15 Trader Joe’s Nut Butter, Ranked from Worst to Best

Trader Joe’s has a wide variety of nut butters, but not all of them are created equal. Some are rich and flavorful, while others fall flat or have tricky textures that make them hard to enjoy. This list takes into account flavor, texture, versatility, and overall enjoyment. Salted or unsalted, crunchy or creamy, there is a nut butter for every preference—but some clearly stand out as winners. If you have ever wondered which jar is worth grabbing, this guide will help you find your perfect spread.

15. Organic Creamy Peanut Butter No Salt

This peanut butter is as basic as it gets, and that is not necessarily a good thing. Without any salt, it lacks depth, making it taste more like a simple peanut paste rather than a balanced spread. The texture is incredibly drippy, meaning it separates quickly and requires a lot of stirring before use. While it is a good option for those who want the purest peanut taste, it can feel a bit underwhelming compared to more flavorful options. It works well in smoothies or baking where you can add your own salt, but as a standalone spread, it just does not hit the mark. Many people find themselves reaching for the salted version instead. Overall, this one ranks at the bottom simply because it is too plain.

14. Sunflower Seed Spread

This is a great nut-free alternative, but it is definitely an acquired taste. Sunflower seeds have a strong, slightly bitter, and earthy flavor, which does not appeal to everyone. The texture is a little pasty, making it harder to spread evenly compared to traditional nut butters. It works well when paired with honey or jam to cut through the earthiness, but on its own, it can be overpowering. Some people love its unique taste, but for those used to peanut or almond butter, this one might not be a satisfying substitute. It does have a good amount of natural protein, which is a plus, but the flavor and texture keep it from ranking higher. If you need a nut-free spread, it is decent, but otherwise, it is not a go-to choice.

13. Organic Creamy Peanut Butter Salted

This version is an improvement over the unsalted one, but it still has its issues. The salt enhances the peanut flavor, making it more enjoyable, but the texture remains a problem. It is very drippy and separates quickly, requiring constant stirring to keep it usable. Some people appreciate the natural, minimally processed taste, but others might find it too runny compared to more conventional peanut butters. It is great for making peanut sauces or adding to oatmeal, but it is not the best for spreading on bread without a mess. While the taste is solid, the consistency makes it less convenient than other options. If you do not mind a little extra stirring, it is a decent choice, but not the best.

12. Raw Almond Butter Creamy

Raw almond butter is a love-it-or-hate-it kind of product. Since it is not roasted, the flavor is much milder and slightly earthy compared to its roasted counterpart. The texture tends to be a little grainy, which can make spreading a bit tricky. It is great for adding to smoothies or mixing into yogurt, but as a standalone spread, it feels like it is missing something. Many people prefer the richer, more toasty flavor of roasted almond butter, which is why this one ranks lower. If you love a pure, unprocessed taste, you might enjoy it, but it is not for everyone. It is a good base for homemade flavored almond butters, but it is not the most exciting on its own.

11. Creamy Almond Butter No Salt

Almond butter is naturally rich and nutty, but without salt, it falls a little flat. The texture is smooth and creamy, making it easy to spread, but the flavor can feel one-dimensional. It works well in recipes where you control the salt, but as a spread on its own, it lacks the depth that a little seasoning would provide. It is a good choice for those looking for a simple, no-additive nut butter, but it does not stand out among Trader Joe’s many options. The natural sweetness of almonds does help, but it still feels a little bland compared to its salted version. If you are eating it with fruit or honey, it can be more enjoyable, but on its own, it is underwhelming. A little salt would make all the difference.

10. Crunchy Almond Butter No Salt

Crunchy almond butter is always a nice option for those who prefer texture, but the lack of salt makes this one less exciting. The crunch gives it a more enjoyable bite, making it slightly better than the creamy no-salt version. However, the flavor still feels like it is missing something. It is good for mixing into oatmeal or smoothies, but as a standalone spread, it does not have much appeal. The almonds provide a natural sweetness, but the salt-free formula keeps it from feeling as indulgent as other options. Some people enjoy the pure almond flavor, but others will likely find it a bit plain. It is decent, but not Trader Joe’s best.

9. Creamy Peanut Butter Unsalted

This is a solid peanut butter with a smooth texture, but without salt, it lacks the bold peanut taste most people expect. It has a natural sweetness that works well in some recipes, but as a spread, it is a little bland. The texture is smooth and spreadable, making it easy to use, but it still requires stirring since it separates over time. It is a good choice for those looking for a very simple peanut butter with no additives. However, for peanut butter lovers who enjoy a stronger, well-rounded flavor, this one might not be satisfying. It is best when paired with something sweet or salty to give it more balance. Overall, it is a decent but slightly boring option.

8. Crunchy Peanut Butter Unsalted

Crunchy peanut butter fans will appreciate the extra texture in this version, which makes it more enjoyable than the creamy unsalted one. However, the same issue remains—the lack of salt leaves the peanut flavor feeling a little flat. The peanut pieces add a satisfying crunch, making it a better choice than its smoother counterpart. It is great for adding to oatmeal or using in peanut sauces, but it is not the most exciting for spreading on toast. Like the other unsalted options, it is best when paired with something sweet or savory. If you love a natural peanut taste, this one is fine, but there are better options. A little salt would take it to the next level.

