7 Costco Deli Picks and 6 That Might Let You Down

Costco’s deli section can be a hit or miss, and knowing what to grab and what to skip can save both money and disappointment. Some items deliver great taste and value, while others fall short and leave you wishing you had chosen differently. With so many options in the cases, it helps to know which ones stand out for quality and which ones are not worth the space in your cart. From cheeses and meats to salads and party trays, there are plenty of picks that vary in freshness and flavor.

BUY: Grillo’s Classic Dill Pickle Spears

Grillo’s Classic Dill Pickle Spears are a refreshing choice if you enjoy a crisp and tangy snack. They have a fresh flavor that tastes homemade compared to many other jarred pickles. The spears keep their crunch, which makes them perfect for sandwiches or as a side with deli meats. They are sold in a large container, making them great for families or parties. If you enjoy bold dill flavor, these pickles are definitely worth adding to your cart.

SKIP: Kirkland Signature Chicken Salad

The Kirkland Signature Chicken Salad looks like an easy ready-to-eat option, but it often disappoints. The mix can feel too heavy with mayonnaise, which makes it taste greasy. The chicken texture is not always consistent, with some pieces stringy and dry. While it is affordable, the flavor can leave you wishing you had made your own fresh version at home. This is one deli pick that may not meet your expectations.

BUY: Kirkland Signature Seasoned Roast Beef

This seasoned roast beef has a rich flavor that stands out among deli meats at Costco. The slices are tender and make a great filling for sandwiches or wraps. The seasoning gives the beef a balanced taste without being overpowering. Many shoppers find it to be a high-quality option at a fair price. It is a reliable pick if you want something versatile for quick meals.

SKIP: Kirkland Signature Caesar Salad Kit

The Caesar Salad Kit looks like an easy meal option, but the lettuce often wilts quickly after purchase. The dressing can taste overly salty and heavy, which takes away from the freshness of the greens. The croutons also turn soft fast, leaving little crunch. While it may save prep time, the quality does not always match the price. Making a Caesar salad at home usually gives you a fresher result.

BUY: Kirkland Signature Imported French Brie

Kirkland Signature’s French Brie brings a creamy and smooth texture that cheese lovers appreciate. The flavor is mild yet rich, which makes it a crowd-pleaser on any cheese board. It pairs nicely with crackers, bread, or even fruit. The value is impressive compared to buying similar brie at specialty shops. If you enjoy soft cheeses, this brie is an excellent buy.

SKIP: Kirkland Signature Extra Lean Uncured Ham

While it may look like a healthier option, this extra lean ham does not deliver on flavor. The slices often taste dry and lack the savory richness you expect from deli ham. Some customers say the texture feels rubbery, which makes it less enjoyable in sandwiches. Even though it is lean, it misses the mark when it comes to taste and quality. It is one item you can pass on without regret.

BUY: Will’s San Francisco Potato Salad

Will’s San Francisco Potato Salad has a creamy and tangy flavor that makes it stand out in Costco’s deli section. The potatoes are tender and well-seasoned, giving it a homemade feel. It is ready to serve and works well for barbecues, picnics, or family meals. The portion size is generous, so you get good value for the price. This is a side dish that adds comfort and flavor to your table.

SKIP: Sonoma Cheese Wine Country Party Tray

At first glance, the Sonoma Cheese Wine Country Party Tray looks like a great shortcut for entertaining. However, the selection of cheeses is often too mild, and the flavors can be underwhelming. The cheeses also do not always taste fresh, which lowers the quality of the tray. For the price, you could create a better spread by choosing individual cheeses from Costco’s selection. This tray may leave your guests unimpressed, so it is better to skip it.

BUY: Kirkland Signature Goat Cheese

Costco’s goat cheese is creamy and tangy, making it a versatile addition to many meals. It spreads well on crackers and bread and also works nicely in salads. The flavor is mild enough to appeal to a wide range of tastes. It is also priced lower than what you often find in specialty stores. If you are a fan of goat cheese, this is a dependable pick to buy.

SKIP: Kirkland Signature Chicken Pot Pie

This deli pot pie is popular because of its size, but it often feels more like a letdown once baked. The crust can turn soggy, and the filling sometimes tastes bland and heavy. The chicken pieces are not always consistent, with some dry and stringy. Even though it looks like comfort food, it rarely satisfies in flavor. For many shoppers, homemade or smaller bakery versions taste much better.

BUY: Principe Prosciutto di San Daniele

Principe Prosciutto di San Daniele is a standout in Costco’s deli offerings. The slices are thin, salty, and full of authentic Italian flavor. It pairs perfectly with melon, cheese, or a fresh baguette. Many shoppers appreciate the high quality compared to what is sold at smaller markets. If you love prosciutto, this is an excellent choice that feels indulgent but still affordable.

SKIP: Kirkland Signature Stuffed Bell Peppers

The stuffed bell peppers are colorful and look appealing, but the taste does not always deliver. The filling can be watery and bland, with too much rice and not enough seasoning. The peppers themselves sometimes become mushy after heating. While the portion size is large, it does not feel like a quality meal. Many customers agree that these are not worth buying.

BUY: Kirkland Signature Sliced Oven Roasted Turkey Breast

This deli turkey is flavorful and moist, making it a solid option for sandwiches and wraps. The slices are thick enough to feel satisfying but still easy to layer. The seasoning is light, so it complements rather than overpowers your other ingredients. It is a convenient choice for quick lunches at home or on the go. With good quality and a fair price, it is one of Costco’s deli meats worth buying.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout