12 Aldi Ice Creams, Ranked From Worst to Best

Some ice creams are worth stocking up on, and others, not so much. Aldi’s ice cream selection is surprisingly good, but not every flavor is a winner. With so many options, it helps to know which ones are worth grabbing and which ones might leave you disappointed. Whether you’re into classic flavors or fun, over-the-top combinations, this ranking will break down the best and worst picks. Here’s how Aldi’s ice creams stack up!

12. Sundae Shoppe Thank You Cherry Much!

This flavor is Aldi’s take on a popular cherry and chocolate combination, featuring cherry ice cream studded with real cherry pieces and chocolate chunks. The ice cream boasts a dark cherry flavor that is both rich and refreshing. While the texture leans slightly towards being icy, the generous inclusion of fruit and chocolate provides a satisfying experience. For fans of cherry-infused desserts, this offers a delightful balance of flavors.

11. Sundae Shoppe Chocolate Ice Cream

This chocolate ice cream has been criticized for its lack of sweetness and depth, with some describing it as tasting primarily of cocoa powder. The texture is also noted to be less creamy than expected, leading to a somewhat disappointing experience. Reviewers suggest that it doesn’t meet the standard of a rich, indulgent chocolate ice cream. Overall, it may not satisfy those seeking a classic, sweet chocolate flavor.

10. Sundae Shoppe Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

This vanilla bean ice cream offers a classic flavor with a smooth and creamy texture. While it may not be as rich as some premium brands, it serves as a versatile base for various desserts and toppings. The subtle vanilla taste makes it suitable for those who prefer a milder flavor profile. It’s an affordable option for everyday indulgence. However, those seeking a more intense vanilla experience might find it lacking.

9. Sundae Shoppe Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream

This flavor features a base that some find lacking in pronounced taste, with cookie dough pieces that are described as hard and bland. The combination results in an underwhelming dessert experience. Compared to other brands, it may fall short in delivering the rich, sweet flavors typically associated with cookie dough ice cream. Consumers looking for a more flavorful option might consider alternatives.

8. Sundae Shoppe Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

This mint chocolate chip variety offers a strong mint flavor that some may find overpowering, potentially overshadowing the chocolate components. The chocolate pieces themselves are noted to be somewhat bland, which might not satisfy those seeking a balanced mint-chocolate combination. Adjusting the intensity of the mint or enhancing the chocolate quality could improve the overall taste experience.

7. Sundae Shoppe Light Sea Salt Caramel Ice Cream

Marketed as a lighter option with reduced fat and calories, this ice cream is noted for its creamy texture but lacks the distinct flavors of sea salt and caramel. The taste is described as muted, which may disappoint those expecting a robust caramel profile. While it offers a smooth mouthfeel, the absence of strong flavor notes makes it less satisfying. For a more indulgent caramel experience, other varieties might be preferable.

6. Sundae Shoppe Moose Tracks Ice Cream

This indulgent flavor combines vanilla ice cream with rich fudge swirls and mini peanut butter cups, creating a delightful mix of textures and tastes. The peanut butter cups are described as particularly enjoyable, adding a savory contrast to the sweetness of the ice cream. The fudge ribbons enhance the overall richness, making it reminiscent of a classic sundae in a single scoop. For those who enjoy a combination of chocolate and peanut butter, this flavor is a standout choice.

5. Sundae Shoppe Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

This rendition of the popular cookies and cream flavor successfully captures the essence of chocolate sandwich cookies blended into a creamy base. The ice cream offers a harmonious balance between the sweet cream and crunchy cookie bits. The generous distribution of cookie pieces ensures a consistent taste in every bite. Fans of the classic combination will find this version both satisfying and indulgent.

4. Sundae Shoppe Strawberry Ice Cream

This strawberry ice cream presents a mild flavor that some find lacking in vibrant strawberry notes. The subtlety of the taste may not appeal to those seeking a pronounced fruity experience. However, its unoffensive profile makes it a versatile option that pairs well with various desserts. Enhancing it with fresh strawberries could elevate the overall flavor.

3. Sundae Shoppe Make Fudge Not War!

As a playfully named option, this ice cream is rich in fudgy elements, featuring dark chocolate ice cream with gooey brownie batter bits. While the cocoa flavor is intense, some detect an aftertaste reminiscent of carob, which may not appeal to everyone. The dense texture and deep chocolate notes make it a decadent choice for chocolate enthusiasts. However, those sensitive to alternative flavor undertones might find it less enjoyable.

2. Sundae Shoppe Brookie Dough

Combining elements of brownies and cookies, this flavor features a chocolate ice cream base with dark, chewy brownie pieces that are praised for their fresh-baked taste. However, the cookie dough chunks are described as crumbly and lacking in flavor, which may detract from the overall enjoyment. The contrast between the rich brownie bits and the underwhelming cookie dough creates an imbalance. Improving the quality of the cookie dough could enhance this flavor’s appeal.

1. Sundae Shoppe Butter Pecan Ice Cream

This classic flavor features crunchy pecans embedded in a creamy base, delivering a satisfying texture contrast. The butteriness of the ice cream complements the roasted pecans, creating a rich, nutty depth that stands out. Unlike some store-brand butter pecan varieties, this one doesn’t skimp on the pecan pieces, ensuring you get a satisfying crunch in every bite. The balance between sweet and savory flavors makes it a great pick for those who appreciate a more classic, less sugary ice cream. While it may not be as indulgently creamy as some premium brands, it still delivers a smooth, enjoyable texture. Overall, it’s a solid option for butter pecan lovers who want quality flavor at a budget-friendly price.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

The Top 13 Craft Beers from Each Region of the U.S.

The craft beer revolution has taken over the United States, turning local breweries into cultural icons and creating a dynamic landscape of unique and innovative brews. Each region boasts a distinctive beer culture that reflects its local ingredients, brewing techniques, and passionate brewers. Read More.

12 Hottest T.J. Maxx Items Flying Off Shelves This February

T.J. Maxx is coming through with some serious finds this February. Whether you’re stocking up on winter essentials, grabbing beauty steals, or treating yourself to a little luxury without the hefty price tag, there’s no shortage of deals worth checking out. Read More.

13 New Costco Finds Shoppers Are Loving This Month

Costco is always adding exciting new products to its shelves, and this month is no exception. Shoppers are discovering fresh snacks, indulgent desserts, and unique grocery finds that are quickly becoming fan favorites. Read More.