16 Best and Worst Trader Joe’s Fall Items of 2024, Ranked

Fall is here, and you know what that means: Trader Joe’s is back at it again with an array of seasonal goodies that’ll make your taste buds dance like it’s a harvest festival. From pumpkin-flavored everything to cozy snacks that scream sweater weather, we have rank the best and the most questionable items of 2024. Get ready to take note—because some of these treats are destined for your cart, while others might just be a spooky little mistake!

16. Pumpkin Spiced Joe-Joe’s Sandwich Cookies

These cookies had a strong pumpkin spice flavor but didn’t win over everyone. While some shoppers enjoyed the creamy filling and crisp cookie, others found the spice overwhelming and artificial. The combination of pumpkin and spice seemed too intense for many, overshadowing the sandwich cookie’s texture and balance. They also received criticism for being too sweet, making it difficult for some to enjoy more than one at a time. Overall, it wasn’t a standout in the fall lineup, and many felt other pumpkin-flavored items outshined it.

15. Pumpkin Ice Cream

Pumpkin Ice Cream sparked mixed reactions among shoppers. While some enjoyed its creamy texture, many felt the pumpkin flavor was too mild to leave a lasting impression. The spice notes were barely noticeable, which made the ice cream feel more like a plain dessert than a fall-themed treat. It wasn’t bad, but it didn’t excite many, especially with stronger seasonal flavors available. For those who like subtle pumpkin, it’s a decent option, but it didn’t stand out as a must-have.

14. Cinnamon Roll Blondie Bar Mix

This mix was fun to bake, but it didn’t pack the punch expected from a fall treat. While the cinnamon flavor was pleasant, it wasn’t as bold or unique as other fall desserts. Many customers felt that the blondie texture clashed with the cinnamon roll concept, leading to a dessert that was just okay. It’s a good option for an easy-to-make treat, but it didn’t wow anyone in terms of flavor. For many, it felt like an average addition to the fall lineup.

13. Pumpkin Spice Bagels

These bagels were an enjoyable seasonal breakfast option for some, but they didn’t fully capture the essence of pumpkin spice. Many reviewers found the flavor to be too mild, lacking the boldness that makes pumpkin spice so beloved in fall. Texture-wise, the bagels were solid, but they didn’t leave a memorable impression. In a lineup full of stronger fall items, these bagels felt more like a background player. They’re worth a try if you love pumpkin spice, but don’t expect to be wowed.

12. Pumpkin Bisque

Pumpkin Bisque received mixed reactions this fall, with many shoppers finding it too sweet for a savory soup. While the creamy texture was appreciated, the balance of flavors felt off, with the sweetness overpowering the expected warmth of spices. Some enjoyed the rich, velvety consistency, but for many, the bisque didn’t capture the savory fall flavors they were hoping for. It’s a decent option if you prefer a sweeter twist on traditional pumpkin dishes, but it wasn’t a hit with those looking for a more balanced fall soup.

11. Pumpkin Empanadas

Pumpkin Empanadas were met with mixed reactions from shoppers, largely due to varying opinions on their sweetness. Some found the filling to be perfectly spiced with a pleasant pumpkin flavor, while others felt it leaned too sweet for their taste. The flaky pastry was a highlight for many, adding a nice contrast to the rich filling. However, the level of sweetness remained a divisive point, with some feeling it overshadowed the pumpkin. Overall, it’s a unique fall item that appeals to those who enjoy sweeter baked goods but may not satisfy everyone.

10. Non-Dairy Oat Beverage Maple Flavor

This maple-flavored oat beverage earned praise for its sweet, smooth taste and versatility in recipes. It’s a popular choice for those looking to add a hint of maple to their coffee or baked goods, and it works well in various dairy-free recipes. However, its sweetness wasn’t for everyone, and some found it a bit overpowering for everyday use. While it’s a hit with fans of maple flavor, it didn’t appeal to all taste preferences. Still, it’s a creative addition to Trader Joe’s fall lineup that many shoppers enjoyed.

9. Honey Roasted Pumpkin Ravioli

This unique fall item blends sweet and savory with its honey-roasted pumpkin filling, wrapped in tender pasta. The ravioli has received high praise for its rich, balanced flavor, although some shoppers have found the sweetness a bit overpowering. The filling’s subtle spices complement the pumpkin, making it a satisfying and hearty dish for fall dinners. It pairs well with simple sauces like brown butter or sage, letting the pumpkin flavor shine. Overall, it’s a creative and flavorful addition to Trader Joe’s seasonal lineup, though the sweetness may not appeal to everyone.

