15 Best Store-Bought Cookies, Ranked

Who doesn’t love a good cookie? From classic chocolate chip, buttery shortbread, or something a little more adventurous, store-bought cookies are a quick and easy way to satisfy your sweet tooth. But with so many options out there, it can be tough to know which ones are truly worth a spot in your pantry. That’s where this ranking comes in, to bring you the ultimate list of the best store-bought cookies, ranked from good to irresistible.

15. Keebler Fudge Stripes

Keebler Fudge Stripes have a classic appeal but tend to fall short on flavor. The shortbread base is a little too dry, and the chocolate fudge stripes don’t pack as much sweetness as you might expect. While they’re a decent option for dunking in milk, the overall taste can be bland compared to other choices. These cookies rely heavily on nostalgia, making them a bit of an acquired taste. Still, for a simple, straightforward treat, they hold their own in the cookie aisle.

14. Nutter Butter

Nutter Butter cookies are for peanut butter lovers, but they can be overwhelming for those who don’t enjoy strong flavors. The cookie itself is crunchy and shaped like a peanut, which is a fun touch, but the peanut butter filling can be a little too rich and sticky. They’re best enjoyed in moderation, as the flavor can become overpowering after a few bites. Still, they do offer a unique twist in the store-bought cookie world. However, if you’re not a peanut butter fan, these might not be your first choice.

13. Famous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies

Famous Amos delivers on the crispy texture, but the flavor isn’t as rich as other chocolate chip cookies. The cookie tends to be a bit too dry, and the chocolate chips don’t have the deep, rich taste that you’d expect. While they are a popular choice for a reason, they don’t quite live up to the gourmet cookie experience. They are great for on-the-go snacking, though, with their bite-sized convenience. For a quick fix, Famous Amos is a solid option, but there are better chocolate chip cookies out there.

12. Chips Ahoy! Original

Chips Ahoy! is one of the most recognizable cookie brands, but the original recipe can be a hit or miss. The cookies are crunchy, which some people love, but others may find them a bit too hard. The chocolate chips are plentiful, but they lack the rich, creamy texture you get with freshly baked cookies. While Chips Ahoy! has a place in the hearts of many, especially for dipping in milk, they don’t quite satisfy a serious sweet tooth. If you’re looking for something more indulgent, these might not be your top pick.

11. Pepperidge Farm Milano Cookies

Milano cookies are more refined, with a delicate balance of flavors between the crisp cookie and the smooth chocolate filling. However, their subtle flavor profile might not satisfy those looking for a sweeter, more indulgent treat. They feel more like a snack for a tea party than a go-to cookie craving. The cookie itself is light and buttery, and the chocolate is rich without being too overpowering. Overall, they offer a sophisticated option but fall short in terms of indulgence.

10. Oreos (Original)

Oreos are undeniably iconic, but the original flavor isn’t for everyone. The chocolate cookie is a little bitter for some, and while the cream filling is sweet, it can taste overly artificial. Oreos shine in their versatility, though—they’re great for dunking, twisting, and even using in dessert recipes. They’ve been around for over a century, so they definitely have their place in the cookie world. Still, compared to some of the other options, they’re more of a nostalgic snack than a gourmet treat.

9. Lofthouse Frosted Sugar Cookies

Lofthouse Frosted Sugar Cookies are visually appealing with their bright frosting and sprinkles, but the taste can be polarizing. The cookie itself is soft and cake-like, while the frosting is incredibly sweet, almost to the point of being overwhelming. For those who love super sugary cookies, Lofthouse is a winner. However, if you prefer a more balanced flavor profile, these might not be for you. Still, they’re festive and fun, making them a hit during holidays and celebrations.

8. Biscoff Cookies

Biscoff cookies have a unique flavor, with hints of cinnamon and caramel that set them apart from your average cookie. They’re crunchy but not too hard, and their slight spice makes them a great pairing with coffee or tea. Biscoff cookies are perfect for those who want something a little less sweet and a bit more sophisticated. They may not be everyone’s first choice for a dessert, but they definitely stand out for their distinctive flavor. They’re a great option if you’re looking for something different from the usual chocolate or vanilla.

