Thanksgiving leftovers deserve a plan. These ten Sam’s Club picks cover every layer of a leftover sandwich — bread, protein, cheese, sauce — so the day-after meal comes together without a trip anywhere.
1. Member’s Mark Cranberry Orange Walnut Boule, 32 oz. – $7.96

Baked fresh in-club daily, this 32-ounce boule brings dried cranberries, crunchy walnuts, and orange zest to what would otherwise be an ordinary leftover sandwich. The flavor leans sweet-tart in a way that complements both turkey and ham — a natural upgrade over plain sandwich bread for the day after Thanksgiving.
Taste: Dense enough to hold up to stacking — sliced turkey, mashed potatoes as a spread, a stripe of cream cheese dip — without going soggy fast. The cranberry-orange sweetness comes through in every bite, with walnut pieces adding a periodic crunch that plain white bread simply cannot match.
Make It Better: Toast the slices before building — the crust firms up and the orange notes intensify. An open-faced hot turkey sandwich on this bread, finished under the broiler, is the best use of the whole loaf.
Worth It?: Worth it — the most distinctive bread choice in the deli bakery case, and the right one for Thanksgiving leftovers.
2. Member’s Mark Hickory Smoked Whole Turkey, priced per pound – $2.98/lb

At $2.98 a pound, the hickory smoked whole turkey is fully cooked and ready to slice — the actual leftover Thanksgiving provides here. Thin-sliced cold, it stacks cleanly onto toasted cranberry boule; pulled apart in rough shreds, it becomes a French dip filling ready to dunk in warm turkey gravy.
Taste: Hickory smoke gives the meat a deeper, more complex flavor than a plain roasted bird. The texture is juicy and easy to work with — either carved into neat slices for a club or pulled into shreds for a more casual build.
Make It Better: Refrigerate the whole bird and slice as needed over the following three days. Cold turkey on toasted cranberry boule with a spread of cranberry jalapeño dip needs nothing else.
Worth It?: The anchor of the whole list — everything else here is built around what’s left of this bird.
3. Member’s Mark Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes, 32 oz. each, 2 ct. – $6.87

Marked down from $7.87, the two-pack of Yukon Gold mashed potatoes functions as both a side dish at dinner and a ready-made spread the morning after. Made with real butter and whole milk, they go from fridge to warm in about seven minutes in the microwave.
Taste: Smooth and creamy without the gluey texture that boxed mash produces — the Yukon Gold base gives them a naturally buttery flavor that holds up even when served cold. Spread on toast, they read like a compound butter; warmed and ladled over sliced turkey on a roll, the effect is closer to an open-faced hot sandwich.
Make It Better: Use them as the base layer on toasted boule slices topped with sliced turkey and a pour of warm turkey gravy — the spread’s natural creaminess does most of the work.
Worth It?: At this price, the two-pack is a straightforward call — the second container earns its keep the day after Thanksgiving.
4. Member’s Mark Macaroni and Cheese, priced per pound – $3.24/lb

Al dente pasta covered in a rich cheese sauce, this Italian-style mac and cheese is prepared fresh in-club daily and sized for a family feast — but it’s the second-day sandwich application that makes it worth picking up. At $3.24 a pound, it’s priced in line with other fresh-prepared deli sides.
Taste: The cheese sauce is rich and straightforwardly savory — not overly sharp, not watery — and the al dente pasta holds its shape and structure after the initial cook. Layered between bread, it stays cohesive rather than falling apart or turning greasy.
Make It Better: Layer cold mac and cheese onto toasted boule with sliced smoked turkey and a few strips of fully cooked bacon — the bacon provides the crunch; the boule holds the weight.
Worth It?: Unusual on paper, but a mac-and-cheese club made from holiday leftovers is one of those combinations that earns repeat requests.
5. Member’s Mark Boneless Uncured Carver Ham, Priced Per Pound – $2.97/lb

Fully cooked and boneless, the uncured carver ham is priced at $2.97 a pound and built for effortless slicing. The absence of nitrates and nitrites is worth noting for those who pay attention to that; the absence of a bone means the whole thing carves quickly and cleanly the morning after the feast.
Taste: Juicy with a natural, off-the-bone flavor — it reads less processed than standard deli ham. Thin slices hold their moisture well, making them as good cold in a sandwich as they are served slightly warm.
Make It Better: Stack thin ham slices with baby Swiss on a warmed King’s Hawaiian roll — the sweetness of the bread and the mild nuttiness of the cheese frame the ham cleanly. A smear of cranberry jalapeño dip on the top bun turns the whole thing into something worth writing down.
Worth It?: Good value at the per-pound price, and the second protein in the leftover rotation keeps things varied through the weekend.
6. Member’s Mark Cranberry Jalapeno Dip, 24 oz. – $6.46

