The 12 Most Disappointing Costco Items, According to Shoppers

Costco is known for offering incredible deals and a wide variety of products that customers love, but not everything on their shelves gets rave reviews. Some items leave shoppers feeling disappointed, either because of quality issues, flavor that misses the mark, or an expectation that just isn’t met. While Costco’s bulk deals are often a win, there are a few products that many say are not worth the hype. Whether it is frozen food that lacks flavor or household items that fall apart too quickly, these items have left shoppers frustrated.

Chef Ramsay Beef Wellington Bites

The Chef Ramsay Beef Wellington Bites sold at Costco may sound gourmet, but they often disappoint shoppers. Many find the pastry to be soggy and the beef inside lacking the rich flavor expected from such a premium dish. The filling can also be inconsistent, with some bites containing more mushroom than beef. While the idea of enjoying a fancy appetizer at home is appealing, the execution does not live up to the name. For the price, many shoppers feel this product falls short of expectations.

Filet Mignon

Costco’s filet mignon is often marketed as a premium cut, but it does not always deliver the tenderness and flavor shoppers expect. Some customers have reported uneven cuts or excessive fat for such an expensive item. Others feel the quality is inconsistent compared to specialty butcher shops or even other Costco cuts. While it is convenient to buy in bulk, filet mignon is one of those items where quality often outweighs quantity. Many suggest paying a little more for a better experience elsewhere.

Stonefire Mini Naan

Stonefire Mini Naan at Costco is convenient for quick meals, but the texture and freshness can be disappointing. Shoppers often find the bread to be dry and not as soft or flavorful as freshly made naan. Reheating does not always help, as it can turn rubbery or too hard. While the bulk price is tempting, many feel the quality does not justify the purchase. If you are looking for authentic naan, homemade or restaurant options may be better choices.

Fresh Produce

Costco’s fresh produce section is hit or miss, with many shoppers feeling disappointed by the shelf life of some items. While the prices are great for bulk purchases, fruits and vegetables often spoil quickly, leaving customers feeling like they wasted money. Certain items, like berries or leafy greens, are especially prone to wilting or molding faster than expected. The large portions can also be overwhelming for smaller households. Many shoppers suggest being cautious with perishable produce from Costco.

Kirkland Signature Drinking Water

Kirkland Signature Drinking Water is affordable, but many shoppers have concerns about the taste and packaging quality. Some report a plastic-like aftertaste that makes the water less refreshing compared to other brands. The bottles themselves can feel flimsy, often crinkling or leaking, which adds to the frustration. While it is a budget-friendly option for bulk water, many feel it does not meet the same standards as other Costco items. If taste and quality are priorities, this may not be the best choice.

Ribeye Steaks

Costco’s ribeye steaks, while convenient for bulk purchases, do not always live up to shoppers’ expectations for premium cuts of meat. Some customers find the marbling inconsistent, leading to steaks that are either too fatty or too tough. Others have noted that the flavor does not match the price, especially compared to ribeye from a butcher shop. While they are an easy option for grilling at home, the quality may not satisfy steak lovers looking for something exceptional. Many feel it is worth seeking out better options elsewhere.

Muffins

Costco’s muffins are a popular item, but not everyone is a fan of their overly sweet and dense texture. Many shoppers find them to be more like cake than a traditional muffin, which can be off-putting for those looking for a lighter treat. The large size can also be overwhelming, with some customers feeling they are paying for quantity over quality. Additionally, the flavors can lack balance, with some varieties tasting artificial. While they are a convenient option for breakfast or snacks, they do not appeal to everyone.

Chicken Pot Pie

Costco’s chicken pot pie is a hearty meal option, but it has not won over all shoppers. Many find the crust to be too thick and doughy, overpowering the filling. The chicken and vegetables inside can feel bland or under-seasoned, leaving the overall flavor unsatisfying. While the large size makes it great for families, the quality does not always match the convenience. For those looking for a comforting pot pie, homemade or other store-bought options may be more satisfying.

Sandwiches & Wraps

The sandwiches and wraps from Costco’s deli section may look appealing, but many shoppers have found them underwhelming. Common complaints include dry bread or wraps that fall apart too easily, as well as fillings that lack freshness or flavor. The portion sizes can be inconsistent, and some customers feel the price is not justified for the quality provided. While they are convenient for quick meals, they do not always deliver the taste or satisfaction expected. Many suggest skipping these and assembling your own at home.

Rotisserie Chicken

Costco’s rotisserie chicken is widely loved, but it does have its critics. Some shoppers have noticed the chicken can be overly salty or have inconsistent seasoning. Others have reported that certain chickens are undercooked or lack the juicy tenderness that made them famous. While it remains a great deal for its price, the quality can vary depending on the batch. For those who prioritize consistency, cooking your own chicken at home may be a better option.

Deli Street Tacos

The deli street tacos kit from Costco has left many shoppers feeling let down. While the idea of a ready-to-assemble taco kit is convenient, the ingredients often lack flavor and freshness. The tortillas can be stiff or break apart, and the meat is sometimes too dry or bland. The portion sizes are decent, but the overall experience does not live up to the expectations of a flavorful taco night. For authentic street tacos, many recommend skipping the kit and making them from scratch.

Kirkland Signature Shrimp Salad

The Kirkland Signature Shrimp Salad is a refreshing and flavorful option for quick meals or entertaining guests. Packed with tender, juicy shrimp and a creamy, seasoned dressing, this salad is perfect as a main dish or a side. It features crisp vegetables that add a satisfying crunch and balance to the rich flavors. Serve it on its own, over a bed of greens, or with crackers for a light and delicious snack. Its freshness and high-quality ingredients make it a standout option in Costco’s deli section.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

12 Must-Have Trader Joe‘s Products for Your Bar Cart

A well-stocked bar cart is the key to elevating any gathering, whether it is a lively party or a quiet evening at home. It sets the stage for creativity, fun, and the perfect drinks to match every occasion. Read More.

The 12 Best Holiday Desserts at Costco, Ranked for Your Sweet Tooth

The holiday season is here, and with it comes the chance to indulge in all the delicious treats that make this time of year so special. Costco is a treasure trove for festive desserts, offering a wide range of mouthwatering options that cater to every sweet tooth. Read More.

17 Target’s Top Kitchen Products You Shouldn’t Miss

If you are on the hunt for top-notch kitchen products that combine functionality and style, Target is the place to be. With a wide selection of tools, gadgets, and appliances, it is easy to find what you need for your kitchen. Read More.