12 Costco Food Court Favorites We Wish Would Come Back

Costco’s food court has always been a fan favorite, offering delicious and affordable treats that keep shoppers coming back. Over the years, however, some of the most beloved menu items have disappeared, leaving loyal customers disappointed. Whether it was a loaded slice of combo pizza, a refreshing acai bowl, or a rich chocolate-dipped ice cream bar, these discontinued favorites are still missed.

BBQ Beef Brisket Sandwich

Costco’s BBQ Beef Brisket Sandwich was a smoky, tender masterpiece that felt like a hidden gem on the menu. The slow-cooked brisket was packed with flavor, smothered in tangy barbecue sauce, and served on a soft, toasted bun. It had just the right balance of sweetness and smokiness, making it a fan favorite among barbecue lovers. The portion was generous, offering a satisfying meal for a great price. Some believe it was removed because it was more expensive to produce than other food court items. Others think it was not selling fast enough, leading to its quiet removal. Fans still talk about it and hope for its return.

Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels

These warm, soft pretzels coated in cinnamon sugar were a simple yet irresistible treat. They had the perfect balance of sweetness and slight saltiness from the dough, making every bite delicious. The exterior had a slight crispiness, while the inside remained soft and chewy. Many customers loved pairing them with Costco’s frozen yogurt for an extra indulgence. Their removal left a gap in the dessert options at the food court, disappointing pretzel lovers everywhere. Some speculate that Costco wanted to streamline its menu, leading to the loss of this favorite. Fans still reminisce about them and hope they will return someday.

Acai Bowl

The Acai Bowl was Costco’s attempt at offering a healthier, refreshing option, and it quickly gained a following. It featured a thick, smooth acai blend topped with fresh strawberries, blueberries, granola, and banana slices. The combination of creamy, crunchy, and fruity flavors made it a satisfying and energizing snack. Many people loved that it felt like a gourmet smoothie bowl but at a much lower price. Its sudden removal left many customers searching for a comparable option elsewhere. Some believe it was discontinued due to supply chain issues, while others think it did not sell well enough. Either way, health-conscious shoppers still wish it would come back.

All-American Chocolate Cake

Costco’s All-American Chocolate Cake was a towering masterpiece of rich, moist chocolate layers. It was generously coated in thick, creamy chocolate frosting and had a decadent taste that chocolate lovers adored. The cake’s enormous size made it a go-to choice for birthdays, celebrations, and any sweet-tooth craving. Despite its popularity, Costco removed it from the shelves, leaving fans scrambling to find alternatives. Some believe the high production costs led to its discontinuation, while others think it was part of an effort to cut back on sugar-heavy desserts. Even years later, people still request its return. Nothing has quite replaced the magic of this chocolatey indulgence.

Chicken Caesar Salad

Costco’s Chicken Caesar Salad was a fresh, tasty option that stood out among the heavier food court items. It featured crisp romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, shredded parmesan, crunchy croutons, and creamy Caesar dressing. The portion size was generous, making it a perfect meal for those wanting something lighter. Many customers appreciated that it was both filling and flavorful, offering a healthier alternative to pizza and hot dogs. Its disappearance left a noticeable gap in the menu, especially for those looking for fresh options. Some believe it was discontinued due to lower sales compared to other items. Fans still wish for its return, hoping Costco will bring back its best salad.

Calzones

Costco’s calzones were a lesser-known but much-loved food court item that combined crispy, golden dough with gooey, cheesy fillings. Stuffed with a rich blend of mozzarella, ricotta, and marinara sauce, they were a satisfying grab-and-go meal. Some versions even included pepperoni or sausage, making them extra indulgent. They had a cult following, especially among those who preferred a more portable alternative to pizza. Unfortunately, they were removed quietly, leaving many customers disappointed. Some believe they took too long to prepare compared to other menu items. Despite their disappearance, fans continue to hope for their comeback.

