12 Five Below Products That Are Overpriced and Underwhelming

Not everything at Five Below is a steal. Sure, the store has some fun finds, but a few products just aren’t worth the hype. Some are lower quality than expected, while others are priced higher than you’d think for what you’re getting. It’s easy to get caught up in the excitement of bargain shopping, but not everything on the shelves is actually a good deal. Before you grab something just because it’s cheap, here are a few items that might leave you disappointed.

Self-Grip Hair Rollers, 6-Pack

This set includes three large and three smaller rollers. However, similar packs with more consistent sizing are available at other retailers for a lower price. The limited number of rollers may not suffice for individuals with thicker hair, necessitating multiple purchases. Additionally, the quality of these rollers has been questioned, with some users finding them less durable. Considering these factors, seeking alternatives elsewhere might provide better value.

Washcloth Set, 5-Count

Comprising five washcloths, this set has been criticized for its low-quality material, which tends to pill and fray quickly. Users have compared them to low-grade kitchen rags, expressing disappointment in their durability. Given the price point, higher-quality washcloths can be found at other retailers for a similar or even lower cost. Investing in better-quality options can ensure longevity and better performance.

Funko Bitty Pop! Blind Bags

These miniature collectibles are priced higher at Five Below compared to other retailers. While the allure of mystery blind bags is appealing, the elevated price point makes them less attractive. Collectors have noted that similar items are available elsewhere at more competitive prices, reducing the perceived value. For those looking to expand their collection affordably, exploring other purchasing options is advisable.

35mm Color Camera Film

Priced at $5.55 for a roll with only 10 exposures, this film offers limited value. In contrast, well-known brands like Kodak provide rolls with 24 exposures for just a few dollars more, offering a lower cost per picture. Photography enthusiasts have found the Five Below film to be less economical and potentially lower in quality. For those serious about film photography, investing in reputable brands ensures better results and more exposures per roll.

Spa Savvy 25-Piece Cosmetic Sponge Set

While a 25-piece set may seem like a bargain, the quality of these sponges has been questioned. Users have reported that the sponges are less durable and not as effective as those from other brands. Additionally, similar sets with better quality sponges are available at other retailers for a comparable price. Investing in higher-quality cosmetic sponges can lead to better makeup application and longer-lasting tools. ​

Shea Moisture Travel Size Curl & Shine Conditioner

This conditioner is designed to enhance curls and impart shine. However, purchasing it at Five Below may not be cost-effective, as similar travel-sized items are often cheaper at other retailers like Target. Some users have reported that the formula can leave hair tangled, requiring additional products to detangle effectively. Additionally, certain formulations have been noted to be watery, leaving hair dry, particularly for those with specific hair types. Considering these factors, exploring other purchasing options or brands may provide better value and results.

Pretty Animalz Unicorn Anti-Imperfection Sheet Mask

This whimsical sheet mask aims to address skin imperfections while providing a fun experience. However, its higher price point at Five Below makes it less appealing, especially when similar Korean sheet masks are available elsewhere for as low as $1. Some users have found the mask slightly small for average-sized faces, affecting overall comfort during use. While it offers a pleasant scent and leaves the skin feeling refreshed, the design may not resemble a unicorn as intended, resembling more of a sci-fi creature. Given the availability of more affordable and effective alternatives, this mask might not be the best investment.

Disco Ball Sipper and Straw

This eye-catching drinkware item features a disco ball design, appealing to those seeking a fun beverage container. Despite its attractive appearance, similar products are available at other retailers, such as Walmart, for half the price. The higher cost at Five Below diminishes its value proposition, especially when more affordable options offer comparable quality. For budget-conscious shoppers, exploring alternative retailers for similar novelty drinkware is advisable.

Cosmo Furbabies Sneaker Plush Dog Toy

This plush toy, designed to resemble a sneaker, aims to provide entertainment for dogs. However, reports indicate that the toy tends to rip apart easily, often lasting only a few days after purchase. The lack of durability means frequent replacements, leading to higher long-term costs. Investing in more robust pet toys from reputable brands may offer better value and longevity, ensuring sustained enjoyment for pets.

Eos Shea Butter Travel Size Shave Cream

This shave cream is known for its moisturizing properties and pleasant scent. However, purchasing it at Five Below may not be the most economical choice, as the same product is available at retailers like Target for $3 less. Price-conscious consumers may find better deals elsewhere, making this purchase at Five Below less justifiable. Exploring other retailers for this shave cream can lead to significant savings without compromising on quality.

Textured Popcorn Bath Towel

This bath towel features a textured popcorn design, adding aesthetic appeal to bathroom decor. However, concerns about the quality of textiles at Five Below suggest that this towel may not offer the desired durability or absorbency. Comparable or even superior towels are available at other retailers, such as Kohl’s, often at a lower price point. Investing in higher-quality towels elsewhere can ensure better performance and longevity.

Twin Wire Journal

This spiral-bound notebook serves as a practical tool for note-taking and journaling. Despite its functionality, the $5 price tag at Five Below is relatively high compared to similar options available at other retailers like Target, Walmart, Office Depot, and Dollar Tree, where similar notebooks can be found for less than half the price. For those seeking cost-effective stationery, exploring alternatives at these retailers is recommended.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

10 Hidden Costco Perks That Even Regular Shoppers Overlook

Costco is already a great place to save money, but there’s a lot more to it than bulk snacks and cheap gas. Some of the best perks fly under the radar, even for longtime members. From hidden discounts to exclusive services, there are plenty of ways to get even more value out of your membership. Read More.

These 10 Costco Bakery Items Taste So Good, You Will Skip Baking

Costco’s bakery section is packed with irresistible treats that make baking at home feel unnecessary. From rich chocolate cakes to buttery pastries, their selection has something for every sweet tooth. Read More.

12 Costco Foods Dietitians Warn Against (Avoid These Picks Now)

Costco offers plenty of great deals, but not everything in the store is a smart choice for your health. Some of their popular foods are packed with excessive sugar, sodium, and unhealthy fats that dietitians strongly advise against. Read More.