7. Creamy No Stir Peanut Butter Spread

This peanut butter’s biggest advantage is its convenience. Unlike natural peanut butters that separate and require stirring, this one has added oils that keep it smooth and spreadable. It has a slightly sweeter taste compared to pure peanut butters, which some people love while others might find too processed. It is great for sandwiches, baking, or just eating by the spoonful. However, since it contains added ingredients, it is not as pure as Trader Joe’s more natural options. It is a good middle-ground choice for those who want peanut butter without the hassle of stirring. If you do not mind the added oils, it is a solid option.

6. Peanut Butter with Honey

The addition of honey makes this peanut butter stand out in the best way. It adds a mild sweetness that balances beautifully with the rich peanut flavor. It is smooth, creamy, and perfect for spreading on toast or drizzling over oatmeal. The natural sweetness makes it a great choice for kids or anyone who prefers a hint of extra flavor. Some might find it too sweet for savory uses, but it works well for most typical peanut butter applications. It is not overpowering, but the honey makes it a bit more indulgent. A great choice if you like a touch of sweetness in your peanut butter.

5. Creamy Almond Butter Salted

This is where almond butter starts to shine. The salt enhances the natural sweetness of the almonds, making the flavor much more balanced and satisfying. It has a smooth, spreadable texture that works well on toast, fruit, or even by the spoonful. Unlike the no-salt version, this one feels complete, with just the right amount of seasoning to bring out the almond’s rich, nutty taste. It is also great for adding to smoothies, oatmeal, or baking, making it one of the most versatile options. The consistency is slightly runnier than peanut butter, but that is normal for almond butter. Overall, it is a delicious and reliable pick for almond butter lovers.

4. Crunchy Almond Butter Salted

If you love a little crunch in your nut butter, this is one of the best choices at Trader Joe’s. The roasted almond pieces add texture, making it more enjoyable than the creamy version. The salt enhances the deep, toasty flavor of the almonds, creating a perfect balance of richness and crunch. It spreads well but still has that satisfying bite, making it great for sandwiches, toast, or eating straight from the jar. The natural oil separation is minimal, so it does not require as much stirring as some other almond butters. This is a go-to choice for those who want a hearty, flavorful almond butter with some texture. If you are a fan of crunchy nut butters, this one is a must-try.

3. Crunchy Peanut Butter Salted

This is a classic peanut butter with the perfect amount of crunch. The roasted peanut pieces add a great texture, making every bite more satisfying. The salt is just right, enhancing the peanut flavor without being overpowering. It is one of the best options for peanut butter lovers who enjoy a more textured experience. Whether you are using it for sandwiches, baking, or snacking, it never disappoints. It spreads well and has a balanced, rich taste that makes it stand out. This is the kind of peanut butter that feels like a treat every time you eat it.

2. Creamy Peanut Butter Salted

For those who prefer smooth peanut butter, this is Trader Joe’s best option. The texture is velvety and spreadable, making it ideal for sandwiches, dipping, or baking. The salt brings out the deep, nutty flavor, making it taste just right without being too salty. Unlike some of the more natural peanut butters, this one does not separate as quickly, which makes it more convenient. It has a rich, roasted peanut taste that feels indulgent but still simple and classic. If you love peanut butter and want the best all-around option, this one is hard to beat. It is everything a peanut butter should be—smooth, flavorful, and perfectly balanced.

1. Cocoa Almond Spread

This is hands down the most indulgent and exciting nut butter Trader Joe’s has to offer. It is like Nutella, but with a stronger almond presence, making it a perfect blend of nuttiness and chocolate. The texture is smooth and creamy, spreading easily on toast, fruit, or anything that could use a little extra decadence. The cocoa flavor is rich without being too overpowering, allowing the almond flavor to shine through. It has just the right amount of sweetness to make it feel like a treat without being overly sugary. Whether you eat it with a spoon or use it as a dip, it is impossible to go wrong with this one. If you want a nut butter that feels like dessert but still has a nutty balance, this is the ultimate pick.

This article originally appeared on RetailShout.

More From RetailShout

Target’s 15 Hair Rollers That Deliver Instant Volume Effortlessly

Target has become the go-to destination for beauty enthusiasts looking for affordable, high-quality tools. Among their standout products are hair rollers that make achieving instant volume a breeze. Read More.

Top 15 Appliance and Gadget Deals to Grab at Costco This January

Costco is kicking off the new year with some incredible deals on top appliances and gadgets that are perfect for upgrading your home. Whether you are looking to simplify your cooking routine, improve your living space, or enjoy the latest tech, Costco has you covered. Read More.

11 Costco Valentine’s Day Gifts You’ll Want to Grab Before They’re Gone

Valentine’s Day is the perfect time to show your love and appreciation with a thoughtful gift, and Costco has an incredible selection to choose from. Whether you are shopping for your partner, a family member, or even a friend, their variety of festive items makes it easy to find something special. Read More.