The 13 Best Peanut Butters for Every Taste, Ranked

Peanut butter is more than just a pantry staple. It is a comfort food, a protein-packed snack, and a nostalgic favorite for all ages. With so many brands on the market, choosing the best one can feel overwhelming. Some brands prioritize health and simplicity, while others focus on smooth texture and bold flavor. To help you find which jars deserve a spot on your shelf, here is a ranking of some of the best peanut butter brands.

13. Once Again Organic Peanut Butter

Once Again Organic Peanut Butter is made with minimal ingredients, appealing to those seeking a clean-label spread. It is USDA-certified organic and non-GMO, which adds to its health credentials. However, many consumers find the texture excessively runny, even after stirring. The flavor is often described as muted or bland compared to more robust options. It separates easily, requiring frequent mixing, which can be inconvenient for daily use. Despite its natural origins, it struggles to impress on taste alone. This places it at the bottom of the ranking for overall enjoyment.

12. Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter

Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter is a long-standing option for those looking for a more traditional, natural spread. It contains no hydrogenated oils and boasts a short ingredient list. Unfortunately, the texture is often criticized for being gritty and hard to spread. Many reviewers also mention a strong roasted flavor that borders on burnt. The oil separation is significant and makes mixing a challenge. Though affordable and widely available, its taste and usability fall short. This leaves it trailing behind more refined natural peanut butters.

11. Whole Foods 365 Organic Peanut Butter

Whole Foods 365 Organic Peanut Butter offers shoppers an affordable organic option. It uses only peanuts and salt, which is great for those avoiding added sugars or oils. However, the consistency is difficult to work with due to heavy oil separation. Stirring takes time and effort, and the spread never quite becomes creamy. The flavor is decent but not particularly memorable. Health-focused consumers might appreciate the clean label, but flavor enthusiasts will likely pass. As a result, it ranks low despite good intentions.

10. PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter

PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter stands out for its unique format—powdered peanuts that you reconstitute with water. It is ideal for people looking to cut fat and calories from their diet. Fitness communities appreciate its portability and protein content. However, the taste is noticeably lighter and lacks the creaminess of traditional peanut butter. The texture can be chalky, depending on how it is mixed. It serves a purpose in smoothies and baking more than as a spread. While innovative, it is not a go-to for classic PB flavor.

9. MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter

MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter is a premium option made with high-quality, organic ingredients. It is praised for its sweet, mild peanut flavor and smooth texture. However, it has a runny consistency that turns sticky after a few bites. This can make it messy to use on toast or sandwiches. While some enjoy its subtle sweetness, others find it lacks depth. It works better in recipes than as a stand-alone spread. Overall, it is a mixed bag for those looking for a balanced peanut butter experience.

8. Adam’s Natural Peanut Butter

Adam’s Natural Peanut Butter is a fan favorite among traditionalists who prefer simple, wholesome ingredients. It contains no preservatives, added sugar, or hydrogenated oils. The flavor is robust and earthy, offering a bold peanut punch. However, its thick oil layer demands thorough and sometimes frustrating mixing. Once stirred, it maintains a decent consistency but still requires refrigeration. It is a strong contender for those who prioritize health over convenience. It earns mid-tier status for balancing nutrition with solid, natural flavor.

7. Kirkland Signature Peanut Butter

Kirkland Signature Peanut Butter delivers big value with impressive quality. Made from just peanuts and salt, it appeals to those seeking a natural product. It has a creamy consistency once stirred and a pleasantly roasted taste. Consumers appreciate the large jar size and affordability. Though it may require some mixing, it holds up well for everyday use. It is a solid staple in households that shop at Costco. Its combination of price, taste, and texture makes it a worthy contender.

6. Teddie Peanut Butter

Teddie Peanut Butter is a family-owned brand that has built a loyal following. Its all-natural formula contains no added sugars or oils, focusing purely on roasted peanuts. The taste is rich and toasty, with a satisfying crunch in its crunchy version. Stirring is required, but the payoff is a thick, hearty spread. Many fans describe it as the most “peanut-forward” brand on the market. It is especially popular in New England, where it has cult status. Teddie earns its spot for authenticity and flavor.

5. Trader Joe’s Crunchy Peanut Butter

Trader Joe’s Crunchy Peanut Butter stands out for its bold roasted flavor and satisfying crunch. It contains only peanuts and salt, staying true to a natural formula. The chunky texture gives it a homemade feel that appeals to many. However, some find the flavor slightly bitter compared to sweeter competitors. It does separate, so stirring is necessary before spreading. Despite that, its deep roast and affordability win fans. Trader Joe’s delivers a punchy, no-frills peanut butter that tastes like it came from a small batch.

4. Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter

Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter is known for its sleek packaging and premium quality. It is made with dry-roasted peanuts and a touch of palm oil to keep it spreadable. The result is a smooth, clean-tasting spread with minimal separation. The flavor is mildly sweet with a natural finish that appeals to both kids and adults. It also comes in convenient squeeze packs for on-the-go snacking. Though a bit more expensive, the taste and texture justify the cost. Justin’s secures a top spot with style and substance.

3. Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanut Butter

Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanut Butter is about as pure as it gets, just peanuts and nothing else. It has no sugar, salt, or oils, making it a favorite among clean eaters. The texture is slightly runny but spreads smoothly once stirred. The flavor is earthy and unmasked, letting the peanut shine through. It is ideal for those who want total control over sweetness and saltiness. Though it may seem plain to some, others love its honest simplicity. It ranks high for delivering on both health and flavor.

2. Skippy

Skippy is a household name that has stood the test of time. Its creamy version is beloved for its perfectly smooth texture and slightly sweet, salty flavor. It spreads effortlessly on bread and is ideal for PB&J sandwiches. Skippy also offers crunchy, low-fat, and natural versions to fit different preferences. While not the most natural option, it wins on reliability and taste. It is kid-friendly and has nostalgic value for many adults. Skippy remains a classic for a reason.

1. Jif

Jif consistently takes the crown in peanut butter taste tests. Its creamy texture, sweet-savory balance, and unmistakable flavor make it a standout. It spreads like a dream and delivers the perfect bite every time. The brand has remained a top seller for decades, with loyal fans across generations. Jif also makes variations like Natural and No Sugar Added to cater to broader preferences. Its classic red lid is instantly recognizable on store shelves. For its unbeatable flavor and consistency, Jif holds the number one spot.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

12 Household Cleaning Staples You Should Only Buy at Costco

Keeping your home clean can feel like a never-ending task, but having the right supplies makes all the difference. Costco is one of the best places to stock up on household cleaning staples. Read More.

12 Must-Have New Costco Products to Pick Up Before March Ends

As March comes to a close, Costco is offering some must-have new products that you will not want to miss. These new arrivals will definitely make your shopping experience even more enjoyable and will offer great value for money. Read More.

The 15 Best Member’s Mark Deals at Sam’s Club This March

Member’s Mark at Sam’s Club offers a wide variety of products that combine quality and affordability. Plus, with so many products to choose from, you can find everything you need in one convenient location. Read More.