7 Sam’s Club Beef Cuts Worth Buying For Your Sunday Dinner

November 21, 2026

Sunday dinner built around a serious beef cut is exactly what this list is for — seven Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus options, each priced per pound, spanning every cooking method and every appetite at the table.

1. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Filet Mignon, priced per pound – $19.97/lb

At $19.97 a pound for USDA Choice Angus beef — four steaks cut fresh daily, each running 1 to 1.5 inches thick — this is the case for staying home on Sunday rather than booking a table. The filet’s signature is tenderness rather than assertive flavor, which means simple preparation serves it best: salt, pepper, and a properly hot pan. It pairs naturally with roasted asparagus or mashed potatoes for a dinner that earns its occasion.

The Verdict: The right buy for a low-effort special occasion; pass it over only if bold beefy flavor matters more to the table than tenderness.


2. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Bone-In Cowboy Ribeye Steak – $14.47-$16.22/lb

The bone alone — protruding from a thick-cut steak that often runs three or more pounds — signals what kind of Sunday dinner this is going to be. This tomahawk-style bone-in ribeye is built for the grill or a high-heat oven roast, and its size means leftovers are part of the plan: cold sliced ribeye the next day makes a reasonable argument for Monday. At $14.47 to $16.22 a pound, it typically feeds three to five people from a single cut.

The Verdict: The better choice when Sunday dinner needs to serve a crowd from one dramatic centerpiece — and costs less per head than splitting the same order at a steakhouse.


3. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Boneless Chuck Roast, priced per pound – $7.47/lb

Sunday pot roast has an obvious starting point: USDA Choice Angus chuck, fresh-cut and aged for tenderness, at $7.47 a pound. The cut is designed for low-and-slow heat — collagen converts to gelatin over hours in a Dutch oven or slow cooker, the meat shreds without effort, and the braising liquid becomes a natural sauce requiring no extra work. One tray typically yields enough for the main meal plus sandwiches or a weeknight dinner from the same cook.

The Verdict: Nothing else on this list covers as much ground from a single Sunday investment — pot roast, shredded tacos, next-day sandwiches — all at this price per pound.


4. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Boneless NY Strip Steak, priced per pound – $13.97/lb

Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Boneless NY Strip Steak, priced per pound

Four strip steaks on a tray, USDA Choice Angus, cut fresh daily — the NY strip delivers bold beefy flavor backed by a fat cap that renders into the crust during a hot sear and moderate marbling that keeps the interior juicy without demanding much technique. At $13.97 a pound it sits comfortably between the economical sirloin and the pricier ribeye, and it handles both cast iron and outdoor grill without complaint. The extra portions slice cleanly for fajitas or a steak salad the following evening.

The Verdict: The dependable workhorse of the steak case — consistent enough to cook most Sundays, versatile enough to repurpose whatever is left over.


5. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Bone-In Short Ribs, priced per pound – $11.97/lb

Kalbi and classic beef braise are very different preparations, but they share one foundation: bone-in short ribs. These sliced USDA Choice Angus ribs arrive fresh, never frozen, and perform well in both a long oven braise and a quick high-heat marinade-and-grill for Korean-style preparation. At $11.97 a pound, the bone and fat translate directly into deep, savory flavor, and the results — braised in wine and aromatics or grilled over charcoal — are rich enough to anchor a Sunday table on their own.

The Verdict: Anyone who braises regularly already knows this cut delivers; those new to it should know the patience required is modest compared to the result.


6. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Boneless Top Sirloin Steaks, priced per pound – $9.97/lb

Member's Mark USDA Choice Angus Beef Boneless Top Sirloin Steaks, priced per pound

Roughly six steaks per tray at $9.97 a pound makes the top sirloin the most practical steak for a Sunday dinner feeding the whole household — USDA Choice Angus, aged for tenderness, and cut fresh daily. The sirloin runs leaner than a ribeye, which means high heat in a cast-iron pan is the right tool, but the clean, beefy flavor holds up without needing a marinade. The count also suits cutting into cubes for kabobs, an easy Sunday alternative to a straight steak dinner.

The Verdict: The smart everyday steak for a family table — honest flavor at a price that turns Sunday steak night into a weekly habit rather than a special occasion.


7. Member’s Mark USDA Choice Angus Whole Beef Extra Trim Tenderloins, Cryovac, priced per pound – $29.97/lb

Weekend dinner planning changes when a whole vacuum-packed tenderloin is the starting point rather than a tray of pre-cut steaks. Hand-selected from grain-fed U.S. cattle, extra-trimmed, and sealed in cryovac for freshness, this whole tenderloin can be roasted intact as a table centerpiece or portioned into individual steaks before cooking — either way, the per-serving cost typically works out well below what pre-cut filet mignons command at the same club. At $29.97 a pound it is the highest-priced cut on this list, and it rewards the household that is comfortable with a whole loin and a sharp knife.

The Verdict: A worthwhile investment for confident home cooks who want an impressive Sunday centerpiece; anyone expecting pre-portioned convenience is better served by the filet mignon tray.

Keep Reading

Related posts

Determined woman throws darts at target for concept of business success and achieving set goals

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.