We Ranked 10 Peanut Butter Brands from Worst to Best (Here’s the Winner)

Peanut butter is a staple in many households, but not all brands are created equal. Some are packed with unnecessary sugars and oils, while others let the rich, roasted peanut flavor shine. With so many options on the market, it can be tough to know which one is worth spreading on your toast. We ranked ten popular peanut butter brands from worst to best based on taste, texture, and ingredients.

10. Great Value Peanut Butter

Great Value might be budget-friendly, but it does not deliver on taste or texture. It has an artificial sweetness that overpowers the peanut flavor, making it taste more like a peanut-flavored spread than real peanut butter. The texture is overly thick and somewhat chalky, which makes spreading a struggle. It also contains a long list of additives and hydrogenated oils, which take away from the natural goodness of peanuts. If you are looking for peanut butter that actually tastes like peanuts, this one falls short.

9. Kroger Peanut Butter

Kroger’s store-brand peanut butter is another option that leaves a lot to be desired. The peanut flavor is weak, and the sugar content is high, making it taste more like candy than a nut spread. It spreads well, but it has an odd aftertaste that is hard to ignore. The ingredient list is filled with preservatives and hydrogenated oils, making it less appealing for those looking for a healthier choice. While it is cheap, it is not worth sacrificing quality.

8. Peter Pan Peanut Butter

Peter Pan is a nostalgic brand, but it does not stand up to the competition. It is one of the sweetest peanut butters on the market, which might be a selling point for some, but it takes away from the natural peanut taste. The texture is light and creamy, but it can feel artificial because of the added stabilizers. While it is decent for mixing into recipes, it lacks the deep, roasted peanut flavor that makes peanut butter great. It is not the worst, but there are better options out there.

7. Skippy Peanut Butter

Skippy is a classic brand that many people grew up eating, but it is far from the best. It has a smooth and creamy texture that makes it easy to spread, but it contains a lot of added sugar and oils. The peanut flavor is there, but it is mild and somewhat masked by the sweetness. It is a decent option for those who love a classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich, but it does not compare to more natural peanut butters. If you want something with fewer additives, you might want to look elsewhere.

6. Jif Peanut Butter

Jif is another childhood favorite, but it is not as great as you might remember. It has a thick and creamy texture that makes it easy to spread, but the flavor is slightly too sweet and processed. The added sugars and hydrogenated oils make it less appealing for those looking for a pure peanut taste. While it is a reliable option that is widely available, it does not stand out in terms of flavor. If you are looking for something more natural, there are better choices.

5. Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter

Justin’s is a popular brand among health-conscious consumers, and it has a lot going for it. The ingredients are simple, with just peanuts and a little bit of oil, which makes for a more natural taste. However, the texture can be inconsistent, sometimes feeling dry or too thick. The flavor is strong and peanut-forward, but it is not as smooth or spreadable as some other brands. It is a good option if you want a more natural peanut butter, but it is not quite the best.

4. Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter

Smucker’s Natural is a step up from traditional peanut butters because it contains only peanuts and salt. The peanut flavor is rich and deep, making it a favorite for those who love a more natural spread. The downside is that it requires stirring, as the oils separate, which can be inconvenient. However, the taste and texture make up for the extra effort. If you are looking for peanut butter without all the unnecessary additives, this is a great choice.

3. Maranatha Peanut Butter

Maranatha is a premium peanut butter brand that delivers on both taste and texture. It has a smooth and creamy consistency, with a rich peanut flavor that is not overpowered by sugar. The ingredient list is clean, with minimal additives, making it a great option for those looking for a healthier spread. It is slightly more expensive than other brands, but the quality justifies the price. If you want a peanut butter that tastes fresh and natural, Maranatha is an excellent choice.

2. Teddie’s All Natural Peanut Butter

Teddie’s is a favorite among peanut butter lovers who appreciate a natural, no-frills product. It contains only peanuts and salt, which results in a bold, roasted peanut flavor that stands out from the rest. The texture is thick but spreadable, and it has a satisfying crunch if you choose the crunchy variety. Unlike other brands, it does not have an overly oily consistency, making it easier to mix and spread. If you love peanut butter that tastes like it came straight from a peanut roaster, this one is a winner.

1. Adams Peanut Butter

Adams takes the top spot for its pure peanut flavor and high-quality ingredients. Made with only peanuts and salt, it has a rich and deep roasted taste that is unmatched by other brands. The texture is thick and slightly grainy, making it feel more like homemade peanut butter than a processed spread. It does require stirring, but the effort is worth it for the clean, natural taste. If you want the best peanut butter that delivers on both flavor and quality, Adams is the clear winner.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

12 Aldi-Brand Products That Are Totally Worth Every Penny

Aldi has built a reputation for offering high-quality products at unbeatable prices, and some of their store-brand items are just as good if not better than big-name brands. Read More.

15 Budget-Friendly Target Finds That Look and Feel Expensive

Finding budget-friendly home and lifestyle items that look high-end can feel like a challenge, but Target makes it easier than ever. You can achieve a luxurious aesthetic with the right picks without spending a fortune. Read More.

Costco Prices Are Climbing (These 10 Items Have Gotten Way More Expensive)

Costco has long been known for its unbeatable prices, but even they are not immune to inflation. Over the past few years, shoppers have noticed that some of their favorite bulk buys have gotten significantly more expensive. Read More.