7. Mrs. Fields Chocolate Chip Cookies

Mrs. Fields cookies are famous for their soft, chewy texture and rich chocolate flavor. They feel closer to a homemade cookie than most other store-bought options, which is why they rank higher on the list. The chocolate chips are gooey and melt in your mouth, while the cookie remains soft and moist. However, they can be a bit too sweet for some, and the freshness doesn’t last as long as you might like. Still, for a quick, indulgent treat, Mrs. Fields is a go-to.

6. Pepperidge Farm Soft Baked Montauk Cookies

These cookies are soft, buttery, and loaded with rich chocolate chunks. The Montauk variety from Pepperidge Farm delivers a decadent chocolate chip experience that feels more premium than your average store-bought cookie. The texture strikes the perfect balance between chewy and soft, giving you that homemade feel. While the price point is a bit higher, the quality is worth it. These cookies are great for those who want a softer, more indulgent cookie without the hassle of baking it yourself.

5. Tate’s Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies

Tate’s Bake Shop cookies are known for their ultra-thin, crispy texture, which sets them apart from most other chocolate chip cookies. They’re buttery, with a perfect balance of sweetness that doesn’t overpower the chocolate chips. If you’re someone who prefers a crispy cookie over a soft, chewy one, Tate’s will be right up your alley. They have a gourmet feel to them, making them a great option for serving guests or pairing with coffee. While they’re pricier than your average cookie, the quality justifies the cost.

4. Girl Scout Thin Mints

Thin Mints are one of the most popular Girl Scout cookies for a reason. The crisp chocolate cookie is coated in a refreshing mint-flavored chocolate that leaves a satisfying cooling sensation with each bite. These cookies are perfect for mint chocolate lovers, and they’re surprisingly addictive. Thin Mints are also versatile—you can eat them straight from the package, crumble them into ice cream, or freeze them for an even more refreshing treat. While they’re only available seasonally, they’re worth the wait.

3. Girl Scout Samoas (Caramel deLites)

Samoas, or Caramel deLites, are a perfect blend of caramel, coconut, and chocolate, all wrapped around a crunchy cookie. They offer a complex flavor profile that’s sweet, nutty, and slightly chewy, making them stand out from other store-bought options. The combination of textures is what makes these cookies so beloved—the crisp cookie base pairs perfectly with the gooey caramel and toasted coconut. Samoas are the kind of cookie that you can’t have just one of, and they’re often a favorite in Girl Scout cookie season. They’re rich, decadent, and incredibly satisfying.

2. Pepperidge Farm Chessmen Butter Cookies

Chessmen Butter Cookies from Pepperidge Farm are the epitome of buttery goodness. They’re light, crisp, and have a melt-in-your-mouth quality that makes them feel luxurious. These cookies aren’t overly sweet, allowing the buttery flavor to really shine through. Their simple yet elegant taste makes them a perfect pairing with coffee or tea, and they’re great for those who prefer a less sugary cookie. The intricate chess designs on each cookie also make them visually appealing, adding a touch of sophistication to any snack table.

1. Levain Bakery Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies

Levain Bakery Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies take the top spot for their over-the-top indulgence. These cookies are massive, with a soft, gooey center and a crispy exterior that gives you the best of both worlds. The combination of rich chocolate chips and crunchy walnuts creates a perfect balance of flavors and textures. Each bite is filled with melty chocolate and a hint of nuttiness, making them feel more like a dessert than a snack. While they come at a premium price, Levain cookies are worth every penny, delivering an unforgettable cookie experience.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

13 Costco Bakery Treats That Are Surprisingly Unhealthy

Walking through the Costco bakery section can be both a delight and a challenge. The aroma of fresh-baked goods is irresistible, and the selection is vast. But, not everything that looks delicious is good for you. In fact, some of these treats are packed with calories, sugars, and fats that can quickly add up. Read More.

13 Creative Rice Additions You Haven’t Tried Yet

Rice is one of those ingredients that we all love because it’s so versatile and easy to make. But let’s be honest, plain rice can get pretty boring after a while. That’s why I’ve put together a list of some amazing additions you probably never thought of. Read More.

Looking for delicious gluten-free options that won’t break the bank? Trader Joe’s has a treasure trove of gluten-free products that taste great and meet your dietary needs. Whether you’re looking for snacks, staples, or sweet treats, there’s something for everyone. Read More.