13 Aldi Copycat Products That Are Almost Identical to the Originals

You know that feeling when you try a store brand and it actually tastes just like the name brand? Aldi does that a lot. Their shelves are packed with familiar-looking items that cost less but still hit the same. Some even come so close, you’ll forget they’re copycats. From snacks and spreads to butter and cereal, Aldi has a bunch of low-key gems that hold their own next to the originals. Here are some of the best ones to look out for next time you’re shopping.

Clancy’s White Cheddar Popcorn

Clancy’s White Cheddar Popcorn is Aldi’s take on Smartfood, and it’s pretty spot on. The popcorn is light, fluffy, and evenly coated with a tangy white cheddar seasoning that sticks to your fingers just like the name brand. It’s gluten-free and made with real cheese, which is a plus if you’re checking ingredient labels. Many Aldi shoppers have noted that Clancy’s version is slightly less salty, which can actually make it easier to keep snacking without feeling overwhelmed. You’ll find it in the chip aisle, usually priced well below what you’d pay for the national brand.

Countryside Creamery Irish Butter

Fans of Kerrygold Irish Butter will find a near match with Countryside Creamery Irish Butter. This butter is made from milk produced by grass-fed cows, giving it a creamy texture and rich flavor. It has that same golden yellow hue and is often praised for how well it spreads and melts. While Kerrygold is imported and carries a premium price, the Aldi version is more affordable without sacrificing taste or quality. Whether you’re slathering it on toast or using it for baking, it delivers that same buttery satisfaction.

Benton’s Fudge Striped Shortbread Cookies

Benton’s Fudge Striped Shortbread Cookies are a familiar sight for anyone who grew up eating Keebler Fudge Stripes. They’ve got the same round shape, crunchy shortbread base, and the signature fudge drizzle on top. The cookie texture is buttery and crisp, while the chocolate coating holds up without getting too soft. Many shoppers say the flavor is almost identical, making them a reliable substitute. Plus, they’re usually available in large packages for a fraction of the cost.

Tuscan Garden Restaurant Style Italian Dressing

If you’re a fan of Olive Garden’s Italian dressing, Aldi’s Tuscan Garden Restaurant Style Italian Dressing might surprise you. It has that same zesty kick with a blend of vinegar, garlic, and Romano cheese flavoring. The consistency is slightly thicker than other store-brand dressings, and it clings nicely to salads and marinades. Online comparisons show that the ingredients and nutritional profile are nearly the same. It’s a great option if you’re trying to recreate that restaurant-style salad at home.

Happy Farms American Cheese Singles

Happy Farms American Cheese Singles look and taste almost exactly like Kraft Singles. They melt smoothly, have that familiar mild flavor, and are packaged in individual wrappers for convenience. They’re great for grilled cheese sandwiches, burgers, or quick snacks. The texture is creamy, and the melt quality is surprisingly good for a store brand. You’ll likely find these at a lower price point than the name brand, making them an easy switch.

L’Oven Fresh Hawaiian Sweet Rolls

L’Oven Fresh Hawaiian Sweet Rolls are Aldi’s version of the iconic King’s Hawaiian rolls. They have that same golden brown exterior and soft, pillowy interior with a hint of sweetness. Perfect for sliders or dinner rolls, they hold their shape well even when filled. The flavor is slightly less sweet than King’s, which some shoppers actually prefer. They’re usually found in a 12-pack and often sell out quickly, especially around the holidays.

Burman’s Real Mayonnaise

Burman’s Real Mayonnaise has a creamy texture and balanced flavor that rivals Hellmann’s. It spreads easily and holds up in sandwiches, salads, and dips without tasting too tangy or too oily. The ingredient list includes soybean oil, egg yolks, and vinegar, similar to what you’d find in the name brand. Taste tests have shown that many people can’t tell the difference in side-by-side comparisons. It’s an easy switch for anyone looking to save without losing quality.

Belmont Smooth Biscuit Spread

Belmont Smooth Biscuit Spread is Aldi’s answer to Lotus Biscoff spread, and it holds up surprisingly well. The consistency is smooth and creamy, perfect for spreading on toast, stirring into oatmeal, or spooning straight from the jar. It has that distinct caramelized cookie flavor with a hint of cinnamon. The ingredients are very similar, and it’s often sold in glass jars like the original. It’s a great pantry staple for anyone who loves sweet spreads.

Millville Marshmallow and Stars Cereal

Millville Marshmallow and Stars is Aldi’s take on Lucky Charms, and it’s a solid dupe. It features crunchy oat cereal pieces and colorful mini marshmallows in classic shapes. The flavor profile is nearly identical, with a sweet vanilla-corn taste that kids and adults both enjoy. The marshmallows are slightly smaller, but that doesn’t take away from the overall fun. It’s often priced lower, making it a budget-friendly breakfast or snack option.

Clancy’s Original Stackerz Potato Crisps

Clancy’s Original Stackerz are Aldi’s alternative to Pringles, and the resemblance is hard to ignore. They come in the same tall canister and are stacked in uniform, thin chips. The texture is crisp with a light crunch, and the flavor is just salty enough without going overboard. Unlike some off-brand versions, these hold their shape well and don’t crumble easily. They’re a handy snack to keep around, especially at a lower price than the original.

Nordpak Spreadable Butter

Nordpak Spreadable Butter is Aldi’s version of Lurpak, and it does a great job mimicking the original. It’s made with real butter blended with rapeseed oil, making it soft and easy to spread straight from the fridge. The taste is rich and creamy, ideal for toast or cooking. Many shoppers say they can’t tell the difference when using it for baking or on warm bread. It comes in a silver tub just like Lurpak, adding to the nearly identical experience.

Belmont Crumbly Oaties

Belmont Crumbly Oaties bear a strong resemblance to McVitie’s Hobnobs, especially in flavor and texture. These oat-based biscuits are crunchy with a slightly crumbly finish and a hint of sweetness. They pair well with tea or coffee and hold up well when dipped. The ingredients are similar, including rolled oats and whole wheat flour. If you’re into classic British biscuits, this one’s worth picking up.

Benton’s Zingy Orange Jaffa Cakes

Benton’s Zingy Orange Jaffa Cakes are Aldi’s take on the beloved British treat made famous by McVitie’s. They feature the same soft sponge base, a layer of orange-flavored jelly, and a coating of chocolate on top. The texture is light and chewy, and the citrus flavor is just strong enough without being overpowering. While the chocolate may be slightly thinner, the overall taste is surprisingly close. They’re great for an afternoon treat or packed into lunchboxes.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

13 Kosher-Friendly Foods You Can Grab at Aldi

Finding kosher groceries doesn’t have to feel like a scavenger hunt. Aldi actually has a solid selection of kosher-friendly items that are easy to spot once you know what to look for. Read More.

Top 16 Trending Sam’s Club Items for July

July’s lineup at Sam’s Club is looking really good right now. From fun summer treats to handy finds for your kitchen, there’s a little something for everyone. Read More.

13 Sam’s Club Home Dupes That Look Just Like the Designer Versions

Looking for stylish home decor that mirrors designer pieces without the high price tag? Sam’s Club offers a variety of home dupes that look just like the designer versions, giving your space a sophisticated and modern touch. Read More.