Dried cranberries and diced jalapeños blended into a cream cheese and sour cream base — this 24-ounce dip is an exclusive Member’s Mark recipe and the kind of item that sells out before the holiday. At $6.46, it is the most versatile condiment on this list by a margin.
Taste: The cranberry sweetness arrives first, then the jalapeño follows without overpowering. The cream cheese base keeps everything smooth and spreadable straight from the refrigerator, with enough cranberry pieces in each spoonful to make the flavor unmistakably seasonal.
Make It Better: Use it as the primary spread in place of mayo or mustard on any turkey or ham sandwich. On the cranberry-orange boule with smoked turkey and Swiss, it doubles down on the cranberry theme in a way that feels intentional rather than accidental.
Worth It?: Genuinely seasonal and genuinely useful — if it’s in stock, buying a second container is the right call.
7. Member’s Mark Homestyle Turkey Gravy, Refrigerated, 2 pk., 48 oz. – $7.64

The two-pack of homestyle turkey gravy exists for two purposes: one container for the Thanksgiving feast, one for the French-dip sandwiches that follow. Seasoned with onion, celery, black pepper, and thyme, and made from turkey dark meat, it reads like a scratch recipe that happens to come in a refrigerated container.
Taste: Smooth and pourable when heated, with real turkey flavor and herbal depth from the thyme and black pepper — it does not taste canned. The texture is thick enough to coat without being gluey, which matters when it functions as a dipping sauce rather than a topping.
Make It Better: Heat a portion in the microwave, pour into a small bowl, and serve alongside a toasted roll packed with sliced smoked turkey and Swiss — dunk before each bite.
Worth It?: The two-pack at $7.64 is the reason this works as a system — one container disappears at dinner, the other is waiting for the sandwiches.
8. King’s Hawaiian Original Dinner Rolls 32 ct. – $6.68

Soft, slightly sweet Hawaiian rolls in a 32-count tray — the format that made every leftover sandwich smaller, faster, and more shareable. At $6.68 for 32 rolls, the per-roll cost makes them the most economical vessel on this list for assembling a crowd’s worth of day-after sliders.
Taste: Light and fluffy with a mild sweetness that offsets savory fillings without competing with them. The rolls don’t need toasting to be enjoyable, but a brief warm-up firms the bottom crust and makes splitting them cleanly much easier.
Make It Better: For a crowd, slice the entire connected batch through the middle before separating the rolls, fill the tray in bulk with turkey, ham, and a stripe of cranberry jalapeño dip, then cut into individual sandwiches.
Worth It?: Crowd-tested and reliable — the right format for anyone feeding a group from holiday leftovers the next day.
9. Member’s Mark Baby Swiss Cheese Slices 2 lbs. – $7.84

Mild and nutty, baby Swiss is the cheese that works equally well cold on a turkey club or briefly pressed on a ham-and-Swiss slider. The 2-pound resealable package, made from rBST/rBGH-free cow’s milk, holds enough slices to cover every sandwich combination in this list with stock left for the rest of the week.
Taste: The flavor sits in a mild, faintly nutty register with a natural creaminess that becomes more pronounced when the cheese is warmed. The slices separate cleanly, hold their shape under stacked ingredients, and don’t turn rubbery under heat.
Make It Better: Two slices over thin-cut ham on a King’s Hawaiian roll, pressed in a dry skillet for 90 seconds per side, produces a hot press that lands closer to a croque-monsieur than a standard leftover sandwich.
Worth It?: A 2-pound resealable block at $7.84 lasts the whole weekend — the utility purchase that belongs in the cart alongside the proteins.
10. Member’s Mark Fully Cooked Bacon, 10.5 oz. – $10.84

Thick-cut, double-smoked, and fully cooked — this 10.5-ounce pack of about 36 slices has been marked down from $12.84 and requires nothing but a few seconds in the microwave. The double-smoke delivers a richer flavor than typical fully cooked bacon, and the thick cut keeps the strips intact under turkey, cheese, and spreads.
Taste: Dense and richly smoky, with the texture of bacon that crisped in the cooking process rather than steamed. The thick cut provides real structural resistance — a strip holds its shape against sliced turkey and a smear of cranberry jalapeño dip without folding into the build.
Make It Better: Two strips on toasted cranberry boule with sliced smoked turkey, baby Swiss, and cranberry jalapeño dip is the complete turkey club — assembled without a pan.
Worth It?: The markdown to $10.84 makes it an easy addition — fully cooked, warming in seconds, and the final piece in a club sandwich that actually tastes like effort went into it.


