5 Best And 5 Worst Steaks To Buy At Sam’s Club

The steak selection at Sam’s Club can be overwhelming, with options ranging from premium cuts to budget-friendly choices. While some steaks are well worth the investment, delivering rich flavors and tender textures, others may leave you disappointed in quality or taste. Knowing which steaks to pick up and which to skip can make all the difference in your next grilling session or family dinner. We have highlighted the best and worst steaks Sam’s Club has to offer, so you can make an informed decision and enjoy a truly delicious meal.

Prime Beef Strip Steak (Best)

Sam’s Club offers Prime Beef Strip Steaks that are packed with flavor and ideal for those seeking a balance between tenderness and beefy taste. Known for its firm texture and minimal fat, the strip steak provides a leaner option without sacrificing flavor. The “prime” designation ensures a high-quality cut with enough marbling to keep the steak juicy when cooked. The strip steak is perfect for a quick sear on a hot grill or skillet, giving it a beautiful crust while keeping the inside tender. For a versatile and flavorful steak, the Prime Beef Strip Steak at Sam’s Club is a solid choice.

Brisket (Worst)

Brisket might be a popular choice for BBQ lovers, but Sam’s Club’s brisket options can sometimes fall short in terms of quality. Brisket requires a long, slow cooking process to break down the connective tissue and turn it tender, but if the meat isn’t top quality, the end result can be dry and chewy. Unfortunately, some briskets at Sam’s Club tend to be on the leaner side, lacking the marbling needed to retain moisture. This makes it a challenge for those who don’t have the time or equipment to cook it properly. If you’re not planning on slow-cooking it, brisket may not be the best choice from Sam’s Club.

T-Bone Steak (Best)

The T-Bone Steak at Sam’s Club offers the best of both worlds with its combination of two prime cuts: the tenderloin and the strip steak. This large cut is prized for its dual texture, providing a tender and buttery experience from the tenderloin side and a firmer, beefier bite from the strip side. Its signature T-shaped bone not only adds flavor during cooking but also makes for an impressive presentation. The T-Bone is ideal for grilling or pan-searing, allowing you to achieve a perfect char while keeping the interior juicy and flavorful. For those seeking variety in a single steak, the T-Bone from Sam’s Club is a fantastic choice.

Sirloin Steak (Worst)

While the Sirloin Steak is a popular choice for its affordability, the cuts available at Sam’s Club can be inconsistent in quality. Sirloin is leaner than cuts like ribeye or strip steak, which means it has less marbling to keep it juicy during cooking. This can result in a tougher texture, especially if overcooked or not prepared correctly. Some sirloin steaks at Sam’s Club also tend to lack the depth of flavor found in other cuts, making them less appealing for steak enthusiasts. If you’re looking for a tender and flavorful steak, the sirloin might not be the best option from Sam’s Club.

Cowboy Ribeye (Best)

The Cowboy Ribeye at Sam’s Club is an excellent choice for anyone who loves a rich, well-marbled steak. This cut stands out with its thick, juicy texture and bone-in style, which helps retain moisture and enhances the steak’s overall flavor. Known for its beefy taste, the ribeye’s marbling melts down during cooking, giving the meat a buttery texture that’s hard to beat. At Sam’s Club, you can find prime-quality Cowboy Ribeyes, ensuring you get a high-grade cut that’s tender and delicious. It’s perfect for grilling, as the bone and marbling add depth, making it a favorite among steak enthusiasts.

Whole Beef Tenderloin (Worst)

Whole Beef Tenderloin is a delicate cut, but it’s not always the best choice at Sam’s Club, where quality can vary. While tenderloin is known for its buttery softness, the whole tenderloin often has inconsistent marbling, which can make the meat dry out quickly when cooking. This cut can also be tricky to prepare at home, as it requires careful trimming and cooking techniques to avoid a rubbery texture. Additionally, the price of a whole tenderloin may not justify its quality, especially when compared to other cuts available. For those looking for tender meat, there may be better options than the tenderloin from Sam’s Club.

Prime Beef Ribeye (Best)

The Prime Beef Ribeye at Sam’s Club is a top-tier choice for anyone wanting a melt-in-your-mouth steak. Known for its rich marbling, this ribeye delivers a juicy and flavorful experience that steak lovers crave. The “prime” grade ensures excellent quality, providing a level of tenderness that’s ideal for grilling, pan-searing, or even sous-vide cooking. The ribeye’s intramuscular fat melts during cooking, giving each bite a succulent texture. It’s a classic choice for those looking for a reliably delicious steak that’s worth the investment.

New York Strip Steak (Worst)

The New York Strip Steak at Sam’s Club can sometimes fall short compared to other options. Known for its leaner texture, this cut can be hit-or-miss in terms of tenderness, especially if the quality is lower. The lack of significant marbling means the New York Strip can be less juicy and flavorful than cuts like the ribeye or Wagyu. It’s best suited for those who prefer a leaner, firmer steak, but it may not satisfy those seeking a more tender and rich flavor profile. While it’s a classic steak cut, the New York Strip from Sam’s Club may not always be the best value.

Japanese Wagyu (Best)

Sam’s Club offers Japanese Wagyu, a premium option for those looking for a truly unique steak experience. Known for its unmatched marbling, Wagyu beef has a rich, buttery texture and a flavor profile that stands out among other steaks. This beef is often graded at the highest levels of marbling, which provides an incredibly tender, melt-in-your-mouth experience. Wagyu is ideal for those willing to invest a bit more in a high-quality steak, as it’s perfect for special occasions or gourmet meals at home. Sam’s Club’s Wagyu selection allows steak enthusiasts to experience a taste of luxury without the need for a restaurant.

Filet Mignon (Worst)

While Filet Mignon is often considered a luxury steak, Sam’s Club’s options may leave something to be desired. This cut is naturally very lean, meaning it lacks the marbling that brings extra flavor and juiciness to the meat. Filet Mignon from Sam’s Club can sometimes be underwhelming, as the lean meat tends to dry out if not cooked perfectly. Moreover, it often comes with a high price tag that might not match the quality offered. If you’re after a flavorful steak, you might be better off choosing a different cut from Sam’s Club.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

15 Budget-Friendly Grocery Items That Taste Surprisingly Gourmet

There are plenty of grocery items that are affordable but can make your meals feel fancy. With a little creativity, you can turn everyday staples into dishes that taste like they came straight out of a gourmet restaurant. Read More.

15 Sneaky Sources of Trans Fats Lurking in Your Diet

Trans fats are often hidden in everyday foods, making it easy to consume them without realizing it. While some foods openly declare their unhealthy ingredients, others quietly slip these harmful fats into your diet. Knowing where to look can help you make better choices and protect your health.Read More.

15 Herbs and Spices to Support Your Health and Well-being

Unlock the secrets of ancient wellness with herbs and spices that can transform your health. Whether you’re looking to boost your energy, improve digestion, or reduce inflammation, these 15 herbs and spices have you covered. Read More.