16 Top-Selling Store-Bought Cookies You Need to Try

Nothing beats the comfort of grabbing your favorite pack of cookies off the shelf after a long day. There’s something about that familiar crunch (or chew) that just hits the spot. Whether it’s a classic chocolate chip or something a little fancier with a swirl of fudge or a hint of peanut butter, store-bought cookies have a way of delivering quick joy without the baking mess. This list rounds up some of the best-sellers; the ones people keep coming back to for a reason.

Oreo by Nabisco

Introduced in 1912, Oreo has become the world’s best-selling cookie, renowned for its distinctive design and taste. This classic treat features two chocolate-flavored wafers embracing a sweet, creamy filling. Over the years, Nabisco has expanded the Oreo lineup to include various flavors and limited-edition releases, catering to diverse palates. Its widespread popularity has led to the creation of numerous dessert recipes incorporating Oreos as a key ingredient. The cookie’s global reach and consistent innovation have solidified its status as a household staple.

Chips Ahoy! by Nabisco

Launched in 1963, Chips Ahoy! has established itself as a beloved chocolate chip cookie brand. Each cookie is generously studded with real chocolate chips, offering a satisfying crunch in every bite. Nabisco has diversified the Chips Ahoy! range to include chewy, chunky, and reduced-fat versions, appealing to various preferences. The brand’s consistent quality and widespread availability have contributed to its enduring success. Whether enjoyed alone or paired with milk, Chips Ahoy! remains a go-to choice for cookie enthusiasts.

Milano by Pepperidge Farm

Milano cookies are synonymous with elegance, featuring a delicate balance of crisp, oval-shaped cookies enveloping a layer of rich chocolate. Pepperidge Farm offers an array of flavors, including dark chocolate, milk chocolate, and seasonal varieties like lemon and strawberry white chocolate. The brand’s commitment to quality ingredients ensures a refined taste experience. Milano cookies are often associated with indulgent moments, making them a popular choice for those seeking a sophisticated treat. Their distinctive packaging also adds to their premium appeal.

Nutter Butter by Nabisco

Nutter Butter cookies stand out with their unique peanut-shaped design and rich peanut butter flavor. Each cookie consists of two crunchy wafers filled with a smooth peanut butter creme, delivering a harmonious blend of textures. Introduced in 1969, Nutter Butter has maintained its popularity among peanut butter aficionados. The brand has also introduced variations, such as Nutter Butter Bites and fudge-covered options, to cater to evolving tastes. Its distinctive shape and flavor profile make it a memorable snack choice.

Fig Newtons by Nabisco

Fig Newtons offer a wholesome twist on traditional cookies, featuring a soft, cake-like exterior filled with sweet fig paste. Introduced in 1891, they have stood the test of time as a nutritious snack option. Nabisco has expanded the line to include other fruit fillings, such as strawberry and raspberry, broadening their appeal. The cookies’ moist texture and natural sweetness make them a favorite among those seeking a fruity treat. Their association with real fruit content adds a perceived health benefit, enhancing their marketability.

Tate’s Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies

Tate’s Bake Shop has garnered acclaim for its thin, crisp chocolate chip cookies that boast a buttery flavor and generous chocolate distribution. Originating from a small bakery in Southampton, New York, these cookies have achieved nationwide recognition. Their homemade taste and texture set them apart in the crowded cookie market. Tate’s commitment to using high-quality ingredients resonates with consumers seeking artisanal products. The brand’s success has led to an expanded product line, including gluten-free options.

Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Thin & Crispy Cookies

Pepperidge Farm’s Farmhouse Thin & Crispy line offers cookies that emulate a homemade texture and flavor. Baked with real ingredients like butter and eggs, they provide a rich, authentic taste. Varieties include classics like chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin, catering to traditional preferences. The thin, crispy profile appeals to those who favor a delicate crunch in their cookies. Pepperidge Farm’s reputation for quality baked goods is well-reflected in this product line.

Keebler Fudge Stripes

Keebler Fudge Stripes cookies are a delightful combination of shortbread and rich fudge. Each round cookie features a buttery shortbread base drizzled with stripes of sweet fudge, creating a visually appealing and tasty treat. The balance of textures and flavors has made them a favorite among both children and adults. Keebler’s whimsical branding, featuring the iconic Keebler Elves, adds a playful element to the product. These cookies are often enjoyed as a standalone snack or used creatively in dessert recipes.

