Which Costco Yogurts Truly Deserve a Spot in Your Cart?

Costco shoppers know the yogurt aisle can be overwhelming. Between family-sized tubs, protein-packed singles, and probiotic blends, it’s hard to tell which options are worth your money and which ones you can skip.

We sorted through reviews, expert rankings, and taste tests to narrow down the selection. Here are the Costco yogurts that truly deserve a spot in your cart—and two that you may want to pass on.

Avoid: Chobani 20 Grams Protein Greek Yogurt Variety Pack

While this high-protein pack delivers on flavor and satiety, Costco’s price tag makes it less appealing. Sam’s Club often sells the exact product for a lower cost.

Nutrition (per 6.7 oz cup): 140 calories, 3g fat, 8–9g carbs, 7g sugar, 20g protein

Why Skip: Great yogurt, but better deals are found outside of Costco.

Avoid: Chobani Greek Yogurt Variety Pack

This 20-pack is heavy on fruit flavors and comes with fruit-on-the-bottom cups that aren’t everyone’s favorite. It’s also pricier at Costco compared to Sam’s Club.

Nutrition (per 5.3 oz cup): 110 calories, 0g fat, 15g carbs, 14g sugar, 11g protein

Why Skip: High sugar, lower protein than other options, and not the best value.

Buy: Kirkland Signature Organic Greek Yogurt

Costco’s house brand rarely disappoints, and the Kirkland Signature Organic Greek Yogurt proves it. This nonfat plain yogurt is thick, tangy, and incredibly versatile. Add honey, fruit, or granola for breakfast, or use it as a base for sauces and baked goods.

Nutrition (per ⅔ cup): 100 calories, 0g fat, 7g carbs, 3g sugar, 18g protein

Why Buy: Excellent protein content, unbeatable price, and endless versatility.

Buy: Organic Bellwether A2 Whole Milk Yogurt

This luxurious yogurt is all about flavor. Creamy and rich with a thinner consistency than Greek, it feels more like a decadent dessert than a snack. Customers love it plain or paired with honey and fresh berries.

Nutrition (per ¾ cup): 115 calories, 8g fat, 5g carbs, 3g sugar, 8g protein

Why Buy: Smooth texture, indulgent taste, and great value in Costco’s two-pack.

Buy: Vanilla Chobani Blended Greek Yogurt

If you prefer a ready-to-go option that’s lightly sweetened, the Vanilla Chobani Blended Greek Yogurt is a safe bet. It’s creamy, flavorful, and works well in breakfast parfaits or as a snack on its own.

Nutrition (per ¾ cup): 130 calories, 0g fat, 17g carbs, 16g sugar, 14g protein

Why Buy: Familiar flavor, smooth texture, and a family-friendly 40-ounce tub.

Buy: Oikos Triple Zero Greek Nonfat Yogurt

This variety pack is a win for anyone seeking a balanced snack. With zero added sugar, zero fat, and natural flavoring, Oikos Triple Zero satisfies without going overboard on calories.

Nutrition (per cup): 90 calories, 0g fat, 7g carbs, 5g sugar, 15g protein

Why Buy: Affordable, protein-rich, and kid-approved flavors like strawberry, mixed berry, and vanilla.

Buy: Yoplait Original Low Fat Yogurt Variety Pack

A classic family-friendly option, this 24-pack comes with peach, strawberry, and French vanilla flavors. Perfect for kids’ lunches or quick snacks.

Nutrition (per cup, varies by flavor): 140 calories, 1.5g fat, 26–27g carbs, 18–20g sugar, 5g protein

Why Buy: Crowd-pleasing flavors and portability, even if the sugar runs high.

Buy: Activia Lowfat Yogurt Variety Pack

Known for its probiotic benefits, Activia remains a popular choice. Costco’s price makes it even more appealing, especially with sales that drop it below $8 for 24 cups.

Nutrition (per cup): Around 90–100 calories, 1.5g fat, 18–19g carbs, 12–13g sugar, 4g protein

Why Buy: Smooth texture, digestive support, and unbeatable value when on promotion.

Final Thoughts

Costco offers a mix of indulgent, protein-packed, and probiotic-friendly yogurts that can fit any lifestyle. Standouts like Kirkland Organic Greek Yogurt, Bellwether A2 Yogurt, and Oikos Triple Zero are definite winners.

But not every pack is a smart buy—especially when price comparisons make Chobani variety packs more attractive elsewhere. With a little savvy, you’ll know exactly which Costco yogurts truly deserve space in your cart.