15 Popular Peanut Butter Brands, Ranked

Peanut butter is one of those timeless foods that people just can’t get enough of. Whether you’re spreading it on toast, mixing it into a smoothie, or eating it straight from the jar, there’s something about that creamy (or crunchy) goodness that hits the spot every time. But with so many brands out there, it can be tough to figure out which one really deserves a place in your pantry. That’s why I’ve put together a list of some of the most popular peanut butter brands out there, ranked from good to absolute best. Each one has its own unique flavor and texture, so no matter what your preference is, there’s something here for everyone.

15. Peter Pan Peanut Butter

Peter Pan is an iconic brand that has been around for decades. Known for its classic creamy texture, it offers an affordable option for peanut butter lovers. While some praise its smooth consistency, critics note that its taste is overly sweet due to the added sugars. The brand’s classic flavor profile appeals to those who prefer a more processed, nostalgic taste. Despite its history, Peter Pan doesn’t always stand up to more natural competitors in terms of pure peanut flavor. Nevertheless, it remains a beloved staple for many.

14. PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter

PB2 is a powdered peanut butter that offers a unique, low-calorie alternative to traditional spreads. Made by pressing out most of the natural oils, it has significantly less fat and calories. It’s particularly popular with health-conscious consumers or those looking to reduce their fat intake. The taste, however, differs from regular peanut butter due to its altered texture and less creamy mouthfeel. While versatile in smoothies and recipes, PB2’s dry consistency doesn’t always satisfy those looking for a standard peanut butter experience. It’s a great option for dieters but lacks the indulgent richness of other brands.

13. Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter

Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter is celebrated for its minimal ingredients: just peanuts and salt. It offers a wholesome option for those who prefer a natural, unprocessed taste. However, it requires stirring, as the natural oils tend to separate from the peanuts. Some people love its raw, earthy flavor, while others find the need for mixing to be inconvenient. The lack of added sugars or preservatives makes it a healthier option, but this purity also means it lacks the sweetness that some consumers expect from their peanut butter. It’s a go-to for the health-conscious.

12. Smart Balance Peanut Butter

Smart Balance Peanut Butter is designed with heart health in mind, featuring added omega-3s from flaxseed oil. It offers a smooth texture and a well-balanced, slightly nutty taste. Despite its health-forward branding, some reviews note that it can be on the oily side due to the flaxseed addition. It’s not overly sweet, which appeals to people watching their sugar intake. While its health benefits make it attractive, the flavor doesn’t stand out as boldly as others in the ranking. Still, it’s a solid choice for those with dietary concerns looking for a balanced option.

11. Trader Joe’s Creamy Peanut Butter

Trader Joe’s has a loyal following, and their Creamy Peanut Butter is no exception. Made with Valencia peanuts, it boasts a rich, natural flavor without any added sugars or preservatives. While some appreciate its simplicity, others might find the texture to be a bit too grainy or oily compared to more mainstream brands. It’s a healthy option for those looking to avoid added ingredients. However, the need for stirring and the oil separation might be a deterrent for some consumers. Still, it’s an excellent choice for those seeking a more organic alternative.

10. Reese’s Peanut Butter

Reese’s Peanut Butter is inspired by the famous peanut butter cups, offering a sweet, dessert-like spread. It has a creamy consistency, but it’s significantly sweeter than most other brands on the market. This makes it a favorite among those with a sweet tooth, but not necessarily for peanut butter purists. The texture is smooth and spreadable, making it ideal for toast, desserts, or even straight from the jar. However, its high sugar content may turn off health-conscious consumers. Despite this, its signature sweetness gives it a special place in the hearts of Reese’s fans.

9. Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter

Justin’s is known for its high-quality, organic ingredients, and their Classic Peanut Butter lives up to that reputation. It has a slightly gritty texture, which some might love for its authenticity, while others may find it less smooth than traditional brands. The flavor is robust, with a strong peanut presence and minimal added sugars. The natural oils tend to separate, requiring a good stir before use, which can be a minor inconvenience. It’s a great choice for those looking for an organic, healthier option. However, the price point is higher than most other brands, which may be a drawback.

8. Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter

Skippy is one of the most well-known brands in the peanut butter world, offering a smooth and creamy texture that spreads easily. It has a sweet, balanced flavor that appeals to a wide audience, making it a go-to for families. While it’s not the most natural option due to added sugars and hydrogenated oils, it provides a classic, reliable taste. Skippy’s consistency is perfect for sandwiches, baking, and snacks. Its affordability and accessibility also make it a top contender in the market. Despite the additives, it remains a favorite among peanut butter fans.

