for its richness without cloying—chills beautifully, elevating any turkey dinner.

Cartmel Sticky Figgy Pudding Cake – $14.99

• Spiced cake studded with dried figs and fruits soaks in toffee syrup for a boozy, British holiday classic.
• Two trays provide 20 mini servings; the complex, zesty notes build with each bite.
• Testers adored the natural sweetness from dates—warm it up for a pudding-like tenderness that steals the show.

Kirkland Signature Chocolate Mousse Dessert – $12.47

• Belgian-crafted single-serve cups layer silky semi-sweet mousse, ganache, and cookie crumbles for textural bliss.
• Six-pack is fridge-friendly, perfect for individual holiday indulgences or party platters.
• Dark chocolate shavings add crunch; our group scored it high for sophistication on a budget.

Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie – $6.80

• Iconic 12-inch single-crust pie with spiced filling that’s a steal for feeding 10-12 on a dime.
• Tender crust holds the mildly sweet, custardy pumpkin—best after a day for deepened flavor.
• Unbeatable value wowed testers despite its simplicity; top with whipped cream for instant upgrade.