Thanksgiving is all about family, gratitude, and—of course—food. And while the turkey may take center stage, the grand finale of any feast is the dessert table. Whether you’re hosting a full spread or bringing something sweet to a friend’s gathering, Sam’s Club makes it easy to impress without the stress (or high price tags). From rich cheesecakes to spiced pumpkin treats, these seasonal bakery favorites are crowd-pleasers that look homemade but require zero baking effort.
Here are six Thanksgiving desserts from Sam’s Club that’ll have your guests asking for seconds — and the recipe.
Member’s Mark Pumpkin Spice Cake Balls – $18.98 / 24 Count
If you’re looking for a fun and shareable dessert, these pumpkin spice cake balls are the perfect pick. Each bite-sized treat combines moist pumpkin-flavored cake with a creamy coating and festive fall decorations. Ideal for party trays or as a little post-dinner sweet, they’re priced at just 79¢ each, making them a steal for entertaining a crowd. The warm spice notes, rich pumpkin essence, and soft texture make these bite-sized delights a standout at any Thanksgiving table.
Member’s Mark 12″ Pumpkin Pie – $5.98 / 58 oz
No Thanksgiving dessert spread is complete without a classic pumpkin pie. Sam’s Club’s version is legendary — freshly baked daily in-store, with a silky spiced pumpkin filling and flaky golden crust. Each 12-inch pie serves 11–14 guests, making it a convenient and budget-friendly option for big gatherings. At just under six dollars, this bakery favorite delivers homemade quality without the hassle of mixing, rolling, or baking.
Member’s Mark 9″ New York-Style Pumpkin Cheesecake – $18.84 / 60 oz
This indulgent cheesecake merges the creamy decadence of New York-style cheesecake with the cozy flavors of pumpkin pie. Nestled on a buttery graham cracker crust, it offers velvety smooth texture and rich autumn spice in every forkful. It serves up to 14 people at only $1.35 per slice, making it an affordable yet luxurious finish to your Thanksgiving meal. Enjoy it chilled, thawed, or even semi-frozen for a refreshing twist on tradition.
You May Be Interested In
Sublime Desserts Assorted Macarons – $14.94 / 36 Count
Add a colorful, elegant touch to your Thanksgiving dessert display with these assorted macarons. Each pack includes 36 delicate cookies in a variety of flavors, from rich chocolate to fruity favorites, at just 41¢ each. The crisp shells and soft, creamy fillings make them an instant hit for guests who prefer a lighter sweet. These dainty French confections look beautiful on platters and make a delightful palate cleanser after a heavy holiday meal.
Member’s Mark 12″ Pecan Pie – $12.98 / 70 oz
Loaded with Georgia pecans and a luscious caramel filling, this pie is pure Southern comfort in every bite. Its buttery crust and nutty-sweet balance make it one of Sam’s Club’s most beloved seasonal desserts, earning rave reviews and a 4.7-star customer rating. Whether warmed with whipped cream or served at room temperature, it’s a rich, decadent way to round out Thanksgiving dinner — and at a fraction of bakery prices.
Member’s Mark Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cake Roll – $8.97 / 26 oz
Soft, spiced pumpkin cake meets rich cream cheese frosting in this rolled masterpiece made fresh daily in Sam’s Club bakeries. The swirl of tangy-sweet filling adds just the right contrast to the lightly spiced sponge, creating a dessert that tastes homemade (without you turning on the oven). With 11 servings, it’s perfect for family gatherings or office potlucks and costs less than a single slice of bakery cake elsewhere.
Final Thoughts
With Thanksgiving desserts this good (and affordable), you can skip the baking stress and still serve a show-stopping spread. Sam’s Club delivers bakery-quality treats that rival homemade favorites — from the flaky pecan pie to the creamy pumpkin cheesecake and festive macarons. Each dessert offers incredible value, generous portions, and seasonal flavors that make celebrating easy and memorable.
So, whether you’re hosting dinner or just bringing dessert, Sam’s Club has you covered — sweetly, affordably, and deliciously.
Recommended For You