8. Salted Maple Ice Cream

Salted Maple Ice Cream brought a unique flavor to the table, making it a favorite for those who love the sweet and salty combination. The rich maple flavor, paired with a hint of salt, created a balanced and indulgent dessert. It’s a standout for those seeking something different from the usual pumpkin spice fare. However, the intense maple flavor wasn’t for everyone, which kept it from ranking higher. Still, it’s a creative and delightful fall treat worth trying.

7. Autumnal Harvest Soup

Autumnal Harvest Soup has become one of the top fall favorites at Trader Joe’s, beloved for its rich, comforting blend of tomatoes, pumpkin, and butternut squash. The creamy texture and balance of savory and slightly sweet flavors make it a go-to for cozy fall meals. Shoppers have praised it as the perfect base for adding extras like cheese or croutons, making it versatile as both a standalone meal or a starter. Its hearty, flavorful profile has consistently earned it high marks from customers. For those seeking the ultimate fall comfort soup, this one ranks near the top.

6. Pumpkin Cheesecake

Rich, creamy, and full of flavor, Pumpkin Cheesecake was a popular choice for fall gatherings. The pumpkin flavor blended beautifully with the cheesecake’s smooth texture, creating a dessert that felt both indulgent and seasonal. Many shoppers enjoyed it as a ready-made option for entertaining, as it required no prep but delivered big on flavor. Its richness and balance of spices made it a standout, though it’s best for those who enjoy a heavier dessert. It’s perfect for satisfying a pumpkin craving during the holidays.

5. Apple Cider Donuts

Apple Cider Donuts were once again a fall favorite, delivering the perfect combination of apple flavor and cinnamon sugar. These donuts reminded many shoppers of fall festivals and apple orchards, adding a nostalgic element to their appeal. Their moist texture and balanced sweetness made them an instant hit, and they consistently rank high on fall must-try lists. Whether enjoyed with coffee or as a snack, they embody everything people love about the season. It’s no surprise they’ve become a staple in Trader Joe’s fall lineup.

4. Butternut Squash Mac & Cheese

Butternut Squash Mac & Cheese returned as a crowd-pleaser this fall, offering creamy, cheesy goodness with a hint of sweetness from the butternut squash. This comfort food had the perfect balance of flavors, making it a versatile dish for both sides and mains. Its rich, satisfying texture and unique flavor profile set it apart from traditional mac and cheese. Many found it to be the ultimate fall comfort food, and it has become a must-try for those looking to indulge in seasonal favorites. It’s consistently ranked among the best fall items for its cozy appeal.

3. Pumpkin Spice Coffee

Pumpkin Spice Coffee was a go-to for those looking to infuse their mornings with fall flavors. The aromatic blend of spices made it feel like autumn in a cup, and it received high praise for its bold flavor and comforting aroma. Many shoppers enjoyed starting their day with this seasonal brew, which perfectly captured the essence of pumpkin spice. It became a staple for fall mornings, offering a cozy and flavorful kickstart to the day. For coffee lovers, this is a must-have fall item that delivers on flavor.

2. Gluten-Free Pumpkin Streusel Muffins

These muffins are a huge hit, even among those who don’t follow a gluten-free diet. The tender crumb and delicious streusel topping make them a standout fall treat. Packed with pumpkin flavor and the right amount of spice, these muffins deliver on both taste and texture. Many shoppers appreciate that the gluten-free aspect doesn’t compromise the quality, with the muffins being just as soft and flavorful as their gluten-filled counterparts. Perfect for breakfast or a snack, they’ve quickly become a fall favorite for many.

1. Pumpkin Spice Mini Sheet Cake

Topping the list, the Pumpkin Spice Mini Sheet Cake has won over shoppers with its moist texture and bold pumpkin spice flavor. The rich cream cheese frosting adds just the right amount of sweetness, complementing the warm spices in the cake. Many have praised its perfect balance of flavors, making it an ideal fall dessert for gatherings or a special treat at home. Its small size makes it easy to enjoy without feeling overindulgent, but the flavor is big enough to satisfy any pumpkin lover. For those seeking the ultimate fall dessert, this sheet cake is a must-try.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

16 Top Aldi Finds Under $10 to Grab This September

Aldi is rolling out some awesome fall finds this season, and trust me, you won’t want to miss them. These are the kind of budget-friendly gems that make your meals and snacks even better, all while keeping things cozy and fun for fall. Read More.

10 Foods That Were Once the Hottest Trends

Food trends are as fickle as fashion. What was once the hottest dish can quickly become passé. From smoothie bowls to charcoal ice cream, we’ve seen a variety of foods enjoy their moment in the spotlight. Read More.

15 Dollar Tree Snacks That Are Worth Stocking Up On

Finding good snacks at a low price can sometimes feel like a challenge, but Dollar Tree makes it easy. They have a wide range of tasty treats that won’t break the bank, and many of them are surprisingly delicious. Read More.