We Ranked 12 Aldi Ice Cream (Here’s the Best and Worst)

Not all Aldi ice creams are created equal. Some are rich and packed with flavor, while others feel like a letdown after the first bite. Whether you’re hunting for a creamy classic or something loaded with mix-ins, we’ve sorted through the lineup to find the best and worst options. No need to guess which pint is worth grabbing, this list has got you covered. Let’s break it down, from the least impressive to the absolute best.

12. Sundae Shoppe Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

This vanilla bean ice cream offers a mild flavor that some may find underwhelming. While it provides a creamy texture, the vanilla notes lack depth, resulting in a somewhat bland experience. It’s suitable as a base for toppings but doesn’t stand out on its own. For those seeking a more robust vanilla taste, other options might be preferable. Overall, it’s a decent choice but not particularly remarkable.

11. Sundae Shoppe Chocolate Ice Cream

This chocolate ice cream leans heavily on cocoa powder, resulting in a somewhat bitter taste. The sweetness is minimal, and the texture isn’t as creamy as other offerings. Chocolate enthusiasts might find it lacking in richness and depth. There are better chocolate options available within Aldi’s range. Its simplicity doesn’t quite capture the indulgence expected from chocolate ice cream. ​

10. Thank You Cherry Much!

Aldi’s attempt at a cherry-flavored ice cream falls short due to its overpowering and somewhat medicinal cherry taste. The inclusion of chocolate chunks doesn’t sufficiently balance the intense flavor. Some consumers might find the cherry notes reminiscent of cough syrup. While the texture is acceptable, the overall flavor profile may not appeal to everyone. It’s a divisive option that caters to specific palates.

9. Sundae Shoppe Cookie Dough Ice Cream

This cookie dough ice cream features a vanilla base with chocolate chunks and cookie dough pieces. However, the mix-ins are sparse, leading to a predominantly plain vanilla experience. The cookie dough chunks, when present, add a pleasant texture but are too infrequent to make a significant impact. Overall, it lacks the indulgence expected from a cookie dough flavor. Those seeking a more generous distribution of mix-ins might be disappointed.

8. Sundae Shoppe Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

This mint chocolate chip ice cream delivers a strong mint flavor that some may find overpowering. The chocolate chips tend to get lost amidst the intense mintiness. The texture is creamy, but the balance between mint and chocolate is lacking. Those who prefer a milder mint flavor might find this option too intense. It’s a refreshing choice but could benefit from a more harmonious flavor distribution. ​

7. Make Fudge Not War!

This flavor is Aldi’s take on a chocolate fudge brownie ice cream. It features a rich chocolate base with fudge swirls and brownie chunks. The brownie pieces add a chewy texture, complementing the creamy ice cream. However, some may find the chocolate flavor leaning towards cocoa bitterness. Overall, it’s a decadent option for chocolate lovers seeking a fudge-infused treat.

6. Sundae Shoppe Strawberry Ice Cream

This strawberry ice cream offers a subtle fruit flavor, with a creamy base that is neither too sweet nor too bland. While it lacks prominent strawberry chunks, it serves as a decent option for those seeking a mild strawberry taste. Enhancing it with fresh strawberries can elevate the flavor. It’s a satisfactory choice for traditionalists who enjoy straightforward fruit flavors. The simplicity of this ice cream allows for versatility in serving options. ​

5. Sundae Shoppe Sea Salt Caramel Light Ice Cream

Marketed as a lighter option with reduced fat and calories, this ice cream delivers a creamy texture but falls short on flavor. The expected sea salt and caramel notes are subdued, resulting in a more generic taste. While suitable for those monitoring their calorie intake, it may not satisfy cravings for a rich caramel experience. Its lightness might appeal to some, but others could find it lacking in depth. The compromise on flavor for reduced calories is noticeable. ​

4. Sundae Shoppe Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

This ice cream captures the classic taste of cookies and cream, reminiscent of Oreo cookies. The base mimics the creamy filling, while abundant cookie bits provide the characteristic chocolate wafer crunch. Its soft and scoopable texture makes it ideal for parties or casual desserts. The nostalgic flavor profile appeals to both children and adults alike. Its faithful representation of the classic treat has earned it high marks among reviewers. ​

3. Sundae Shoppe Moose Tracks Ice Cream

This variety combines creamy vanilla ice cream with rich fudge swirls and mini peanut butter cups. The peanut butter cups are notably flavorful, adding a delightful texture contrast. The fudge swirl contributes to a sundae-like experience straight from the tub. For peanut butter enthusiasts, this flavor is particularly appealing. Its combination of elements creates a harmonious and indulgent treat. ​

2. Sundae Shoppe Butter Pecan Ice Cream

This ice cream features crunchy pecans embedded in a creamy base, delivering the classic butter pecan experience. The nuts retain their crunchiness, providing a pleasant textural contrast. The base is smooth and rich, complementing the nuttiness without being overly sweet. It’s a solid choice for fans of nutty ice cream flavors. The quality of the pecans and the balanced sweetness make it a noteworthy option.

1. Sundae Shoppe Brookie Dough

Combining the best of both worlds, this flavor features chewy brownie pieces and cookie dough chunks within a creamy base. The brownie bits are particularly rich and flavorful, offering a genuine baked-good taste. While the cookie dough can be slightly crumbly, the overall experience remains delightful. It’s an excellent choice for those who can’t decide between brownies and cookies. The combination of textures and flavors provides a satisfying dessert experience.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

20 Chic Walmart Home Decor Picks That Look High-End

You don’t have to spend a fortune to make your home look stylish and high-end. Walmart has some seriously chic decor pieces that give off designer vibes without the hefty price tag. Read More.

14 Affordable and Stylish Target Clothing Picks That Are Worth Every Penny

Finding stylish and affordable clothing does not have to be a challenge, especially when Target offers so many trendy options. Whether you are looking for cozy sweaters, versatile jeans, or statement pieces, there is something for every style and budget. Read More.

10 Best Costco Bargains You Need in Your Cart Today

Costco is packed with amazing deals, but some bargains stand out more than others. From healthy snacks to pantry staples, there are plenty of must-have items that offer great value. Read More.