7. Teddie Super Chunky Peanut Butter

Teddie Peanut Butter, particularly the Super Chunky variety, is a beloved choice among those who prefer a more textured spread. It’s made with only peanuts and salt, making it a natural option with no added sugars or oils. The large peanut chunks provide a satisfying crunch, and the flavor is rich and robust. It does require stirring, as the oils naturally separate, but the effort is well worth it for a fresh-tasting spread. Teddie is often praised for its authenticity and peanut-forward flavor. It’s a top choice for health-conscious consumers who enjoy a crunchy texture.

6. Brad’s Organic Peanut Butter

Brad’s Organic offers a simple, natural peanut butter made from organic peanuts with no added sugar or oils. It has a strong, earthy flavor that is more robust than sweeter, mass-produced brands. The texture is slightly gritty, which some find appealing for its authenticity, while others might prefer a smoother spread. It’s a bit pricier than conventional brands, but the organic certification and lack of preservatives make it worth it for those seeking a healthier option. Like many natural peanut butters, the oil separation requires stirring. However, its pure, unprocessed taste stands out.

5. Once Again Organic Peanut Butter

Once Again is a brand that prides itself on sustainability and organic practices. Their peanut butter is made from responsibly sourced peanuts and contains no added sugars or oils. The flavor is rich and nutty, with a slightly gritty texture that comes from the minimal processing. It’s a great option for those who prefer their peanut butter to be closer to the raw, natural flavor of peanuts. While it’s a bit more expensive than mainstream brands, its commitment to quality and environmental sustainability makes it a favorite among health-conscious consumers. Its eco-friendly packaging also appeals to many.

4. Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

Jif is a classic, and for many, it’s the gold standard in peanut butter. Known for its smooth texture and balanced sweetness, it’s perfect for everything from sandwiches to baking. While not the most natural option, it strikes a balance between flavor and affordability. The added sugars and oils give it a creaminess that many people find irresistible. It spreads easily, making it convenient for a variety of uses. Jif’s iconic taste has made it a household staple for generations, and despite the competition, it remains a top contender.

3. Fix & Fogg Peanut Butter

Fix & Fogg is a premium brand known for its high-quality, natural ingredients. Their peanut butter is made with slow-roasted peanuts, which gives it a deeper, more complex flavor. It has a slightly gritty texture that reflects its minimal processing and natural oil content. The brand offers several varieties, including smooth, crunchy, and flavored options, all made with the same commitment to quality. While it’s more expensive than mainstream brands, the taste and texture are well worth the extra cost. Fix & Fogg is a favorite among peanut butter enthusiasts looking for something special.

2. Spread the Love Naked Organic Peanut Butter

Spread the Love is a small-batch, organic peanut butter brand that offers an exceptionally pure product. Made with just peanuts, it has a rich, deep flavor that highlights the quality of the nuts used. There are no added sugars, oils, or preservatives, making it one of the cleanest options available. The texture is slightly gritty but very spreadable, making it a versatile choice for everything from toast to smoothies. Its premium price reflects the quality, and it has become a favorite among those looking for a healthier, more natural peanut butter. The brand’s commitment to sustainability also resonates with many consumers.

1. Wild Friends Classic Creamy Peanut Butter

Wild Friends takes the top spot for its smooth, creamy texture and bold peanut flavor. This brand is known for its natural ingredients and commitment to producing high-quality, flavorful peanut butter. Made without palm oil, Wild Friends offers a spread that is both creamy and easy to stir, with no oil separation. The taste is rich and peanut-forward, with just the right amount of salt to enhance the flavor. It’s a bit pricier than mainstream brands, but the quality of the ingredients and the brand’s focus on sustainability make it a standout. For peanut butter lovers, Wild Friends offers the perfect balance of flavor and texture.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

29 Delicious and Affordable Meals You’ll Love

Finding delicious meals on a tight budget doesn’t have to be hard. I’ve put together a list of 29 cheap and tasty meals that are perfect for any time you’re looking to save some money without sacrificing flavor. Read More.

10 Foods That Are Cheaper to Order Out Than Cook at Home

Eating out often gets a bad rap for being expensive, but that’s not always the case. Sometimes, grabbing a meal at your favorite spot can actually be lighter on the wallet than whipping it up in your own kitchen. Read More.

10 Chef-Approved Cooking Tips to Try in Your Own Kitchen

Cooking at home can be a joy, especially when you know a few tricks from the pros. Professional chefs have some amazing tips that can make your meals even more delicious and your time in the kitchen a lot more fun. Read More.