The A to Z candy challenge turns a simple haul into a letter-by-letter puzzle. These nine Five Below picks cover some of the alphabet’s harder slots with flavors and textures worth seeking out on their own terms.
1. Airheads® Candy Share Size 5-Pack – $1.99

Five bars of stretchy taffy for $1.99 — this share-size pack covers the A entry in any challenge haul and then some. The assortment changes by bag, which is part of the draw; the Mystery white bar in particular has become a fixture in candy culture.
Taste: Bold fruit flavors hit on first bite with the tartness dialed up more than most taffy brands manage. The texture is soft and pliable, pulling apart in long elastic ribbons — not sticky in a cloying way, just agreeably chewy throughout.
Make It Better: Freeze a bar for a firmer pull, or press two different flavors together and eat them as a single layered piece to build something the package never intended.
Worth It?: Five bars for under $2 makes the per-piece math hard to argue with — yes, worth it.
2. Amos® Peelerz® Chili Mango Gummy Candy 3oz – $2.00

The interactive candy that turns snacking into a small event: each piece features a peelable outer layer — pliable, like a fruit roll-up — over a soft chewy center, with chili mango flavor built into both. It’s the kind of P-letter entry that justifies a Five Below stop on its own.
Taste: Mango sweetness arrives first, then a building chili heat that lingers on the back of the palate without crossing into uncomfortable territory. The outer layer is tart and thin; the center is denser and sweeter, so peeling them apart actually changes the flavor experience.
Make It Better: Peel the outer layer before eating — going in whole defeats the layered experience the format is built around and undersells what makes this candy distinct.
Worth It?: Anyone who wants a candy that actually requires interaction will find this worth the $2.
3. Nerds® Gummy Clusters Bag 3oz – Rainbow – $1.50

Crunchy Nerds candy encrusted around a soft gummy center — the contrast is the whole appeal, and at $1.50 for a 3oz bag, Five Below prices it below most grocery checkout racks. The Rainbow variety cycles through multiple fruit flavors, so no two handfuls taste exactly alike.
Taste: Crunchy, tangy shell gives way to a chewy gummy middle that softens the bite and introduces a sweeter note. The result is two distinct phases in a single piece — first the crackle, then the yield — without either overwhelming the other.
Make It Better: Very Berry bags are also stocked in some locations and offer a less tangy, deeper flavor profile by comparison — worth grabbing both for a side-by-side.
Worth It?: The texture contrast is real and the price is right — hard to argue against $1.50 for the most structurally interesting gummy in this bracket.
4. Cookie Dough Bites® Chocolate Chip Theater Box Candy 3.1oz – $1.50

Movie nights have a natural home in this theater-style box — soft chocolate chip cookie dough pieces, each wrapped in a layer of milk chocolate, all for $1.50. The format makes them easy to share, though the box rarely survives the opening credits.
Taste: The dough center is sweet and dense with chocolate chip pieces throughout, and the milk chocolate shell keeps the sweetness from going one-note. At room temperature the contrast is mild; chilled or frozen, the dough firms up considerably and becomes the main event.
Make It Better: Freeze them for 30 minutes before eating — the dough tightens into something that lands much closer to actual frozen cookie dough and makes the whole experience noticeably better.
Worth It?: Frozen, this punches well above its $1.50 price — an easy yes for anyone who already reaches for edible cookie dough products.
5. Bubs® Sour Diamond Tutti Frutti – $3.00

Diamond-shaped sour gummies from Sweden arrive with a texture most American candy aisles don’t replicate: squishy and marshmallow-soft rather than the firm chew of standard gummies. At $3.00 they sit on the pricier end of Five Below’s candy wall, but they’re the most genuinely different item on it.
Taste: The tutti frutti flavor reads as a bright, layered fruit mix — sweet upfront with a sour coating that activates after the first bite. The marshmallow-like give means the sour sugar sits on the surface longer than it would on a firmer gummy, extending the tang through the whole chew.
Make It Better: The brand produces other shapes — skulls, bottles — in different flavor profiles using the same marshmallow-soft base; worth sampling more than one variety if the store stocks them.
Worth It?: Three dollars well spent for anyone curious about imported gummy formats — skip it if classic American-style chew is the preferred texture.
6. Zero King Size Candy Bar 3.4oz – $2.99