Hot Turkey and Provolone Sandwich

The Hot Turkey and Provolone Sandwich was a delicious, comforting food court option that many customers still miss. It featured thick slices of roasted turkey paired with melted provolone cheese, all served on a soft, warm roll. The addition of tangy mustard and fresh greens made it even better. It was a satisfying alternative to the heavier, more indulgent menu options. Some speculate that it was removed due to lower demand compared to the pizza and hot dog staples. Others believe the ingredients were too expensive to keep up with Costco’s budget-friendly pricing. Either way, fans continue to ask for its return.

Combo Pizza

The Combo Pizza was a food court staple that was packed with flavor and loaded with toppings. It featured a perfect blend of pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, and mushrooms, all piled high on a thick, crispy crust. The combination of melted cheese and zesty tomato sauce made every bite delicious. Many customers considered it the best option for those who wanted more than just cheese or pepperoni. Costco shocked fans when they discontinued it, citing a desire to simplify the menu. Despite the reasoning, people still ask about it and hope for a comeback. It remains one of the most requested discontinued items.

Churro

Costco’s Churro was an oversized, golden-brown pastry coated in cinnamon sugar and served warm. It had a crispy exterior and a soft, doughy inside, making it a satisfying treat. It was a go-to snack for many customers who wanted something sweet after their meal. The best part was its price, making it an affordable indulgence. Costco replaced it with a new, thicker version, but many fans argue it is not the same. The original had a better balance of crispiness and sweetness, making it far superior. Fans still reminisce about the old version and hope for its return.

Chocolate Dipped Ice Cream Bars

These ice cream bars were a simple yet iconic treat that Costco shoppers loved. They featured a creamy vanilla ice cream base coated in a rich, crunchy chocolate shell. Each bite had the perfect combination of sweetness and texture, making them highly addictive. Many customers would buy them as a refreshing treat after a long shopping trip. Costco quietly removed them, leaving fans wondering why such a popular item was discontinued. Some believe rising costs played a role, while others think it was just a menu revamp. Regardless, many still ask for their return.

Cheeseburger

Costco’s Cheeseburger was an attempt to offer a premium fast-food-style burger at an unbeatable price. It featured a thick, juicy beef patty topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a signature sauce. Many customers compared it to popular restaurant burgers and were pleasantly surprised by its quality. Unfortunately, it did not last long on the menu, as Costco pulled it after a short run. Some speculate it did not sell as well as expected, while others believe it was too complicated to prepare quickly. Fans still wish they had another chance to enjoy it. If Costco ever decides to bring it back, it could become a cult favorite.

Gelato

Costco’s Gelato was a hidden treasure that provided a high-quality, creamy dessert experience. It came in rich flavors like chocolate, pistachio, and mixed berry, all served in generous portions. Many customers loved how smooth and flavorful it was, making it a perfect treat after a meal. Unlike regular soft-serve ice cream, it had a denser texture that made it feel more indulgent. Costco removed it without much explanation, leaving gelato fans disappointed. Some believe it was due to low demand, while others think it was a cost-cutting measure. Regardless of the reason, people still miss this delicious dessert.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

The 20 Ultimate Target Guide for First-Time Solo Living Essentials

Moving into your own place for the first time is an exciting milestone, but it can also feel overwhelming when you are figuring out what essentials to buy. Having the right items can make your new space comfortable, functional, and truly feel like home. Read More.

11 Surprisingly Healthy Snacks and Drinks You Can Find at Dollar Tree

Dollar Tree is not just a place for affordable household items; it also offers a surprisingly wide selection of healthy snacks and drinks. These products often include natural ingredients and are low in fat, sugar, or calories. Read More.

13 Budget-Friendly Groceries to Snag at Dollar Tree This Month

If you are looking to stretch your grocery budget without compromising on quality, Dollar Tree has some fantastic options this month. Many of these items are perfect for busy days, when you need something tasty in a pinch. Read More.