Mini cheesecakes look impressive but the costs add up fast. These four Five Below finds cover the full build at prices that make a whole batch worth attempting any night of the week.
1. Oreo® Cookies Family Size 1lb 2.12oz – $5.00

Crush them into fine crumbs, mix in melted butter, and the crust for a full batch of minis comes together without any cooking at all. The family size is well over a pound — enough to cover multiple rounds — and the standard Oreo delivers the right cookie-to-creme balance for a base that holds clean once chilled.
The Bottom Line: No other crust cookie gives this much coverage at this price for a base that virtually everyone at the table will recognize and like.
2. Funfetti® Galaxy Space Blue Vanilla Frosting 15.6oz

A swipe of this galaxy-blue vanilla frosting turns a plain chilled mini into something that looks party-ready without any piping skill. The confetti sprinkles are built right into the frosting, so there’s nothing extra to track down — aimed squarely at ease and color over precision.
The Bottom Line: Worth picking up when the batch is headed somewhere with an audience — the color and sprinkles do the decorating work for you.
3. Ghirardelli® Squares Caramel Milk Chocolate 5.32oz – $7.00

Caramel-filled milk chocolate squares melt into a smooth ganache that drizzles over chilled minis in thin, clean ribbons — the kind of finish that makes a simple dessert look like it came from a bakery case. At $7 for 5.32oz, it’s the priciest item in this group, but the caramel-chocolate combination does real work on the final plate.
The Bottom Line: If the goal is making these look impressive for someone, this is the item that earns the most visible return.
4. Food Storage 42-Piece Set – $5.55

Forty-two containers across multiple sizes mean covered, chilled minis stored neatly without stacking bare cheesecakes on top of each other. The set includes larger 16-cup containers alongside smaller cup-sized options — handy for pre-measuring crust crumbs or portioning toppings before assembly — and everything nests flat for compact storage between uses.
The Bottom Line: Makes the most sense when you’re making more than a single small batch, since covered storage is what keeps the texture right the next day.