Lofthouse Frosted Sugar Cookies

Lofthouse Frosted Sugar Cookies are known for their soft, cake-like texture and colorful frosting topped with sprinkles. Often found in grocery store bakeries, these cookies are a popular choice for celebrations and holidays. Their sweet, buttery flavor and festive appearance make them appealing to a broad audience. Lofthouse frequently releases seasonal variations, keeping their offerings fresh and exciting. Despite debates about their sweetness, they remain a staple in the store-bought cookie aisle.

Little Debbie Oatmeal Creme Pies

Little Debbie’s Oatmeal Creme Pies consist of two soft oatmeal cookies sandwiched around a sweet, creamy filling. Introduced in 1960, they were the first snack cake produced by the brand and have since become an iconic product. The combination of chewy oatmeal cookies and smooth creme offers a satisfying contrast in textures. Their nostalgic appeal and affordability contribute to their enduring popularity. Often enjoyed as a lunchbox treat, they hold a special place in many consumers’ hearts.

Famous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies

Famous Amos cookies are renowned for their bite-sized, crunchy texture and rich chocolate flavor. Each cookie is generously studded with semi-sweet chocolate chips, delivering a satisfying sweetness in every bite. The brand has maintained its commitment to quality by using premium ingredients, ensuring a delightful snacking experience. Their convenient packaging makes them an ideal choice for on-the-go indulgence or lunchbox treats. Famous Amos continues to be a beloved name in the cookie market, appealing to both nostalgic consumers and new generations alike.

Grandma’s Cookies by Frito-Lay

Grandma’s Cookies offer a taste reminiscent of homemade treats, featuring flavors like chocolate chip, peanut butter, and oatmeal raisin. Each cookie is crafted to provide a soft, chewy texture that evokes memories of traditional baking. The brand’s variety packs make them suitable for sharing or enjoying different flavors in one sitting. Grandma’s commitment to delivering comforting, classic cookies has solidified its place in the hearts of many consumers. Their widespread availability ensures that a sweet, familiar treat is never too far away.

Archway Cookies

Archway is celebrated for its soft, homestyle cookies that come in a variety of flavors, including the classic iced oatmeal. These cookies are known for their moist, chewy texture and rich, comforting taste. The brand has a long-standing tradition of baking cookies that feel like they came straight from a family kitchen. Archway’s dedication to quality ingredients and time-honored recipes has garnered a loyal customer base. Their seasonal offerings and classic varieties continue to delight cookie enthusiasts nationwide.

Mrs. Fields Cookies

Mrs. Fields is synonymous with soft, chewy cookies that boast a homemade taste. Their signature chocolate chip cookies are loaded with rich, gooey chocolate, providing a decadent treat. The brand offers a wide range of flavors, including white chocolate macadamia and oatmeal raisin, catering to diverse preferences. Mrs. Fields’ commitment to freshness and quality has made their cookies a popular choice for gifts and special occasions. Their stores and online presence make it easy for customers to indulge in these delightful confections.

Entenmann’s Cookies

Entenmann’s offers a variety of baked goods, with their soft-baked chocolate chip cookies being a standout favorite. These cookies are characterized by their moist texture and generous distribution of chocolate chips. The brand’s long history of delivering quality pastries and cookies has earned them a trusted spot in many households. Entenmann’s commitment to freshness ensures that each cookie tastes as if it were just baked. Their products are widely available in supermarkets, making them a convenient choice for many.

Walker’s Shortbread Cookies

Walker’s Shortbread is a Scottish brand renowned for its rich, buttery cookies made from a traditional family recipe. Each cookie offers a crumbly texture that melts in the mouth, delivering a pure, unadulterated shortbread experience. The brand uses simple, high-quality ingredients like butter, flour, sugar, and salt, staying true to its heritage. Walker’s distinctive tartan packaging adds a touch of Scottish authenticity and charm. Their cookies have become a global favorite, often enjoyed with tea or as a standalone treat.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

15 Practical Amazon Products That Are Winning Over Our Readers

When it comes to finding practical products that make life easier, Amazon has a treasure trove of options. From organizing your daily routine to making home chores more efficient, these items are winning over countless users. Read More.

12 Stylish Spring Fashion Finds at Costco You Will Not Want to Miss

Spring is the perfect time to refresh your wardrobe, and Costco has some surprisingly stylish finds waiting for you. From comfy basics to trendy staples, there is something for everyone at great prices. Read More.

12 Affordable Aldi Chilled and Frozen Finds That Deliver Big on Quality

Aldi’s chilled and frozen aisles are full of hidden gems. From crispy seafood to cheesy comfort meals, there are plenty of affordable options that taste way better than you would expect. Read More.