The Z entry that actually closes the alphabet — a king-size bar built for anyone who has never understood why chocolate always gets top billing. Chewy caramel, crunchy peanuts, and fluffy nougat are covered in smooth white fudge instead of milk chocolate, all for $2.99.
Taste: Lighter and less sweet than a standard milk chocolate bar, with the white fudge coating giving the whole thing a distinctive, slightly vanilla-forward character. The peanuts and caramel hold up against the nougat in a way that keeps each bite from feeling monotonous — there is real textural work happening here.
Make It Better: A short stint in the fridge sharpens the distinction between the soft nougat and the nuts, making the contrast more pronounced and the bar easier to break into clean sections.
Worth It?: A genuine Z-letter answer that holds up on its own merits — not just an alphabet filler.
7. Dum-Dums® Flavor Vaultâ„¢ Lollipops 13.7oz – $5.00

Blueberry donut, fried banana, spicy pineapple, pickle — the Flavor Vault bag is built around discontinued Dum-Dums flavors that never made it to mainstream retail shelves, sold as a Five Below exclusive in a 13.7oz bag for $5.00. It’s the rare candy purchase that doubles as a tasting event.
Taste: The lollipop base is classic Dum-Dums: clean, not over-sweet, and smooth on the finish. The flavors are the story — some land as genuine discoveries worth revisiting, others register more as interesting curiosities, and the mixture of both is what keeps the bag engaging well past the first handful.
Make It Better: This bag is designed for blind tasting games — lay them out unlabeled and have people identify flavors before reading the wrappers. It sells out fast; grab it on first sight.
Worth It?: This one justifies a dedicated store visit — it sells out for a reason.
8. Sour Punch® Bites® Candy 3.7oz – Pickle Rouletteâ„¢ – $1.50

Three familiar sour flavors — green apple, lemon lime, watermelon — are hiding one rogue piece: pickle. That’s the entire mechanic, and at $1.50 for a 3.7oz bag, it’s a low-stakes way to bring an interactive element to any candy challenge or group tasting round.
Taste: The non-pickle bites land as standard sour gummy territory: chewy, sugar-coated, and bright with fruit flavor. The pickle piece, when it arrives, is bracingly savory-sour in a way that is genuinely jarring against the sweet baseline — not unpleasant so much as disorienting, which is the product’s entire point.
Make It Better: Best played with another person: take handfuls without looking, distribute, and wait. The reaction is as much the product as the candy itself.
Worth It?: A one-time buy that earns its $1.50 easily; whether it becomes a repeat depends entirely on how the group takes the pickle reveal.
9. Jelly Belly® Boba Milk Tea 4.25oz – $5.00

Boba tea orders run $7 and up at most cafés; this 4.25oz box translates the flavor lineup — mango, matcha, strawberry, taro, Thai milk tea — into a $5.00 jelly bean flight. It’s the J-letter entry that draws the most attention in Five Below novelty candy hauls for good reason.
Taste: The creamy, slightly floral notes of milk tea translate surprisingly well into Jelly Belly’s dense, smooth-skinned format. Each flavor is distinct and identifiable: the taro reads earthy-sweet, the matcha carries a vegetal note that cuts the sugar, and the Thai milk tea is the most convincing boba recreation in the box.
Make It Better: Eating two or three flavors together at once mimics the layered quality of an actual boba drink; the taro and mango combination in particular holds up.
Worth It?: The flavor accuracy is better than a novelty jelly bean has any right to be — boba fans will find the $5.00 well spent.


